Gimlet
30 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/melbourne30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 13 threads.
What people say, in short
Gimlet is among the most-named places whenever Melbourne diners are asked for fine dining, and most commenters recommend it. Three diners praise the food, two of them also the service, and one singles out the T-bone while two mention the late-night cheeseburger. Four commenters suggest it for dates or a partner night out. One advises booking ahead. It does divide opinion: two diners call it overhyped or overrated and find the food underwhelming, though some still like the drinks or atmosphere, and one had a poor visit with a burger served cold inside.
Address
Gimlet, 33 Russell St, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- T bone, Cheeseburger
- Best for
- Dates
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Gimlet, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Bananayello in r/melbourne · Jan 2024
Says they have heard it is nice, offered as a suggestion for a proposal dinner.
- Recommendsu/Alternative-Camel-98 in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Named Gimlet as a suggestion in reply to the request.
- Recommendsu/lamingtonsandtea in r/melbourne · Dec 2024
Suggests Gimlet as a good option for the date.
- Recommendsu/bobsuruncle77 in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Said Gimlet seems a close match for what the asker wants, and linked its menu.
- Recommendsu/Ciraan in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Lists this among their favourite places in reply to the question.
- Recommendsu/azabob in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Picks Gimlet as their top choice in reply to the question.
- Recommendsu/polichick80 in r/melbourne · Jul 2024
Agrees with the earlier Gimlet suggestion.
- Recommendsu/Mish-mash-ing in r/melbourne · Jan 2025
Named as the top pick and advises booking ahead.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/ArcadianPilot in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Praised Gimlet strongly, without describing its food or setting.
- Recommendsu/Present-Librarian-89 in r/melbourne · Nov 2026
Calls Gimlet excellent, though a reservation may be hard to get.
- Recommendsu/mixturedd in r/melbourne · Oct 2024
Names Gimlet as a pick without further comment.
- Recommendsu/Snegsy in r/melbourne · May 2024
Endorses Gimlet, saying it handles fine dining well, with great food and seasoned service staff.
- Recommendsu/20shepherd01 in r/melbourne · Nov 2023
Seconds Gimlet and says they have been wanting to go late for its cheeseburger.
- Recommendsu/deanosaurus9 in r/melbourne · Nov 2026
Was skeptical given the hype, but found food and service truly excellent; costly, though.
- Recommendsu/Enough_Survey_9404 in r/melbourne · Nov 2026
Says they liked Gimlet.
- Recommendsu/xlr8_87 in r/melbourne · Jan 2025
Listed as a suggestion in a short list of options.
- Recommendsu/Autistic_Bean_1998 in r/melbourne · Jan 2025
Repeats Gimlet as the suggestion, pointing back to earlier mentions.
- Recommendsu/rontricks in r/melbourne · Dec 2024
Suggests Gimlet.
- Recommendsu/zerrett_7 in r/melbourne · Dec 2024taste
Suggests Gimlet, specifically its T-bone.
- Mixedu/FewerPosts in r/melbourne · Nov 2024
Mixed view: thinks Gimlet's food is underwhelming, but its atmosphere impressed them.
- Caveatu/n00bert81 in r/melbourne · Jul 2024
Calls Gimlet overhyped, though its drinks are nice.
- Recommendsu/NoDegree3291 in r/melbourne · May 2026
Lists it among recommended options.
- Recommendsu/cuddlepot in r/melbourne · Jun 2025
Lists Gimlet as a suggestion, without further detail.
- Caveatu/capsicumnugget in r/melbourne · Jan 2025taste
Had a poor visit where the burger was served cold inside, and they found it unpleasant.
- Recommendsu/PhysicalAd7116 in r/melbourne · Dec 2024
Suggests Gimlet.
- Recommendsu/Ok_Appointment_3195 in r/melbourne · Dec 2024
Suggests Gimlet.
- Recommendsu/muuuu in r/melbourne · Dec 2024
Suggests Gimlet.
- Mixedu/mullumbimbo89 in r/melbourne · Jul 2024taste
Calls Gimlet nice, but its food is solid rather than exciting or innovative.
- Recommendsu/thhd9 in r/melbourne · Jul 2024
Lists it as a top-notch option for taking a partner out.
- Recommendsu/mattel-inc in r/melbourne · May 2024
Includes it in a bulleted list of suggested options.
Also on
Gimlet is on other maps too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Melbourne, Australia
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.