Pinocchio's, Harvard Square

Calls Pinocchio's the top pick for Sicilian slices, with its location near Harvard.

Prefers Sicilian with a soft, airy crust over dense dough, and names other favorite spots.

Calls Pinocchio's the best pizza they've had and keeps returning on visits home.

Calls the spot under discussion mediocre and recommends Pinocchios a block away.

Suggests it for pizza, calling it good and not a New York-style imitation.

Calls Pinocchio good, though not a New York-style slice.

Enthusiastically praises the honey-garlic chicken slices at Pinocchio's.

Suggests it for Sicilian-style pizza.

Calls Pinocchio's in Harvard Square the best pizza nearby, though not in Boston itself.

Suggests trying it, naming it as a Cambridge option.

Says a tourist would prefer this Harvard Square spot over Picco for pizza.

Strongly dislikes the place and considers it poor.

Calls this spot's squares great, though they fall short of Chicago-style deep dish.

Says Pinocchio's is much better than the Harvard Square Joe's.

Gives Pinochios as a direct answer to the jumbo slice question.

Replies that it is still open and as good as ever.

Answers the question by naming Pinocchio's in Cambridge, also called Noch's.

Goes for the Sicilian but also likes the round; never disappointed.

Judges Pinocchio's clearly worse than Joe's in a blunt comparison.

Says the linked Harvard Square place looks only okay; dislikes slice shops with many toppings.

Calls it good but heavy, indulgent and somewhat greasy.

Names Pinocchio's in Cambridge as another spot for Sicilian pizza.