The Optimist
21 people recommendvia r/Atlanta, r/Georgia23 comments cited below
What people say, in short
The Optimist is a seafood restaurant that many diners recommend, with one regular saying it remains as good as it ever was and another calling it excellent. The bar has been a longtime go-to spot for one patron, who notes there are no TVs, so conversation is the entertainment. A couple of commenters offer mixed views: one praises the halibut but dislikes how tightly packed the tables are, and another found the shrimp appetizer disappointing though other dishes were tasty. One commenter also notes it is suitable for special occasions without being overly expensive.
Address
The Optimist, 914 Howell Ml Rd, Atlanta, GA 30318
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/mokeymurph in r/Atlanta · Jun 2026
Suggested as a place for a seafood tower.
- Recommendsu/SpiritFingersKitty in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
A favorite place not on the Michelin list.
- Recommendsu/More_Foundation21 in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Picks it as the seafood recommendation.
- Recommendsu/neminat in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026
Endorses The Optimist among the listed restaurants.
- Recommendsu/AyAySlim in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Names The Optimist as a recommendation.
- Recommendsu/hauttdawg13 in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Throws out The Optimist as a seafood spot.
- Recommendsu/Freaky_Deaky_Dutch in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026
A returning diner confirms The Optimist has held up in quality over time.
- Recommendsu/j__magical in r/Georgia · Dec 2024
Names The Optimist when asked for must-eat places in Atlanta.
Show all 23 cited comments
- Recommendsu/swats30 in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Named as a recommendation.
- Recommendsu/Green_Yonder in r/Atlanta · Jun 2026
Recommends it.
- Recommendsu/Fragrant-Ad8977 in r/Atlanta · May 2026ambience
Their go-to bar spot since 2013, no TVs so you make conversation.
- Recommendsu/ultimate_array in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Listed among their recommendations.
- Recommendsu/Antilon in r/Atlanta · Jul 2026price
Good and suitable for special occasions without breaking the budget.
- Recommendsu/TheWarDoctor in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Recommends Optimist on the Westside.
- Recommendsu/Dragonai in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Agrees it is spectacular all around.
- Mixedu/capitalGainsAdvisory in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026ambience
Praises the halibut but dislikes how crowded the tables are.
- Recommendsu/toque-de-miel in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Recommended for fancy seafood overall.
- Recommendsu/swellfie in r/Atlanta · Jun 2026taste
Came to say the same; thinks it is excellent.
- Recommendsu/richard-bucket in r/Atlanta · Jun 2026
Agrees with the parent that this is the answer.
- Recommendsu/Many_Refrigerator773 in r/Atlanta · Mar 2026
Adds it based on location near the venue.
- Mixedu/Legitimate_Honey_575 in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026taste
Shrimp appetizer was horrifically disappointing, but other things pretty tasty.
- Recommendsu/mattbasically in r/Atlanta · Jul 2025
Says the Optimist is about the only good seafood place.
- Recommendsu/Blackkidfromtheburbs in r/Georgia · Dec 2024
Says they love it.
More maps in Atlanta, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.