Pinky Ring
18 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/nashville25 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 7 threads.
What people say, in short
Many diners recommend Pinky Ring, which is in Madison. One diner calls it the closest they found to a Jersey pie, another rates it among the good New York-style pizzas, and one praises its specialty slices. Two diners find it mid or disappointing, and one found the sauce and cheese on a plain slice underwhelming. Many call it pricey, though two say it is worth it.
Address
Pinky Ring Pizza, 414 Gallatin Pike S, Madison, TN 37115
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Specialty slices
- Opinions divided
- Yes
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Mixedu/partyhatsmileyface in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Crisp crust on a plain slice, though the sauce and cheese underwhelmed; plans to try specialty slices.
- Recommendsu/Ebl1859 in r/nashville · May 2025value
Better pizza-per-dollar and better quality than 5 Points by their math.
- Recommendsu/NiceMeet2U in r/nashville · May 2026
Names Pinky Ring as their pick.
- Recommendsu/tylerwhitlatch in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Calls Pinky Ring pretty delicious.
- Recommendsu/MacGyver387 in r/nashville · May 2026
Lists it among several good local pizza places.
- Recommendsu/Pure_Background7708 in r/nashville · May 2026
Seconds Pinky Ring as a good pick.
- Caveatu/TheSupremeHobo in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Says to ignore Pinky Ring praise, calling its pizza mediocre and a plain cheese pie overpriced.
- Caveatu/Awkward_Dimension_86 in r/nashville · Apr 2025price
Says Pinky Ring charges a lot for a plain cheese pizza.
Show all 25 cited comments
- Caveatu/Mets081234 in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Disappointed, given the strong praise elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/No_Instruction1696 in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Lists Pinky Ring among places they enjoy.
- Caveatu/citylimitband in r/nashville · May 2025price
Named among authentic NY-style shops that are expensive.
- Recommendsu/TheBigGreenPeen in r/nashville · Feb 2025
Suggests Pinky Ring as a pizza option, alongside another spot.
- Recommendsu/NashvilleDefender in r/nashville · Feb 2025taste
Lists Pinky Ring with Frankie's as a great choice in East/Madison.
- Recommendsu/Careless-Caramel-997 in r/nashville · Jul 2025
Suggests Pinky Ring Pizza for anyone nearer Madison.
- Recommendsu/s_l_e_e_p_y_g_a_l in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Calls it their favorite of the group.
- Recommendsu/MothraDidIt in r/nashville · Apr 2024taste
Urges trying it, calling it the nearest they've tasted to Jersey-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/Here-for-a-drink in r/nashville · May 2026
Names Pinky Ring as the pick.
- Recommendsu/OhNoItsDEVO81 in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Says Pinky Ring's Madison location is excellent.
- Recommendsu/jonneygee in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Defends Pinky Ring as delicious and says its big NY-style slices justify the cost.
- Recommendsu/demonkidz in r/nashville · May 2026
Lists Pinky Ring among their go-to pizza places.
- Recommendsu/lonekthx in r/nashville · May 2025
Believes the place is likely the area's top pizza, while calling another spot good and a bit cheaper.
- Recommendsu/VeryLowIQIndividual in r/nashville · May 2025taste
The sauce is great.
- Mixedu/thejasonblackburn in r/nashville · May 2025price
Good but still way overpriced.
- Caveatu/nimrodidiot in r/nashville · May 2025price
Warned others off.
- Caveatu/Rabid_Hermit in r/nashville · May 2025price
Expensive and the location makes it feel worse.
More maps in Nashville, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 12 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.