Neptune Oyster, North End
53 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/boston, r/CambridgeMA, r/massachusetts30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 47 threads.
What people say, in short
Neptune Oyster in the North End is a small, busy oyster bar that many diners name first for oysters and lobster rolls, and several call it the best seafood in the city outright. One diner says the raw clams, oysters and fried clams are great but the chowder is badly made. Diners describe a line at peak times and no reservations, and some advise going at off-hours. Some diners flag it as expensive, one calls it overhyped, and one ranks it as their least favorite among the places they tried.
Address
Neptune Oyster, 63 Salem St APT 1, Boston, MA 02113
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Oysters, Lobster roll
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Neptune Oyster, North End, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/HouseOfBamboo2 in r/boston · Apr 2024taste
Listed as a top pick for oysters.
- Recommendsu/yaelshammer in r/boston · Mar 2026
Also lists Neptune Oyster as a strong seafood pick.
- Recommendsu/RPA1969 in r/boston · May 2026
Recommends Neptune for oysters, suggests going off-hours and trying the lobster roll.
- Recommendsu/Chapter_Complete in r/boston · May 2026taste
Calls Neptune amazing, a close second for oysters.
- Recommendsu/Paul_M_C in r/boston · May 2026
Says Neptune is clearly the best oyster answer in the city.
- Recommendsu/2phatt in r/boston · Jun 2026taste
One diner says Neptune Oyster beats Union Oyster.
- Recommendsu/SaltandLillacs in r/boston · Jul 2025
Recommends Neptune's oysters.
- Recommendsu/Pinwurm in r/boston · Jan 2024
Called a luxury lobster roll choice, though the commenter says it is very hard to get into.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/JMD331 in r/boston · May 2024
Recommends it, noting a likely queue but judging it worth the visit.
- Recommendsu/mpjjpm in r/boston · Jun 2025taste
Says the food is strong and prefers Neptune because its hot buttered lobster roll beats mayo-based versions for them.
- Recommendsu/suzmckooz in r/boston · Apr 2025taste
Praises Neptune's oysters and lobster rolls and says the whole menu is strong, based on repeat visits.
- Mixedu/witchy12 in r/boston · May 2026wait time
A visitor finds the oysters good but notes the small space draws huge peak-time lines.
- Mixedu/SgtStupendous in r/CambridgeMA · May 2025taste
Says Neptune's raw clams, oysters and fried clams are great, but its chowder is badly made.
- Recommendsu/ReturnofTeamRegime in r/boston · Sep 2026
Names Neptune as a favorite seafood restaurant.
- Caveatu/Illustrious-Hair-524 in r/boston · Jun 2025taste
Ranked this as their least favorite by a wide margin.
- Recommendsu/Purple_Lavishness225 in r/boston · Sep 2025
Names Neptune Oyster as its answer to the lobster roll question, with no further detail given.
- Recommendsu/handleinthedark in r/boston · Apr 2025taste
Says Neptune is strong for seafood in general, though it takes no reservations and is cramped, so arrive early.
- Recommendsu/RogueInteger in r/boston · Sep 2025
Named as a local favorite for a treat.
- Recommendsu/hostessdonettes in r/boston · Jul 2025taste
Names Neptune as the pick if pure food quality matters more.
- Recommendsu/bostongreens in r/boston · Aug 2026wait time
Names Neptune as the only rival to the best lobster roll, with a long wait in line.
- Recommendsu/ihatepostingonblogs in r/massachusetts · Jun 2026
Calls it the only correct answer for the North End.
- Recommendsu/oby100 in r/boston · Mar 2026taste
Calls Neptune Oyster the top roll in the city; defends it against frozen-lobster talk.
- Recommendsu/THINKFR33LY in r/boston · Apr 2024
Agrees with a list that put Neptune among the top oyster picks.
- Recommendsu/Abydosprime in r/boston · May 2026taste
One diner gives Neptune Oyster an emphatic endorsement as the best choice.
- Recommendsu/willzyx01 in r/boston · Sep 2025price
Names Neptune Oyster as its pick but flags that it is expensive.
- Recommendsu/Thatguyyoupassby in r/boston · May 2025
Recommends Neptune as the alternative to Saltie Girl.
- Recommendsu/Santillana810 in r/boston · Apr 2025taste
Praises Neptune's lobster rolls but notes they are not sold to go.
- Recommendsu/RunsWith_Pandas in r/boston · Apr 2024taste
Strongly endorses Neptune Oyster as the best choice.
- Recommendsu/jaritadaubenspeck in r/boston · Apr 2024taste
Gives an emphatic top pick.
- Caveatu/conteins in r/boston · May 2026
Calls Neptune overhyped.
More maps in Boston, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.