Exodus Bagels, Roslindale
19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/boston24 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Exodus in Roslindale attracts strong bagel recommendations, including comparisons with New York-style bagels and praise for the balance of chew and lightness. One diner particularly likes the Eggrything bagel. Value and convenience are the caveats: a critic finds it overpriced, and supporters say a visit needs planning. Spring and summer 2026 comments describe renovation-related limits and missed breakfast sandwiches, so check the menu and ordering arrangements directly.
Address
Exodus Bagels, 2 McCraw St, Roslindale, MA 02131
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Eggrything bagel
- Best for
- Breakfast
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Exodus Bagels, Roslindale, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Pinwurm in r/boston · Nov 2024
Recommends this shop as one of three good bagel options.
- Recommendsu/hostessdonettes in r/boston · Nov 2024taste
Calls it the best middle-ground option between styles for them.
- Mixedu/DrGuyIncognitoDDS in r/boston · May 2026service
Says orders lately run from a trailer by the loading dock; pickups went fine, but advises a backup plan.
- Recommendsu/10drawkward01 in r/boston · Jun 2026
Calls the bagels excellent at the Roslindale and West Roxbury boundary.
- Recommendsu/joshhw in r/boston · Jul 2026taste
Calls Exodus top-tier with no further reasoning.
- Recommendsu/mgmstudios in r/boston · Oct 2025
Offers Exodus as the answer; the shop sits near the Roslindale and West Roxbury boundary.
- Recommendsu/Brosarioo in r/boston · Nov 2023
Gives Exodus Bagels as a top answer, with no other detail.
- Recommendsu/kay_rah in r/boston · Jul 2026taste
Says they love Exodus's bagels and have relied on them for years.
Show all 24 cited comments
- Mixedu/DerpWilson in r/boston · Oct 2025price
Finds Exodus pricey yet still considers its bagels great.
- Recommendsu/HotTaeks in r/boston · Nov 2023variety
Says Exodus carries egg bagels, but only on weekends.
- Recommendsu/LangdonAlgerPuzzles in r/boston · Jun 2026taste
Thinks Exodus is probably the top choice, praising its balance of chewy and light texture.
- Recommendsu/schorschico in r/boston · May 2026
Expresses missing the Jamaica Plain location, implying fondness for it.
- Recommendsu/cosplayshooter in r/boston · Mar 2026taste
Says this Roslindale shop comes nearest to a New York-style bagel available locally.
- Recommendsu/Choice-Ad-9180 in r/boston · Jul 2026
Calls Exodus good, but notes it needs some advance planning.
- Recommendsu/ezekielragardos in r/boston · Nov 2023taste
Says Exodus stays their favorite bagel spot despite eating NYC bagels often; egg options available on weekends.
- Recommendsu/easiepeasie in r/boston · Nov 2023
Agrees with Exodus, advises ordering early since it sells out, and says they love its Eggrything bagels.
- Mixedu/gnudle in r/boston · May 2026consistency
Says the business seems unable to get organized, though the bagels are good.
- Mixedu/Stock_Adeptness_9134 in r/boston · May 2026consistency
Misses the breakfast sandwiches and was frustrated by the renovation timeline when commenting.
- Recommendsu/axpmaluga in r/boston · Mar 2026taste
Agrees with the praise, while noting the shop is in Boston but outside the center.
- Recommendsu/spaceflower890 in r/boston · Feb 2026
Rates Exodus, in Roslindale, as excellent for anyone seeking bagels.
- Recommendsu/Crafty_Leadership775 in r/boston · Mar 2026consistency
Calls this Roslindale spot the most dependable and overall top pick lately.
- Caveatu/kirbywonderbread in r/boston · Oct 2025price
Finds Exodus overpriced and not worth the money.
- Recommendsu/No_Glass1613 in r/boston · May 2025taste
Calls Exodus in Roslindale the top bagel in greater Boston, though concedes it's far from the asker.
- Recommendsu/fakecrimesleep in r/boston · Nov 2024taste
Also names it among the closest to New York-style bagels they have had locally.
More maps in Boston, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.