The Gibney, Cottesloe

Includes Gibney among upmarket dinner suggestions, while warning the information may be dated.

Would skip Gibney, since a group of teenagers there would spoil the mood.

Visited Gibney recently and found it below the expectations its recommendations set.

Names it as their likely recommendation among true fine-dining options.

Picks The Gibney as the clear best choice over the other options.

Recommends this upmarket Cottesloe European restaurant, praising its beachfront outlook.

Fully endorses Gibney; simply being there feels like a celebration.

Thought The Gibney was outstanding and would pick it over two other options.

Says Gibney is style over substance; its food is average and seafood arrived lukewarm.

Calls The Gibney top tier, with standout tartare, strong food, cocktails and wine.

Calls it a personal favourite that's expensive for what's served but accepted given its Cottesloe setting.

Lists it among personal favourites.

Agrees Gibney is top notch and says it is where they would go.

Agrees with the Gibney suggestion.

Has not eaten there yet, but reports it's well regarded and it looks appealing.

Suggests this as a left-field pick over 6Head; says the beef menu is reasonable and the experience consistently excellent.

Recommends trying it, having come away impressed.

Suggests the bar counter as a more comfortable seat option there.

Calls Gibney really nice, with a lovely location and good food.

Lists this among options that could suit the celebration.

Agrees The Gibney is top-notch with reliably excellent food.

Gives a clear, unhedged top pick for Gibney.