Secret Pizza, El Sereno
23 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodLosAngeles, r/AskLosAngeles, r/LosAngeles24 comments cited below
What people say, in short
The great majority of those who mention Secret Pizza recommend it, and several call it the best New York-style pizza in LA or the top pick for the question. One commenter notes it doesn't deliver, and one found it mediocre.
Address
Secret Pizza, 3501 Monterey Rd, Los Angeles, CA 90032
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Secret Pizza, El Sereno, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Designer-Ingenuity75 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Names Secret Pizza as the answer to the question.
- Recommendsu/CapOnBrimBent in r/FoodLosAngeles · May 2026
Suggests this El Sereno spot, Secret Pizza, as a place to try.
- Recommendsu/jeffgoldblum2019 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Answers the NY-style question by naming Secret Pizza.
- Recommendsu/darrylsutter in r/FoodLosAngeles · Dec 2023
Suggests Secret Pizza as an answer to the question.
- Recommendsu/itstomthebomb in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2026
Lists Secret Pizza as a good option, ranked below Park Pizza.
- Recommendsu/cloud_busting in r/FoodLosAngeles · Oct 2025taste
Thinks this shop makes much better New York-style slices than Bub's.
- Recommendsu/Ryboflavinator in r/AskLosAngeles · Oct 2025
Names Secret Pizza as the top pick, crediting the maker's long effort.
- Recommendsu/Sasquatchgoose in r/AskLosAngeles · Jun 2026
Names it among several good LA pizza spots worth checking out.
Show all 24 cited comments
- Recommendsu/concernedcanary in r/LosAngeles · Sep 2025
Includes Secret Pizza in their list of recommended pizza spots.
- Recommendsu/SaddamMustaine in r/AskLosAngeles · Sep 2025
Calls Secret Pizza great in a list of LA pizza picks.
- Recommendsu/jetboyjetgirl in r/LosAngeles · Aug 2024taste
Thinks Secret Pizza is the best NY-style pizza in LA.
- Recommendsu/osay77 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2026
Firmly picks Secret Pizza as the top choice.
- Recommendsu/Weak_Procedure_408 in r/AskLosAngeles · Oct 2025
Endorses Secret Pizza.
- Recommendsu/LunaBeams in r/FoodLosAngeles · Dec 2023
Replies with Secret Pizza as a suggestion.
- Recommendsu/GuavaGiant in r/FoodLosAngeles · Aug 2026
Simply names Secret Pizza as the answer.
- Recommendsu/Chrindo in r/Pizza · Nov 2025value
Says they visited for the first time recently and found it good.
- Recommendsu/Loud_Palpitation_734 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Sep 2026
Lists Secret Pizza as one of their top picks.
- Recommendsu/thirdeyeopen23 in r/FoodLosAngeles · Sep 2026
Strongly picks Secret Pizza as the best option.
- Recommendsu/AndromedaDaze in r/FoodLosAngeles · Nov 2025taste
Says Secret Pizza is far better.
- Recommendsu/miffy907 in r/AskLosAngeles · Oct 2025
Names Secret Pizza as a hidden gem, with a playful tone.
- Recommendsu/aysiu in r/LosAngeles · Sep 2025
Names Secret Pizza as their answer.
- Caveatu/Substantial_One5369 in r/AskLosAngeles · Sep 2025taste
Tried Secret Pizza from the list; found it mediocre and doubts it would satisfy a New Yorker.
- Recommendsu/lindabeth in r/FoodLosAngeles · Feb 2025
Agrees that Secret Pizza is the top answer.
- Recommendsu/TomIcemanKazinski in r/FoodLosAngeles · Oct 2024taste
Says Secret Pizza is very good but doesn't deliver; unsure of its neighborhood.
More maps in Los Angeles, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.