Mulberry Street Pizzeria
16 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/LosAngeles, r/FoodLosAngeles, r/AskLosAngeles24 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Many people recommend Mulberry Street as a New York-style pizzeria, and some argue it is the best in LA. It has more than one outlet (Sherman Oaks and Beverly Hills are named) and the comments mix them; the location shown on the map is Sherman Oaks. Several say it travels poorly and is best eaten on site, and some call it mediocre or say it declined.
Address
Mulberry Street Pizzeria, 15136 Ventura Blvd, Sherman Oaks, CA 91403
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Thin New York style slice, Thin New York style pie
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Mulberry Street Pizzeria, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/donutgut in r/LosAngeles · Aug 2024taste
Says it's good and gets the hype, though prefers Pepes NY.
- Recommendsu/Castingjoy in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025taste
Praises Mulberry's thin NYC-style slices and pies, saying they're excellent.
- Recommendsu/ILoveLipGloss in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Lists the Sherman Oaks Mulberry as a recommended spot.
- Recommendsu/Lukeboozwalker in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025taste
Argues firmly that this spot serves LA's top New York-style pizza, and will defend that stance.
- Recommendsu/CodMilt in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Includes this on a master list of places they've enjoyed or trust.
- Mixedu/le_sighs in r/FoodLosAngeles · Oct 2024delivery
Likes Mulberry's but says it travels poorly, so it's a weaker pick for delivery.
- Recommendsu/Lecture_Unhappy in r/FoodLosAngeles · Dec 2023
Answers the question by naming Mulberry Street.
- Mixedu/detentionbarn in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025taste
Says it's only worth ordering a full pie, since reheated slices disappoint.
Show all 24 cited comments
- Recommendsu/edwardex in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025
Lists Mulberry among recommended spots.
- Mixedu/euthlogo in r/FoodLosAngeles · Dec 2023
Says Mulberry Street is a good slice worth it only when nearby.
- Caveatu/KnashDavis in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2026
Says it was poor on their last visit, which was years ago.
- Recommendsu/pinkiepowder in r/AskLosAngeles · Sep 2025taste
Says it comes nearest to New York-style pizza among places tried.
- Recommendsu/BiscuitPanic in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025
Agrees it's top in LA; the Beverly Hills location was authentic and strongly recommended.
- Caveatu/japandroi5742 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025consistency
Calls Mulberry Street mediocre and says quality has dropped over two decades.
- Mixedu/donorcycle in r/FoodLosAngeles · Oct 2024delivery
Agrees with the travel complaint; says Mulberry fails when eaten cold the next day, though suggests stopping by.
- Recommendsu/Annual_Ant_4289 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2024
Recommends Mulberry Street as another pick.
- Recommendsu/todd0x1 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Jul 2024
Recommends trying this place too.
- Recommendsu/Muhlyssa_A in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2026
Answers with Mulberry Street as their white pizza pick.
- Recommendsu/Zenforcer1 in r/LosAngeles · Sep 2025
Names Mulberry Street as their answer.
- Recommendsu/lapaperscissors in r/AskLosAngeles · Sep 2025taste
Agrees with the Mulberry Street suggestion above.
- Caveatu/Successful-Ground-67 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025taste
Calls Mulberry mediocre.
- Recommendsu/OTWaffle_44 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Apr 2025
Offers the Ventura Blvd Mulberry location as a pick.
- Recommendsu/jmaca90 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Calls Mulberry a good easy option for a basic slice; past visits were to a Beverly Hills branch.
- Mixedu/Fast_Dragonfruit_883 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Jul 2024delivery
Likes the sauce but says it only works if eaten on site.
More maps in Los Angeles, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.