Andy's Pizza, Adams Morgan
133 people recommend, 19 warn against itvia r/washingtondc30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 34 threads.
What people say, in short
Most people who mention Andy's recommend it, and some call it the best pizza in town. Andy's has more than one outlet and most comments do not say which one: some name the Adams Morgan location shown here, and some single out the Shaw one. Some praise the crust. Caveats: some say delivery is unreliable, one thinks the NoMa branch gets less care than another, and a diner calls it overrated.
Address
Andy's Pizza Adams Morgan, 2465 18th St NW, Washington, DC 20009
At a glance
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Andy's Pizza, Adams Morgan, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Caveatu/spince in r/washingtondc · Jun 2025delivery
Complains that a pizza from this Andy's was ruined.
- Recommendsu/Environmental_Leg449 in r/washingtondc · Sep 2025taste
Says Andy's pizza tastes good.
- Recommendsu/dkinmn in r/washingtondc · Oct 2025taste
Visited and says the crust ranks among the best, with the onion-mushroom slice a highlight.
- Recommendsu/rmxcited in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025
Says Andy's Pizza is excellent.
- Recommendsu/sandman_wv in r/washingtondc · Dec 2025value
Lists two slices here as a cheap lunch pick.
- Recommendsu/THEBIGHUNGERDC in r/washingtondc · May 2026taste
Praises the white pizza with added sausage as excellent.
- Recommendsu/BennyDaBoy in r/washingtondc · May 2026taste
Says Andy's ranks fairly high on their personal pizza list, while noting that taste varies.
- Recommendsu/703own in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025ambience
Says the Shaw spot has real character and recommends grabbing a fresh cheese pie there on Saturday evenings.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/RomanoLikeTheCheese in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025taste
Describes Andy's as delicious.
- Recommendsu/Mister_Infinity in r/washingtondc · Oct 2026
Places this spot in the middle of the route for a pizza crawl.
- Recommendsu/eusebius2004 in r/washingtondc · May 2024
Names Andy's as the pizza pick in reply to the request.
- Recommendsu/bitterwife2299 in r/washingtondc · May 2026
Calls it their top pizza locally and urges others to try it.
- Recommendsu/shoefly72 in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025
Calls the Shaw spot an amazing place for snacks and hangouts around nearby concerts.
- Recommendsu/HowardBunnyColvin in r/washingtondc · May 2026
Gives a blunt, enthusiastic thumbs-up to the place.
- Recommendsu/ReigningCatsNotDogs in r/washingtondc · Feb 2024
Says Andy's is also good, as a second option alongside Ledo's.
- Recommendsu/pete_the_puma51 in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025
Calls Andy's the best pizza in town.
- Recommendsu/busche916 in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025variety
Says the veggie slice is the one to order.
- Recommendsu/branyk2 in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025value
Would rather treat themselves to this than eat cheaper, worse pizza repeatedly; notes pricey places can be worse too.
- Recommendsu/Fr0st_RemiiX in r/washingtondc · Feb 2025
Recommends Andy's as the sole answer to the question.
- Recommendsu/20CAS17 in r/washingtondc · Jun 2024
Names Andy's in Adams Morgan as a late-night option, saying it stays open until around 2.
- Recommendsu/lolhello2u in r/washingtondc · Jun 2024taste
Doesn't find Andy's mediocre in any city, even New York.
- Recommendsu/Zwicker101 in r/washingtondc · Jul 2025ambience
Says they visit often and find it cozy, a good place for a fun outing.
- Recommendsu/depression_quirk in r/washingtondc · Jun 2024taste
Says Andy's comes closest to pizza from their home region, though a bit pricey.
- Recommendsu/tickyticky13 in r/washingtondc · Apr 2025taste
Recommends Andy's in Adams Morgan, ahead of Pizza Paradiso.
- Recommendsu/DigSolid7747 in r/washingtondc · Oct 2024
Says they love Andy's.
- Caveatu/MoreCleverUserName in r/washingtondc · Apr 2026delivery
Says Andy's delivery goes through third parties, so it's unreliable for orders.
- Caveatu/bludynamo in r/washingtondc · May 2026consistency
Says the NoMa branch lacks the extra care they feel another location puts in.
- Mixedu/hikikomori4eva in r/washingtondc · Aug 2025taste
Praised the crust but said the pepperoni was sparse for the pie and less flavorful than elsewhere.
- Caveatu/WoTMike1989 in r/washingtondc · May 2024
Says people overrate Andy's, and expects pushback for saying so.
- Mixedu/captainredfish in r/washingtondc · May 2026delivery
Loves the food but says app delivery often arrives cold or smashed.
More maps in Washington DC, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.