NY Pie, Nashville West

Says NY Pie is a solid by-the-slice option and notes a West Nashville location.

Says this pizza makes the prices being discussed feel irrelevant to them.

Feels it's the nearest to home and rates it highest for an authentic NJ/NY slice.

Recommends NY Pie.

Named among authentic NY-style shops that are expensive.

Likes NY Pie a little more than the ranking above did, and asks for it well done.

Tried NY Pie recently and liked it a lot.

Reports a friend praising NY Pie, and says their own pizza there was good.

Wishes NY Pie had a better vodka slice option, but otherwise finds it close enough.

Recommends this place's grandma pie as a standout pick.

Emphatically recommends NY Pie.

Would like a South Nashville branch and regularly grabs slices at the West Nashville location.

Calls NY Pie good but says they prefer other local spots.

Recommends the West Nashville location as a pizza pick, without further detail.

Recommends giving this spot a try as one of the pizza week picks.

Consistently disappointed by it.

Calls NY Pie's white pizza one of their all-time favorites and says the cannoli is very good too.

Says NY Pie is good, but its current special pizza seems uninspired.

Says the NY Pie praise had them sold, though they dislike another spot's ranking in the same comment.

Enthusiastically points to the west side branch and says the asker will be glad they went.

Agrees with the NY Pie thread and calls its pizza, stromboli and calzones great after ordering each many times.

Agrees NY Pie is the right pick, claiming it's the only local spot close to New York style.