Saltie Girl, Newbury Street
30 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/boston30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 24 threads.
What people say, in short
Saltie Girl is a Newbury Street seafood spot that many diners recommend, with several praising its lobster roll and some singling out its tinned fish. Opinion on the clam chowder is split: some diners vote for it, while others find it too bacony or more like bechamel with clams. Several people call it pricey, and some find it overhyped or say it has slipped.
Address
Saltie Girl, 279 Dartmouth St, Boston, MA 02116
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Lobster roll, Tinned fish
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Saltie Girl, Newbury Street, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Chapter_Complete in r/boston · May 2026taste
Says Saltie Girl is amazing for oysters and has the best lobster roll.
- Caveatu/Grainger407 in r/boston · Apr 2026taste
Calls it overrated and not good.
- Caveatu/AppropriatePaper4401 in r/boston · May 2026
Says Saltie Girl on Newbury is popular with some, but feels it is somewhat overhyped.
- Recommendsu/miraj31415 in r/boston · Jul 2026taste
Lists Saltie Girl as a place for fried clams and clam chowder.
- Recommendsu/purplecouchthrowaway in r/boston · May 2025taste
Suggests it as an attractive spot with good seafood, while noting it is expensive.
- Recommendsu/bloppyploppy in r/boston · Sep 2024taste
Says their lobster roll tasted very good, though it costs much more than another spot's.
- Recommendsu/Illustrious-Hair-524 in r/boston · Jun 2025taste
Says it's their favorite despite finding it pricey, after trying many spots.
- Recommendsu/pollogary in r/boston · Jun 2025taste
Says they love this place's version of the roll.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Caveatu/Lord_Kittensworth in r/boston · Apr 2026taste
Calls it overrated for serving tinned fish and advises visitors against eating canned fish there.
- Mixedu/cane_stanco in r/boston · Sep 2024
Says the place was better in its earlier smaller space; credits it for early tinned-fish focus.
- Recommendsu/dstator00 in r/boston · Jan 2024taste
Named as the pick for a hot lobster roll.
- Recommendsu/rayray3417 in r/boston · Mar 2026
Suggests trying Saltie Girl in Back Bay.
- Recommendsu/Boisemeateater in r/boston · Aug 2025taste
Names Saltie Girl's warm-butter roll as its top lobster roll pick.
- Caveatu/AppleiFoam in r/boston · Sep 2024price
Argues the menu prices outrun the food quality, including canned seafood priced like fresh.
- Recommendsu/Cute-Fun3025 in r/boston · Jul 2026ambience
Recommends Saltie Girl for its vibes.
- Caveatu/the_coolhand in r/boston · Apr 2026consistency
Says the last few chowders were just bechamel with clams.
- Recommendsu/pattysal in r/boston · Apr 2026variety
Notes a wide oyster selection and obscure canned seafood, plus pricey but tasty creative options.
- Recommendsu/jtet93 in r/boston · Aug 2025taste
Says the tinned fish here is excellent, though the rest of their food didn't appeal to them.
- Caveatu/Thatguyyoupassby in r/boston · May 2025consistency
Says Saltie Girl was great before expanding, but quality dropped sharply after it grew.
- Recommendsu/sacrebleuballs in r/boston · Apr 2024taste
Says they tried its roll after moving to Boston and judged the quality clearly above Yankee Lobster's.
- Caveatu/Physical-Program1030 in r/boston · Apr 2026taste
Finds the chowder too bacony, comparing it to loaded baked potato soup rather than clam chowder.
- Recommendsu/mark_mac21 in r/boston · Apr 2026
Puts in a vote for the chowder at Salty Girl on Newbury Street.
- Caveatu/Pinwurm in r/boston · Apr 2026
Calls it overrated for seafood and points to other oyster bars instead.
- Recommendsu/bluewhale0610 in r/boston · Apr 2026taste
Tried its lobster roll and found it incredible, preferring it to Sail Loft's.
- Mixedu/itsonlyastrongbuzz in r/boston · Nov 2025variety
Says the scallop crudo was dropped from the menu, a disappointment, though other dishes still impress.
- Recommendsu/Wrateman in r/boston · Sep 2025
Lists Saltie Girl among the solid options for lunch.
- Recommendsu/phdecoder in r/boston · Aug 2025taste
Counts Saltie Girl among its favorites, a solid upscale choice.
- Recommendsu/Kyliewoo123 in r/boston · Jun 2024taste
Calls it great seafood without naming a specific dish.
- Recommendsu/arisk2002 in r/boston · Apr 2024
Names this as a top pick.
- Recommendsu/HirtzCompass in r/boston · Apr 2024taste
Agrees with the Saltie Girl pick.
More maps in Boston, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.