Crieve Hall Bagel Co.
21 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/nashville26 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Many diners recommend Crieve Hall Bagel Co, and a few name it as their breakfast pick. A couple of diners single out the rosemary bagel, one praises the toasted everything schmear and customizable sandwiches, and another says the coffee and food are solid with plenty of seating on weekdays. Two diners are less convinced: one says it isn't a proper New York-style bagel, and another feels quality has slipped, citing lopsided bagels. A few diners were mixed: one found it just okay, one arrived at midday to find it sold out and suggests coming early, and one pointed to limited hours and crowds but called the bagels decent.
Address
Crieve Hall Bagel Co. - Trousdale, 4825 Trousdale Dr #228, Nashville, TN 37220
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Rosemary bagel, Toasted everything schmear
- Best for
- Breakfast
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Crieve Hall Bagel Co., as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/barricadedsuspect in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Calls Crieve Hall Bagel amazing even as a non-bagel fan.
- Recommendsu/jbourne1233 in r/nashville · Feb 2024
Recommends Crieve Hall Bagels as the place to satisfy a bagel craving.
- Mixedu/Status-Pipe-3211 in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Found Crieve Hall just okay, while preferring a different shop for New Jersey-style bagels.
- Recommendsu/sinisterbuttocks in r/nashville · Mar 2024
Names Crieve Hall Bagel as the brunch pick after Radnor Lake.
- Recommendsu/Odd_Arachnid_3981 in r/nashville · Feb 2026
Names Crieve Hall Bagel Co. as a suggestion for the breakfast question.
- Recommendsu/Fit-Shock-1469 in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Loved a rosemary bagel with sun-dried tomato cream cheese and called it great.
- Caveatu/_krisper_ in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Tried Crieve Hall and concluded it isn't a proper NY-style bagel.
- Recommendsu/Theodora1976 in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Names Crieve Hall among their favorites.
Show all 26 cited comments
- Recommendsu/SecretComparison7700 in r/nashville · Jun 2024
Says they'd drive to this Crieve Hall spot instead when in that area.
- Recommendsu/oatmealfoot in r/nashville · Jun 2025
Lists Crieve Hall Bagel as a breakfast pick, alongside H&S and Benji's.
- Recommendsu/lasermanmcgee in r/nashville · Mar 2024
Says they love this bagel shop and agrees it is a good pick.
- Recommendsu/uknowsidrum in r/nashville · Feb 2024
Agrees with the earlier pick and names Crieve for bagels.
- Recommendsu/SlowlybutShirley59 in r/nashville · Feb 2026
Says they loved the bagel shop and found the long queue part of the fun.
- Recommendsu/Grace-Music in r/nashville · Oct 2024
Strongly backs Crieve Hall's bagels as the top choice.
- Mixedu/divineshadow44 in r/nashville · Feb 2024
Visited midday and found it sold out; advises arriving early.
- Recommendsu/jmail4242 in r/nashville · Feb 2026
Names Crieve Hall Bagel Co as a breakfast suggestion.
- Recommendsu/mirimir_ in r/nashville · Feb 2026taste
Says the coffee and food are solid and seating is plentiful on weekdays.
- Recommendsu/judegray in r/nashville · Oct 2024
Lists Crieve Hall Bagel as a recommendation.
- Recommendsu/Litzz11 in r/nashville · Feb 2026taste
Says they went out of their way for warm cinnamon raisin bagels and ate them plain.
- Recommendsu/PheeNelson2469 in r/nashville · Jun 2025
Lists Crieve Hall Bagel as their breakfast pick.
- Mixedu/stugots85 in r/nashville · Oct 2024wait time
Notes limited hours and hype crowds but says bagels were decent.
- Caveatu/Life-Significance649 in r/nashville · Oct 2024consistency
Feels quality declined with lopsided bubbly bagels and cites toxic management.
- Recommendsu/trish4278 in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Loves the rosemary bagel with house-made giardiniera cream cheese.
- Recommendsu/obliviousCrane in r/nashville · Oct 2024taste
Says this shop is far ahead of other options, with a casual tone.
- Recommendsu/Lumberjack1229 in r/nashville · Feb 2024
Agrees the earlier Crieve Hall suggestion is the right pick.
- Recommendsu/spnChick in r/nashville · Oct 2024variety
Praises toasted everything schmear and build-your-own sandwich options.
Also on
Crieve Hall Bagel Co. is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Nashville, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.