Post Alley Pizza, Pike Place
61 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/Seattle, r/SeattleWA, r/AskSeattle30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 28 threads.
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend Post Alley Pizza, and many name it as their pick for a slice near Pike Place Market. A diner calls it among the closest local slices to New York style, and one found the pizza fantastic but notes it has no indoor seating. One visitor found the crust clearly not floppy but the sauce quite salty. Some commenters say its opening hours can be hard to work around, and some say it has declined or did not impress them.
Address
Post Alley Pizza, 1123 Post Ave, Seattle, WA 98101
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Post Alley Pizza, Pike Place, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Antique_Mechanic133 in r/Seattle · Mar 2026taste
Ate there on a first visit and found it very good.
- Recommendsu/Mr-Hox in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026
Lists this as a go-to answer for the pizza and pasta question.
- Recommendsu/xcbrendan in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Rates the Post Alley spot as solid and says slice options are scarce in the city.
- Recommendsu/WalkingonCoffee in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2025portion
Says two slices there are pretty filling for them.
- Recommendsu/mikutansan in r/Seattle · Apr 2025
Suggests Post Alley Pizza when asked for a better pizza place.
- Recommendsu/spraj in r/Seattle · Nov 2023taste
Lists this among Seattle pizza strong enough to rank in most cities, except possibly New York or New Haven.
- Recommendsu/ImpressiveAirline169 in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Describes it as a dependable, no-fuss spot for a plain slice close to the Market.
- Recommendsu/bvorke in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Calls Post Alley Pizza their current favorite, though its opening hours can be hard to work around.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Royal_Annek in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Offers it as one of two picks for the pizza question.
- Recommendsu/Matthews628 in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026taste
Calls Post Alley the clear pick for pizza specifically.
- Recommendsu/splanks in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2025
Calls this the best nearby pizza option for someone visiting the market.
- Recommendsu/quesodillamarcelo in r/AskSeattle · Jul 2026taste
Calls it a good pick, well known for respectable pizza, and suggests checking its photos first.
- Recommendsu/chicken_and_jojos_yo in r/Seattle · Sep 2025taste
Says Post Alley is the clear top pick for slices, with other good spots too.
- Recommendsu/SnooStrawberries6934 in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Considers Post Alley among the closest local slices to New York.
- Recommendsu/AnselmoHatesFascists in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026
Names it as a top pick for single slices.
- Recommendsu/delicious_things in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2025
Names it among standout local pizza spots in a reply defending the city's pizza scene.
- Recommendsu/Anand999 in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026taste
Rates it as great, placing it just behind the commenter's top spot.
- Recommendsu/Dapper_Signal4608 in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026taste
Called it the favourite of the three; found the pizza fantastic and the sauce good, though there is no indoor seating.
- Recommendsu/H0tsh0t in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2025
Names this as the pizza answer for a Pike Place visitor, while suggesting other local food as well.
- Recommendsu/FreddyTwasFingered in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Says they came to endorse both of the parent's picks.
- Recommendsu/Lulubelle4548 in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026
Simply endorses the parent's two picks as the right answers, with no added detail.
- Recommendsu/Unholy_Prince in r/Seattle · Oct 2024taste
Names Post Alley among the good pizza here, with the same higher-price caveat.
- Recommendsu/MickDubble in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026
Endorses Post Alley as one of the two standout spots in the Pike Place area.
- Recommendsu/Livid-Bottle7385 in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2026taste
Says they really enjoy it.
- Recommendsu/Captainpaul81 in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Calls Post Alley good too, as a second recommendation in the comment.
- Recommendsu/synack in r/Seattle · Oct 2024
Suggests this place as an answer to the crunchy-crust question, without giving details.
- Caveatu/TheNonExample in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026
Says its schedule is similarly inconvenient for weekday lunch.
- Caveatu/platapusdog in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026taste
Says Post Alley did not impress them.
- Caveatu/Dobus in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025consistency
Says Post Alley has declined lately.
- Mixedu/reeveb in r/Seattle · Nov 2024taste
Tried it and found the crust clearly not floppy, but thought the sauce was quite salty.
Also on
Post Alley Pizza, Pike Place is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.