5 Points Pizza, Five Points
28 people recommend, 13 warn against itvia r/nashville30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 12 threads.
What people say, in short
Many diners call Five Points Pizza the best or among the best in town, and two say it is consistently good. Several rave about its habanero cream sauce. People mention its East, West and Gulch locations, but most comments do not say which one they mean. Many find the pies pricey, a few object to an added fee, and many rate the New York-style pizza as only average, okay or worse.
Address
Five Points Pizza East, 1012 Woodland St, Nashville, TN 37206
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Habanero cream pizza, Old World
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to 5 Points Pizza, Five Points, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/partyhatsmileyface in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Great flavors and an almost perfect crust, though not as hot as hoped; would grab another after drinking nearby.
- Mixedu/jazzy_peanut_butter in r/nashville · May 2025price
OK New York-style pizza but a 14-inch supreme at this price should be the best ever, and it is not.
- Recommendsu/Smithy_T in r/nashville · Mar 2024taste
Author is highly fond of the restaurant's signature spicy cream sauce and wants to recreate it at home.
- Recommendsu/70PercentAreBots in r/nashville · May 2025taste
Thinks the price fits a dine-in restaurant and says cheaper takeout spots are all worse.
- Caveatu/svanaoi996bsjak in r/nashville · Apr 2024price
Names this spot in reply to the name-and-shame call about fee-charging places; no other opinion given.
- Caveatu/Ebl1859 in r/nashville · May 2025value
Worse pizza-per-dollar ratio than Pinky Ring for a supreme.
- Recommendsu/flightnotright in r/nashville · May 2025consistency
Pricey but nothing else comes close and it is always consistently good.
- Mixedu/Common-Scientist in r/nashville · Apr 2024price
Recalls liking this place's habanero cream pizza, but calls the added fee ridiculous on a pizza.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Mixedu/PashaCello in r/nashville · May 2025value
Only visits during happy hour for the slices; feels pie prices have climbed too far.
- Caveatu/cobaltscar in r/nashville · May 2025price
They add a convenience or boxing fee on top.
- Recommendsu/boobrandon in r/nashville · May 2025taste
Likes their vodka sauce pizza.
- Recommendsu/Safe-Ticket8448 in r/nashville · May 2026
Names Five Points Pizza as a pick.
- Recommendsu/ThisSideOfHistory in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Recommends the Old World pie; says it satisfies a northeasterner's craving.
- Recommendsu/AndrewSouthern729 in r/nashville · May 2025consistency
Says the pizza is worth the cost because it is reliably good.
- Caveatu/CorgitheClown in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Doesn't see the hype; finds it very average.
- Recommendsu/symphwind in r/nashville · May 2025taste
Opts for the larger supreme now and then, saying they really enjoy it enough to splurge occasionally.
- Mixedu/alexborowski in r/nashville · Apr 2024price
Says they were priced out of this place, but still calls its pizza great.
- Recommendsu/Wynter_born in r/nashville · Mar 2024taste
Tells readers to request the off-menu pizza with the habanero cream sauce, noting it has no macaroni.
- Recommendsu/rocketpastsix in r/nashville · May 2026
Lists this spot among local places that counter the claim that Nashville pizza is bad.
- Recommendsu/No_Instruction1696 in r/nashville · May 2026
Lists 5PP among places they enjoy.
- Recommendsu/WorkdayDistraction in r/nashville · May 2025
Says it is the top spot for grabbing a couple of slices.
- Caveatu/citylimitband in r/nashville · May 2025price
Calls it pricey, but in line with other New York-style shops, and finds these costlier than comparable spots back in NYC.
- Recommendsu/ParanoidAndrew87 in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Agrees with the parent, calling Five Points the top pizza in town.
- Recommendsu/SwampFox4 in r/nashville · Mar 2024taste
Answers the question by saying the pizza looks like mac and cheese and calls it awesome.
- Recommendsu/tnecnivx in r/nashville · Jan 2026taste
Names 5 Points as a preferred pick over NY Pie.
- Caveatu/SeaAd7934 in r/nashville · Jan 2026taste
Says 5 Points Pizza falls short for that style, compared with better versions they've eaten.
- Caveatu/nrselleh in r/nashville · May 2025consistency
Says the West location lacks warmers for takeout orders, so pizza is cold when people get home.
- Recommendsu/s_l_e_e_p_y_g_a_l in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Long-time fan of Five Points.
- Recommendsu/Big_Bottle3763 in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Calls Five Points their top pick.
- Caveatu/count_montecristo in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Calls it overrated and questions why it was ranked higher.
More maps in Nashville, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 12 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.