Sinclair's Oyster Bar, City Centre
21 people recommend, 16 warn against itvia r/manchester30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 23 threads.
What people say, in short
Sinclair's Oyster Bar draws praise for its large outdoor seating area and its old building, and several visitors find the pints budget-friendly for the city centre. Others say the beer itself is not good, with one patron calling the Sam Smith's beer poor. One commenter rates it worth a visit for its historical value.
Address
Sinclairs Oyster Bar, 2 Cathedral Gates, Manchester M3 1SW, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Price
- Budget
- Best for
- Budget
- Opinions divided
- Yes
- Known for
- Beer garden, Cheap pints
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Sinclair's Oyster Bar, City Centre, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Caveatu/Easterling1 in r/manchester · Mar 2026value
Won't return; pints too poor quality for five pounds though fine at three.
- Caveatu/murdermeinostia in r/manchester · Mar 2026ambience
Complains about loud music and unpleasant atmosphere for the price.
- Caveatu/star_tiger in r/manchester · Mar 2026value
Pints aren't good but were tolerated because cheap; price rise will hurt them.
- Recommendsu/SneakAttackDamage in r/manchester · Mar 2026ambience
Loves it for a pint, especially the beer garden, though loud music would cut the visit short.
- Mixedu/Acceptable_Willow276 in r/manchester · Sep 2025price
Confirms it is the place and likes its prices.
- Caveatu/hannahlemch in r/manchester · Mar 2026price
Angered by a large price jump.
- Mixedu/adam_estrella in r/manchester · Mar 2025ambience
Ranks it second, but only if a street DJ is not outside.
- Recommendsu/AcademyBorg in r/manchester · Sep 2024price
Named as a cheaper choice for drinks overall.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/IIJOSEPHXII in r/manchester · Mar 2025service
Says the Shambles Square venues would easily accommodate a group this size.
- Recommendsu/Defiant_Practice5260 in r/manchester · May 2025
Agrees it is the answer; notes its prices get press and recalls a strict no-phones rule.
- Caveatu/dave_k_17 in r/manchester · Mar 2026price
Stopped going when the price rose.
- Caveatu/soulslinger16 in r/manchester · Mar 2026taste
Disagrees the pint looks good, citing it's Sam Smiths.
- Recommendsu/Flag_nonces_fck_off in r/manchester · Mar 2026ambience
Rates it worth visiting for its historical value, noting the Yorkshire-based brewery behind it.
- Recommendsu/MrTurleWrangler in r/manchester · May 2025ambience
Calls it great and likes the large outdoor seating.
- Caveatu/QuietMoney7517 in r/manchester · Mar 2026price
Stopped going when the pint price topped two pounds fifty.
- Mixedu/SimpleManc88 in r/manchester · Mar 2026price
Was their cheap go-to for years but was shocked by the price.
- Mixedu/tacetmusic in r/manchester · Mar 2026ambience
Serves its own traditional beers in a legit ancient building.
- Recommendsu/3rd__i in r/manchester · Jan 2026
One of the nice tudor pubs near the Old Wellington.
- Recommendsu/rookie93 in r/manchester · Apr 2025price
Thinks it has the lowest pint prices in the city, based on a past visit.
- Recommendsu/ThrowRA-blahbla in r/manchester · Oct 2026value
Says it has cheap pints, a no-phones policy and cool history.
- Caveatu/PYPH2015 in r/manchester · Mar 2026value
Beer is poor; only went for cheap pints and won't return.
- Caveatu/SaltyName8341 in r/manchester · Mar 2026taste
Thinks the Sam Smith's beer served here is poor.
- Recommendsu/seandev77 in r/manchester · Apr 2025ambience
Likes this small venue, especially its beer garden, based on a past visit.
- Caveatu/OutrageousPianist332 in r/manchester · Mar 2026service
Bouncer knocked over their pint and dismissed it.
- Recommendsu/Joooooooosh in r/manchester · Mar 2026
Highlight offering the traditional pub experience.
- Recommendsu/kiwi_bob_1234 in r/manchester · Jan 2025ambience
Interior is excellent; urges a quick look inside.
- Recommendsu/Psychological-Duck13 in r/manchester · May 2026price
Suggests it as a cheap non-Spoons option.
- Caveatu/KanyeNot in r/manchester · Mar 2026value
Says it is no longer that cheap
- Recommendsu/dentalplan98 in r/manchester · Mar 2026value
Calls it the best and cheapest
- Recommendsu/Zarniwoop7 in r/manchester · Oct 2024
Calls it the go-to for a Manchester pub that has been moved.
More maps in Manchester, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.