Windy City Pie, Phinney Ridge

Praises its Chicago-style pie and calls its tavern-style the best they've had, Chicago included.

Calls it closer to pan pizza and says they personally dislike it.

Not a fan of its deep dish; Breezy-style days were good but fell short of the original.

Says its deep dish is pretty good but feels more like a casserole than pizza.

Lists this among local pizzerias they rate above the pizza in the post.

Calls Windy City good but says they prefer another place.

Calls it good but finds ordering ahead for dining in odd; says waiting is part of it.

Names it among standout local pizza spots in a reply defending the city's pizza scene.

Adds that the place also sells slices at certain times of day.

Calls it good pizza but doubts it suits a young child's party.

Calls it delicious and a personal favorite in town, though not authentic Chicago style.

Cites it as an example of good Seattle pizza, against a worst-in-country claim.

Found the pies soggy on the few visits and doesn't understand the praise it gets.

Lists it among the pizza places they love.

Recommends it and says the city has excellent pizza.

Says Breezy Town consolidated with Windy City; slices still available but menu less expansive; pizza still great.

Calls Windy City a solid pick because it's close to the show's venue.

Finds the place pretty good, though Chicago has better pizza options.

Reports the Phinney Ridge spot was too pricey for a solo diner, so they walked away from it.

Warns that stacked fees and tips push the final bill well past the menu price.

Enjoyed a Windy City pie after getting the tip and found it tasty.

Says they regularly get this spot, alongside another spot.