Star Pizza

Says this deep dish gives some comfort and resembles Chicago style until a trip home.

Warned others off after a bad experience.

Named as the nearest deep-dish option around.

Answers the request by saying this place makes heart-shaped pizzas around Valentine's Day.

Recommends this to a deep-dish fan, naming a specific pie order.

Names this Montrose pizzeria as an old-timer operating since the 1970s.

Warned others off after a bad experience.

Warned others off after a bad experience.

Lists it among the top places for pizza by the slice.

Says the Upper Kirby location's pizza is very good, though its cheese blend may need a special request for plain provolone.

Says this place hasn't been decent for years and was never good to them.

At the Shepherd branch, deep dish and NY-style pies were poor, though toppings were fine; one was thrown out.

Suggests adding it to the list.

Names this as a pizza suggestion in reply to the question.

Lives nearby; says the cheese is premixed but still calls it decent pizza.

Says they love it and have since childhood; last ate there roughly a decade back.

Recalls going there as a kid and remembers the food being very good.

Says they visit the Shepherd location often and suggests trying a pizza there together on another occasion.

Places its deep dish at the top of their ranking.

Recommends it.

Says it's well known but not amazing, though its ingredients are fresh and it's not a national chain.

Praises its lunch special as good value, even when it isn't a buffet.