Show Me Pizza
23 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/austinfood26 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Show Me Pizza on South First draws recommendations for Neapolitan-style pies and vodka sauce pizza. Repeat visitors describe good experiences, while other diners report burnt crust, an unfinished pie or a thick, chewy base that disappointed them. Delivery earns specific support, with a commenter preferring it because seating is limited.
Address
Show Me Pizza, 2809 S 1st St, Austin, TX 78704
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Neapolitan style pizza, Vodka sauce pizza
- Best for
- Delivery
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Show Me Pizza, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Coujelais in r/austinfood · Mar 2026
Recommends Show Me on South 1st for Neapolitan-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/GeneralOptimal10 in r/austinfood · Feb 2026
Calls Show Me great, though based on only one visit.
- Recommendsu/ElOhEel in r/austinfood · May 2025taste
Wonders why Show Me gets little attention, ranks it among Austin's top pizzas, and rates its vodka sauce highly.
- Recommendsu/Defiant-Lettuce-8236 in r/austinfood · Sep 2025taste
Says it's really good Neapolitan pizza.
- Recommendsu/SouthAustinShakedown in r/austinfood · Mar 2025
Lists this among pizza places they like.
- Recommendsu/unauthorizedcuddles in r/austinfood · Jan 2025
Suggests Show Me Pizza as an answer to the wood-fired pizza question.
- Recommendsu/NicksTexasPickles in r/austinfood · Sep 2026
Enthusiastically suggests it.
- Recommendsu/rwwl in r/austinfood · Feb 2026consistency
Says they have eaten there many times and it has been great each visit.
Show all 26 cited comments
- Recommendsu/AngryN00dle in r/austinfood · Jan 2025taste
Praises Show me's cauliflower crust as delicious.
- Recommendsu/Broad-Row6422 in r/austinfood · Jun 2024taste
Calls Show Me very good; says parking is hard, so they walk.
- Mixedu/turkishguy in r/austinfood · Apr 2024taste
Finds the pizza delicious but seating is sparse, so delivery is their preferred option.
- Recommendsu/rum-n-ass in r/austinfood · Mar 2026
Suggests Show Me as the go-to pick for South Austin pizza.
- Recommendsu/Wormwithamustache_ in r/austinfood · May 2025
Agrees with the parent that Show Me's vodka pizza is the pick for this question.
- Caveatu/ShesFunnyThatWay in r/austinfood · Mar 2026taste
Found the crust charred and mostly gone after trimming, with a scorched bottom; not impressed.
- Recommendsu/thelittlestdog23 in r/austinfood · Sep 2025taste
Had it once and found it amazing; wants to go back.
- Recommendsu/Eastern_Gazelle_1600 in r/austinfood · Nov 2024taste
Top recommendation; says its gluten-free crust stands apart from others and they eat there often.
- Recommendsu/Verrakai in r/austinfood · Jun 2024taste
Says the parent's place is extremely good but Neapolitan style, unlike Homeslice.
- Recommendsu/Emergency_Channel876 in r/austinfood · Sep 2026
Calls it a real gem, emphatically.
- Recommendsu/AtomicSancho in r/austinfood · Sep 2025taste
Recommends this spot for Neapolitan-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/Jcarter1632 in r/austinfood · Sep 2025taste
Has been enjoying Show Me lately, especially its neo-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/Individual_Land_2200 in r/austinfood · Sep 2025taste
Nearby resident tried it, loved the pizza, and found parking, seating, and the dining room hassle-free.
- Recommendsu/teknas33 in r/austinfood · Mar 2025taste
Listed among good Neapolitan-style places.
- Recommendsu/Boo_T in r/austinfood · Jan 2025taste
Says Show me pizza's cauliflower crust is excellent.
- Recommendsu/fikustree in r/austinfood · Oct 2024taste
Says its self-made cashew cheese is very good.
- Recommendsu/voodoo15 in r/austinfood · Sep 2025
Names Show Me Pizza on First Street when asked for the best pizza in town.
- Caveatu/Ops1tango5 in r/austinfood · May 2025taste
Had Show Me's pizza, found it among their worst meals, and could not finish it.
More maps in Austin, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.