Proper Order, Smithfield
34 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Dublin, r/AskIreland30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 15 threads.
What people say, in short
Proper Order is a specialty coffee shop in Smithfield that most people who name it recommend. Several call the coffee top tier, great or the best they have had in Dublin, and people praise its pastries and its beans. On the downside, one commenter says it has become too crowded and pricey, and another finds the coffee too bitter and the place too trendy.
Address
Unit 1, Proper Order Coffee Co., The Distillery Building, Smithfield, Dublin 7, D07 WDX9, Ireland
At a glance
- Best for
- Specialty coffee
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Proper Order, Smithfield, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/HikenNoSabo7 in r/Dublin · Sep 2026
Lists it among places for expertly prepared specialty coffee.
- Recommendsu/patrickfortune in r/Dublin · Jun 2025taste
Coffee is top notch with unique kinds of pastries.
- Recommendsu/Over_the_Under in r/Dublin · Mar 2026
Points out the café sits near the Smithfield stop and suggests it as an option.
- Recommendsu/Fishsticks66 in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025taste
Says it stocks well-regarded Nordic roasters' beans.
- Recommendsu/JackTheKrakenHackett in r/Dublin · Aug 2024value
Calls Proper Order the top spot in town, costly but judged worth it.
- Recommendsu/helcat0 in r/Dublin · Feb 2025taste
Says it makes really great coffee and stocks beans you won't find elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/SgtKnee in r/Dublin · Nov 2026
Lists this alongside another spot as a top coffee pick.
- Recommendsu/Open-Opinion6587 in r/Dublin · Jun 2025
Praises it as the go-to with good people and good coffee.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/SignificantThought35 in r/Dublin · Apr 2025
Gives a bare suggestion of Proper Order for coffee.
- Recommendsu/LaikSure in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Simply says Proper Order is a good bet.
- Recommendsu/ElevatorCreative158 in r/Dublin · Jun 2025taste
Calls the pastries amazing.
- Recommendsu/cedardesk in r/Dublin · Sep 2024
Lists this spot among its coffee suggestions for the city.
- Recommendsu/JPB1995 in r/Dublin · Apr 2025
Would rank this above two other spots on a short-stay coffee list.
- Recommendsu/Coconut2674 in r/Dublin · Feb 2025
Lists it among good places around Smithfield.
- Recommendsu/hydro_0 in r/Dublin · Dec 2023
Says it is great.
- Recommendsu/Expert-Thing7728 in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Ranks it among the top three for drinking out.
- Recommendsu/ElasticatedThread in r/Dublin · Nov 2026
Lists this among the coffee spots they suggest.
- Recommendsu/alexanderishere in r/Dublin · Dec 2025
Names this spot in reply to the café question, without further detail.
- Recommendsu/Stella_v17 in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Lists Proper Order among picks.
- Recommendsu/crashoutcassius in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Says they like this place.
- Recommendsu/Macken04 in r/Dublin · Apr 2025
Lists this Smithfield spot as very good.
- Recommendsu/nonoriginalname42 in r/Dublin · Feb 2025
Suggests it as the go-to Smithfield pick.
- Recommendsu/IrishHenshin in r/Dublin · Aug 2024
Agrees with the praise for Proper Order.
- Recommendsu/aintinaine in r/Dublin · Jun 2024
Names it as a good answer to the coffee question, in Smithfield.
- Recommendsu/NotPozitivePerson in r/Dublin · Jun 2024taste
Says it's pretty good for high-end coffee.
- Recommendsu/Standard_Ad_6067 in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Ranks Proper Order second.
- Recommendsu/Shot_Explorer in r/AskIreland · Oct 2025
Still ranks Proper Order first in their list.
- Recommendsu/FTHEHEDGEGME in r/Dublin · Feb 2025taste
Calls its coffee top tier and the best they've had in Dublin.
- Caveatu/rayhoughtonsgoals in r/Dublin · Aug 2024service
Dislikes the seating changes since the move and says it is now too crowded and pricey.
- Caveatu/Jane_Doughnut_ in r/Dublin · Nov 2026taste
Dislikes this trendy spot, finding its coffee too bitter.
More maps in Dublin, Ireland
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.