Bucktown Pizza
17 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/chicagofood21 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Bucktown Pizza draws praise for East Coast-style slices and a crisp crust. The garlic white pie and three-sauce slice have specific fans. Opinions are not unanimous: diners also find it merely decent, too reheated or not worth the slice price, while other customers consider the portions good value.
Address
Bucktown Pizza, 1912 N Western Ave, Chicago, IL 60647
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Garlic white pie, Three sauce slice, Sausage slice
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Bucktown Pizza, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/idkwhattowriteee in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Praises the crisp-yet-foldable crust and enjoyed both cheese and three-sauce slices.
- Recommendsu/randomUsername1569 in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Calls it their new favorite NYC/Jersey style pizza spot.
- Recommendsu/Busy-Dig8619 in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Says slices have good crunch, sweeter sauce, good cheese; white pizza was legit.
- Recommendsu/EntertainmentFew7103 in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Says place is really good with crisp crust, not greasy.
- Recommendsu/adhprs in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Particularly praises the garlic white pie.
- Recommendsu/wine-n-dive in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Calls it a super solid spot and enjoyed the slices.
- Recommendsu/himalyaslaya in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Praises the crust's perfect crunch and the three-sauce slice's good flavor.
- Mixedu/xelanart in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Finds the prices good but the pizza only okay, and prefers Pizza Matta at a similar price.
Show all 21 cited comments
- Recommendsu/alamayn in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026value
Thought slices were big and worth it; all tasty.
- Mixedu/greengasman in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026value
Calls the slices good and a nice neighborhood addition, but not the best.
- Recommendsu/citynomad1 in r/chicagofood · Oct 2026taste
Really liked it; prefers this style over tavern; sicilian slice great too.
- Recommendsu/Numerous-Hawk1471 in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Calls it authentic East Coast-style pizza and is a fan.
- Mixedu/TheSpaceMonkeys in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026price
Likes the pizza but does not consider a cheese slice budget-friendly.
- Recommendsu/optiplex9000 in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Loves the pizza; most slices tried have been fantastic.
- Recommendsu/CantEverDie_ in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026service
Loves the pizza shop.
- Recommendsu/EmperorNick in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Really crispy but not cracker crust; really liked it.
- Recommendsu/semdi in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Calls the slices great.
- Recommendsu/Oddly-Sym in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026taste
Calls the pizza solid.
- Recommendsu/Any_Caterpillar_4466 in r/chicagofood · Sep 2026value
Loved the pizza under its previous name and considers the slices excellent value.
- Recommendsu/Logan012356789 in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Agrees the pizza is decent.
- Caveatu/experiencedreview in r/chicagofood · Jul 2026taste
Massively disappointed; tasted reheated and less crust than photos.
More maps in Chicago, United States
- Places to visit in Chicago
- Best restaurants in Chicago
- Best steak in Chicago
- Museums in Chicago
- Best burgers in Chicago
- Best cafés in Chicago
- Best breakfast in Chicago
- Best bars in Chicago
- Best sushi in Chicago
- Best ramen in Chicago
- Indian restaurants in Chicago
- Best brunch in Chicago
- Best seafood in Chicago
- Bookstores in Chicago
- Parks in Chicago
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.