Portage Bay Cafe, University District
32 people recommend, 28 warn against itvia r/Seattle, r/AskSeattle30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 31 threads.
What people say, in short
Portage Bay Cafe has several Seattle locations; the listing is for the Roosevelt Way location in the University District, and commenters also mention the South Lake Union spot. Opinion is sharply split: many name it as a breakfast or brunch option, and one has ordered the pancakes for years and still likes them, while many call it overrated or mediocre. A couple praise the topping bar, a few mention waits and crowds, one says it was better before ownership changes, and one calls it costly for what you get but far better than another spot.
Address
Portage Bay Cafe, 4130 Roosevelt Way NE, Seattle, WA 98105
At a glance
- Best for
- Breakfast, Dine-in, Family
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Portage Bay Cafe, University District, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Caveatu/Memeboidad3 in r/Seattle · Aug 2024
Calls Portage Bay a place to avoid.
- Recommendsu/KittenG8r in r/AskSeattle · Feb 2026
Names Portage Bay as the answer to the original breakfast question.
- Mixedu/hesheatingup in r/Seattle · Aug 2024
Loved it before, but no longer wants to go after chef and ownership changes.
- Mixedu/CrampyPanda in r/AskSeattle · Aug 2025
Calls Portage Bay overhyped but still suggests trying it.
- Caveatu/SillyChampionship in r/Seattle · Oct 2026taste
Says Portage Bay is poor at any branch and the food is weak.
- Caveatu/lolalucky in r/AskSeattle · Aug 2025
Calls Portage Bay mid and questions the long waits despite taking reservations.
- Caveatu/zh3nya in r/AskSeattle · Aug 2025
Calls Portage Bay bleh, one of many mediocre brunch spots.
- Caveatu/tapesmoker in r/Seattle · Jan 2025
Would not argue against someone calling Portage Bay mediocre.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/yuckgeneric in r/AskSeattle · Feb 2026
Recommends Portage Bay Cafe; says its Roosevelt and 65th branches are equally good.
- Recommendsu/Shortsleevedpant in r/AskSeattle · Feb 2026
Agrees with the Portage Bay answer given above.
- Caveatu/interstellar89 in r/AskSeattle · Feb 2026
Judges Portage Bay Cafe a weak breakfast spot, among the least impressive in town.
- Caveatu/DarkFlowerPewPew in r/Seattle · May 2025ambience
Says the place is chaotic even for a small group, let alone a crowd of eleven.
- Caveatu/Ltownbanger in r/Seattle · Feb 2025
Calls it overrated, saying that's why the earlier pick got downvoted.
- Caveatu/OccasionalGoodTakes in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Warns against trusting Portage Bay recommendations, calling the place a tourist trap.
- Mixedu/didyoubutterthepan in r/Seattle · Apr 2024taste
Likes the farmers hash but says its vegetables come out too firm every time, regardless of season.
- Caveatu/CChocobo in r/Seattle · Oct 2026
Calls the cafe bad overall and wonders why it stays so busy.
- Caveatu/stevieG08Liv in r/Seattle · Jan 2025
Says they stopped reading the list once Portage Bay appeared in it.
- Recommendsu/avidfan2018 in r/AskSeattle · Aug 2026
Rates Portage Bay as a solid brunch choice.
- Caveatu/NoStatement4495 in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Calls Portage Bay overrated.
- Recommendsu/beetlekittyjosey1 in r/Seattle · Jun 2024
Names Portage Bay as a brunch option in reply to the original question.
- Recommendsu/ottermom03 in r/AskSeattle · Jan 2026
Named as a group breakfast option in a bulleted list of suggestions.
- Mixedu/Kilsimiv in r/Seattle · Jan 2025price
Says it is costly for what you get but far superior to Beth's.
- Recommendsu/kibbles137 in r/Seattle · Dec 2024variety
Agrees the toppings bar is the draw.
- Recommendsu/FlinchMaster in r/Seattle · Dec 2024consistency
Has ordered pancakes there for years and still likes them, praising the topping bar.
- Recommendsu/Blushing-Sailor in r/AskSeattle · Sep 2026
Lists Portage Bay Cafe as another option near downtown, in South Lake Union.
- Recommendsu/rosiecatchan in r/AskSeattle · Mar 2026
Recommends Portage Bay Cafe for breakfast, pointing to the SLU location with big windows and a rowing shell.
- Recommendsu/optamastic in r/AskSeattle · Jan 2026
Listed among brunch options for a group of this size.
- Recommendsu/Icy_Attitude_4 in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Notes multiple locations and a strong brunch menu.
- Recommendsu/goddamnpancakes in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025taste
Calls Portage Bay Cafe a favorite brunch spot, especially praising its french toast.
- Recommendsu/Sensitive_Maybe_6578 in r/AskSeattle · Jul 2024
Suggests Portage Bay as a breakfast option, with no further detail.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.