Square Pie Guys, Passyunk
20 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/philly, r/philadelphia22 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Many commenters rank Square Pie among the city's best, and several call it their favorite or the top square-style pie. One commenter singles out the pancetta, porchetta and squash pies, and another suggests ordering the porchetta. Commenters place it on Passyunk Avenue or in Queen Village and Bella Vista. Two commenters were unimpressed: one calls it overrated after a single visit and one says it is small for what it costs. One more calls it expensive but says it spoiled other pizzas for them.
Address
Square Pie, 801 Passyunk Ave, Philadelphia, PA 19147
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Porchetta pie
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Square Pie Guys, Passyunk, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/jm20008john1989 in r/philly · Jul 2026
Names Square Pie on Passyunk as their top pick.
- Recommendsu/pringlesreturns in r/philadelphia · Oct 2026taste
Says the Passyunk location's pie is quite thick and good.
- Recommendsu/kingdazy in r/philly · Jul 2026taste
Thinks it is the top square-style pie in Philadelphia and likely the best overall in its neighborhood.
- Recommendsu/tsarkees in r/philly · Sep 2024variety
Lists Square Pie as favorite for deep dish.
- Recommendsu/SomeOffice7100 in r/philadelphia · Dec 2024
Says they personally like this Queen Village spot and offers it as a suggestion for a recommendations request.
- Recommendsu/Leatherman34 in r/philly · Sep 2024taste
Describes it as an underrated contender for the city's top pizza and calls it incredible.
- Recommendsu/zombietom21 in r/philadelphia · Oct 2026
Suggests Square pie as a pick for someone open to a square style.
- Recommendsu/NimdokBennyandAM in r/philly · Jul 2026
Calls it top pizza in town and says they adore the place.
Show all 22 cited comments
- Recommendsu/attytood4 in r/philly · Jun 2024
Urges readers not to overlook this spot.
- Recommendsu/maxbarnyard in r/philadelphia · Oct 2026taste
Recently ate the pancetta pie and called it excellent, and earlier pies with porchetta and squash too.
- Recommendsu/irish_to_kms in r/philly · Jul 2026variety
Agrees it's tastier and says they mostly order the weekly specials, which they rate very highly.
- Recommendsu/oliver_babish in r/philly · Jul 2026
Says they love this spot and visit on some nights, alternating with Emmy Squared.
- Recommendsu/penifSMASH in r/philly · Jun 2026taste
Says this is the only pizza they actually liked in the city and calls it very good; thinks the rest fall short.
- Recommendsu/AshamedAd6133 in r/philly · Jul 2026
Says they loved it when living nearby and the post makes them want to return.
- Recommendsu/MisterAlaska in r/philly · Jul 2026
Says they love it; the photo made them hungry.
- Recommendsu/waterboy1321 in r/philadelphia · Jul 2024
Names Square Pie as among the city's top pizza spots.
- Recommendsu/patjc101 in r/philadelphia · Nov 2026
Seconds the Square Pie pick and suggests ordering the porchetta.
- Recommendsu/stumbling_coherently in r/philadelphia · Nov 2026taste
Says Square Pie is great and belongs with the top thick square options.
- Recommendsu/ari_mel89 in r/philadelphia · Oct 2026
Says it's their personal favorite, agreeing with the Square pie comment above.
- Recommendsu/Beginning_Anything30 in r/philadelphia · Mar 2024taste
Says the price is steep, yet other pizzas now seem lacking after trying this one.
- Caveatu/extracreddit114 in r/philly · Jul 2026value
Says it's too small for what it costs and burns their mouth, though wishes others enjoy it.
- Caveatu/heddalettis in r/philly · Jul 2026taste
Tried it once, disliked it, and calls the place overrated.
More maps in Philadelphia, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.