Emmy Squared Pizza, West Midtown
18 people recommend, 2 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/Atlanta22 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people recommend Emmy Squared, a Detroit-style pizzeria with several Atlanta outlets; the map shows the West Midtown outlet, which several diners name, and a couple point to the Glenwood Park outlet. Some recommend it for Detroit-style pizza, and one calls the hot honey jalapeno pie especially good while saying the crust has come out undercooked in the middle. A couple call it overpriced, and one finds Detroit style not to their taste.
Address
Emmy Squared Pizza: West Midtown, 1009 Marietta St NW Ste a, Atlanta, GA 30318
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Detroit style pizza
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Emmy Squared Pizza, West Midtown, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/fancywinky in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Suggests this pizzeria as the answer to the square fluffy crust request
- Recommendsu/cjl1023 in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024
Says Emmy Squared West Midtown hits.
- Recommendsu/peeinherbut in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Seconds the earlier suggestion of this pizzeria
- Recommendsu/Tribat_1 in r/Atlanta · Nov 2024
Names this pizzeria, located in West Midtown, as a direct answer to the vodka pizza question.
- Recommendsu/potatoriot in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024variety
Suggests Emmy Squared for Detroit style pizza in West Midtown.
- Recommendsu/al-j- in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025taste
Says the pizza is really good
- Mixedu/Steezywild12 in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026
Notes Midtown has positive reviews, yet Detroit-style pizza isn't really to their liking.
- Recommendsu/DeadMoneyDrew in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026taste
Calls the Glenwood Park Beltline branch yummy; says its pizzas are very rich despite looking small.
Show all 22 cited comments
- Caveatu/smashkeys in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025value
Calls it overpriced bad pizza and steers people to a local shop instead
- Mixedu/petals-n-pedals in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025consistency
Complains crust is never fully cooked yet loves the hot honey jalapeño pizza
- Caveatu/DisplacedCapsFan in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025price
Dismisses it as overpriced chain pizza
- Recommendsu/LurkerRead in r/Atlanta · Mar 2024
Offers the Glenwood Park location as a pick, with no further detail.
- Recommendsu/queengoldentigress in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Reports that people at the bar named Emmy Squared among their favorites.
- Recommendsu/PersianVol in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025taste
Says probably the best Detroit style and praises their burger as well
- Recommendsu/VisualAd5213 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Recommends this place for Detroit-style pizza, calling it pretty good and worth trying.
- Recommendsu/weareallonenomatter in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025taste
Fully agrees it is a solid pie and praises a salad too
- Recommendsu/mjd459 in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024taste
Seconds Emmy Squared as the best and recommends the Colony and Caesar salad.
- Recommendsu/Big-Lion-4746 in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Recommends the west Atlanta location
- Recommendsu/shoopadoop332 in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Recommends the BeltLine location for this style of pizza
- Recommendsu/breakfastpitchblende in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Recommends the Bill Kennedy Way location, or the original spot on Marietta Street.
- Recommendsu/Delicious-Dinner3051 in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025variety
Loves the place and points out it also offers a gluten-free Detroit-style pie.
- Recommendsu/PopKoRnGenius in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025
Calls the pizzeria fantastic
More maps in Atlanta, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.