Tonnarello, Trastevere
24 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/rome, r/ItalyTravel30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 25 threads.
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend Tonnarello, and a couple singled out its amatriciana and a couple its carbonara. The main caveat is the crowd: some commenters describe long queues, though one says the line moves quickly, and several call it a tourist trap. One commenter finds the pasta mediocre and another the ingredients lacking, while one diner found the meal disappointing but rated the tiramisu highly.
Address
Tonnarello, V. della Paglia, 1/2/3, 00153 Roma RM, Italy
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Amatriciana, Carbonara
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Tonnarello, Trastevere, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Caveatu/Ok_Fudge8200 in r/rome · Jun 2026wait time
Says queuing at Tonnarello is pointless when a similar nearby restaurant is steps away.
- Recommendsu/f0reskinbandaid in r/rome · Oct 2026taste
Says one of their best meals was at this Trastevere spot, praising properly emulsified pasta sauces despite a westernized feel.
- Caveatu/martin_italia in r/rome · Jun 2025
Labels it a notorious tourist trap in Trastevere, while saying other good places there exist.
- Caveatu/undercover_rhodesian in r/rome · Mar 2024taste
Warned others off after a bad experience.
- Caveatu/Exciting-Apple-40 in r/rome · Nov 2025
Says to skip it.
- Recommendsu/Soft-Bumblebeee in r/rome · Jul 2025
Recommended as a place to eat in Trastevere, among several good restaurants the commenter names.
- Caveatu/throwawayayayay777 in r/rome · Oct 2024
Lists this among places to avoid and dismisses it strongly.
- Recommendsu/TidesTheyTurn in r/rome · Oct 2025taste
Visited as a tourist and found it overall great, with its amatriciana as their top pasta of the trip.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Mixedu/contrarian_views in r/rome · Jun 2025
Says tourists love it, noting that locals' favourites don't always suit visitors unfamiliar with Italian food.
- Caveatu/No_Bag_4342 in r/rome · Mar 2024
Agrees with the criticism and repeats a secondhand serious claim, with no firsthand account.
- Caveatu/TRFKAS in r/rome · Nov 2025
Says to skip it and calls it a tourist trap.
- Caveatu/Annual_Respect5998 in r/rome · Jul 2026wait time
Advises skipping Tonnarello because of long queues outside and TikTok-driven hype.
- Recommendsu/Humble-Noise937 in r/ItalyTravel · Jun 2025taste
Recommends Tonarello in Trastevere for delicious trattoria-style food; liked its pinse.
- Caveatu/Sebastian1678 in r/rome · Oct 2024
Agrees with the parent that these listed places are tourist traps.
- Recommendsu/awajitoka in r/rome · Mar 2024
Liked the food and had a positive time there; wants others' views on it.
- Recommendsu/toomuchkern in r/ItalyTravel · May 2025taste
Agrees, says they came for the amatriciana and rate it the best in Rome.
- Recommendsu/bevo1776 in r/ItalyTravel · Apr 2025
Rates the Trastevere spot as very good.
- Mixedu/tealsta in r/rome · Mar 2026taste
Says the meal there disappointed, but the tiramisu saved the visit and is their top tiramisu in the city.
- Recommendsu/blackdolphin12 in r/rome · Sep 2025taste
Had a great carbonara there and rated it highly, despite others calling it a tourist trap.
- Recommendsu/ash_222222 in r/ItalyTravel · May 2025taste
Calls Tonnarello fantastic, echoing others' praise.
- Recommendsu/Due_Flan_699 in r/rome · Mar 2025taste
Felt it met its reputation, loved the cacio e pepe and pesto rigatoni, but noticed many foreign visitors.
- Recommendsu/akfisherman22 in r/rome · Mar 2025
Agrees with the Tonnarello suggestion.
- Recommendsu/Cherry-Bell9292 in r/rome · Jan 2025
Lists this among spots they would recommend, noting it is widely promoted online.
- Recommendsu/Lingotes in r/ItalyTravel · Sep 2024taste
Commenter recommends Tonarello for carbonara.
- Recommendsu/xxprowerxx in r/rome · Mar 2024taste
Calls it fine overall, with good food and good portions.
- Recommendsu/jakem415 in r/rome · Sep 2025
Lists it among Trastevere spots they visited nightly and rated great.
- Recommendsu/shwiftysack in r/ItalyTravel · May 2025
Calls it their top meal in Rome, found just across a bridge in Trastevere.
- Recommendsu/redditbeforenight in r/ItalyTravel · Sep 2024taste
Enjoyed the Trastevere branch, calling the fried artichoke wonderful and getting a table in ten minutes without booking.
- Recommendsu/Educational_Tip3005 in r/rome · Jun 2026taste
Calls Tonnarello's stracetti and focaccia excellent.
- Recommendsu/studyingthepast1 in r/rome · Mar 2024
Says it ranked among their favourites on a previous Rome trip.
More maps in Rome, Italy
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 3 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.