Pizza Pilgrims
19 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/london, r/LondonFood, r/AskLondon25 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Pizza Pilgrims is recommended across London, including its Covent Garden outlet. Fans praise the flavour and value, and one suggests it for a casual group dinner. Critics report inconsistency, soggy pizza or a changed favourite that no longer tastes as good. Another finds it acceptable rather than London's best. These are chain-wide experiences, not all reports from the Covent Garden kitchen.
Address
Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden, 23 Garrick St, London WC2E 9BN, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Pizza Pilgrims, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/swansw9 in r/london · May 2025
Rates Pizza Pilgrims highly.
- Recommendsu/Poo_Poo_La_Foo in r/london · Sep 2026taste
Says the Victoria branch is good.
- Recommendsu/Ha_che in r/london · May 2025
Lists Pizza Pilgrims among their pizza recommendations.
- Recommendsu/SpicyAfrican in r/london · Jun 2024
Says you can't go wrong with Pizza Pilgrim's either.
- Recommendsu/Skirting0nTheSurface in r/london · Oct 2024
Enjoyed repeated visits with a group.
- Recommendsu/markym_uk in r/LondonFood · May 2025
Recommends Pizza Pilgrims for pizza.
- Recommendsu/traveleatsleeptravel in r/LondonFood · Oct 2025
Named as another cheap pizza chain that does really good pizza.
- Recommendsu/devtastic in r/london · May 2025
Lists Pizza Pilgrims as a handy pizza option around Covent Garden and London Bridge.
Show all 25 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Fit-Pass-2398 in r/london · May 2025
Names Pizza Pilgrims as a recommendation.
- Caveatu/Charlie-Bell in r/LondonFood · May 2025portion
Found it small, overpriced and soggy, and disappointing.
- Caveatu/ddek in r/london · Oct 2024consistency
Says it's become inconsistent with rapid expansion and trails rivals.
- Mixedu/LongyUTD in r/LondonFood · Jun 2026taste
Feels Pizza Pilgrims is okay but nowhere near London's best pizza.
- Caveatu/I_Sure_Hope_So in r/LondonFood · May 2025taste
Considers it over hyped.
- Recommendsu/Honourable_Mention5 in r/AskLondon · Sep 2026
Calls it a solid option.
- Recommendsu/ForeverAgamer91 in r/UK_Food · Jan 2026
Recommends any Pizza Pilgrims location among London pizza picks
- Recommendsu/neemarita in r/AskLondon · Sep 2026
Loves it and votes for it again.
- Recommendsu/harlequin_24 in r/LondonFood · Jun 2026price
Suggests Pizza Pilgrims as an inexpensive whole-pizza option.
- Recommendsu/MoodyMango4880 in r/LondonFood · Oct 2025ambience
Suggests it for a super casual group dinner.
- Caveatu/UnhappyScore in r/london · May 2025taste
Calls Pizza Pilgrims' pizza sloppy and poor.
- Caveatu/neroli__ in r/london · Oct 2024taste
Favourite pizza changed and tasted mediocre, apparently a cost cut.
- Recommendsu/RevolutionaryMail747 in r/london · Oct 2024value
Praises the flavour, ingredients and value.
- Recommendsu/Standard-Spite-6885 in r/AskLondon · Sep 2026
Recommends Pizza Pilgrims.
- Recommendsu/Adventurous_Site_107 in r/UK_Food · Jan 2026
Says Pizza Pilgrims is good as well
- Recommendsu/Spare-Machine6105 in r/LondonFood · Jun 2026
Suggests Pizza Pilgrims for pizza.
- Recommendsu/dommiichan in r/LondonFood · Jun 2026taste
Says Pizza Pilgrims is tasty.
More maps in London, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 9 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.