Pleasant Cafe, Roslindale

Regular who says staff make them feel welcomed; calls the old-school, no-frills pizza delightful.

Recommends this Roslindale cafe as a dependable pizza pick.

Recommends Pleasant Cafe in Roslindale with a specific order: more cheese and well done.

Hype-style claim that this is Boston's best pizza.

Says the pizza has declined and is well below its earlier quality.

Names Pleasant Cafe in Roslindale as the answer and explains how to reach it by bus.

Likes the cafe, but its crust is chewier and breadier than the crisp, flaky style of bar pizza.

Warned others off after a bad experience.

Agrees it's very mediocre, perhaps only decent on the best days.

Says they love the place, citing friendly people and good food.

Uses a pun nickname; says newcomers get cold treatment there, yet they still ordered takeout.

Calls the pizza great and says the interior appeared in a well-known film.

Says this Roslindale spot's pizza is excellent, responding to the parent's mention.

Recommends it mainly for its retro feel rather than the pizza itself.

A friend loves it, but they found it totally mid on a visit and admits pretending to like it.

Says the pizza is horrible and can't understand why the wife's family orders it.

Says this spot is the real deal.

Says they are fed up with pleasant cafe and asks which West Roxbury spot the other poster used.

Heard it makes top anchovy pizza and plans to go for lunch.

Describes it as a regular spot with inconsistent results.

Likes the cafe a lot but says its pizza is not the South Shore bar style.

Doesn't think it's the best; people come for the old-school vibe and cheap cocktails, not the food.