Fellini's Pizza, Buckhead
39 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/Atlanta, r/Georgia30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 14 threads.
What people say, in short
Most people who weigh in recommend Fellini's, a local pizza brand with outlets across Atlanta; the map shows the Buckhead outlet. Some people name the Buckhead, Candler Park or Howell Mill outlets. Some diners single out how much cheese the pies carry, and one says a plain cheese pie has an unusually generous amount. Some people are lukewarm and some dismiss it outright.
Address
Fellini's Pizza, 2809 Peachtree Rd, Atlanta, GA 30305
At a glance
- Best for
- Budget
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Fellini's Pizza, Buckhead, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Own-Reflection-8182 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Says quality depends on branch, and that the Buckhead and Howell Mill outposts both impress.
- Recommendsu/whirling_cynic in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026value
Admits other pizza is better, but finds the Candler Park branch a good value for the money.
- Recommendsu/ssagar186 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Thinks the Howell Mill branch ranks among the better local pizza spots, speaking from firsthand visits.
- Recommendsu/Drivo566 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026consistency
Says the Buckhead location has always been great.
- Recommendsu/Inevitable-Bend-2586 in r/Atlanta · Nov 2025value
Recommends buying their dough there, and says they include some sauce with it.
- Recommendsu/balbizza in r/Georgia · Nov 2024taste
Regularly picks Fellini's for a more American-style slice.
- Recommendsu/bplzizcool in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Calls the Candler Park location their go-to for years.
- Recommendsu/kilgoreq in r/Atlanta · Sep 2026taste
Calls Fellini's extremely cheesy, which fits what the thread is looking for.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/SellTheBridge in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Says they sometimes buy dough from this pizza place.
- Recommendsu/madig010 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Says the original Ponce location will always be their favorite.
- Recommendsu/potatoriot in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024
Lists Fellini's among pizza options near Midtown.
- Mixedu/VinnySmallsz in r/Atlanta · Apr 2025taste
Calls Fellini's the answer for a New Yorker's craving, but says it is still imperfect.
- Caveatu/AlexKintnerSwimClub in r/Atlanta · Apr 2024
Says Fellini's is bad, without giving detail.
- Recommendsu/scarletbcurls in r/Atlanta · Apr 2024
Lists Fellini's as an alternative go-to spot besides Antico.
- Recommendsu/stilldadok in r/Atlanta · Apr 2024taste
Calls the Fellini's Special a great slice and says NY places slice the same way.
- Recommendsu/FEDCBAT in r/Atlanta · Sep 2026portion
Says Fellini's loads on cheese beyond the usual spots.
- Recommendsu/Mdp2pwackerO2 in r/Atlanta · Sep 2026taste
Praises Fellini's white pizza and finds its plain cheese pie unusually cheesy.
- Recommendsu/RealName136 in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024
Recommends Fellini's off Buckhead.
- Mixedu/TraeYoungsOldestSon in r/Atlanta · Apr 2024taste
Says Fellini's calzones are okay, though the sauce is too bland.
- Recommendsu/ATLanskie in r/Atlanta · Apr 2024taste
Pushes back on the criticism, saying the pizza there is great.
- Recommendsu/Outrageous_Pay1322 in r/Atlanta · Sep 2026
Gives a short, enthusiastic endorsement of Fellini's.
- Recommendsu/snail_garden in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Defends Fellini's, telling those who dislike it off.
- Recommendsu/EyesSlammedShut in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026ambience
Misses the Candler location most, enjoying slices and beer outside.
- Recommendsu/pina_koala in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Says Fellini's Candler Park edges out Savage Pizza.
- Recommendsu/FiguringItOutAsWeGo in r/Atlanta · Mar 2024taste
Calls Fellini's great for a lunch slice and salad, though not thin enough for them.
- Recommendsu/StanFromAtl in r/Atlanta · Jun 2026ambience
Suggests Fellini's as a good option when wanting something more casual.
- Recommendsu/ucancallmevicky in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026value
Says the Sicilian pie is cheap for its size and amazing.
- Recommendsu/thatcurvychick in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026ambience
Recalls going there every Friday with friends and holds it dear.
- Caveatu/Gotsta_Win in r/Atlanta · Jun 2025taste
Says Fellini's is terrible
- Caveatu/CPG135 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Calls Fellini's crap.
More maps in Atlanta, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.