Fourth Man in the Fire
31 people recommend, 9 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/Pizza30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 30 threads.
What people say, in short
The Fourth Man in the Fire is widely recommended for pizza, with margherita, pepperoni and Hawaiian pies among the named picks. Diners also suggest it for a sit-down meal, and one mentions a patio. The dissent is broader than a single bad visit: a critic dislikes the sauce, another the takeout pizza, two report frustrating service, and others consider it underwhelming. One visitor was turned away near closing, so the praise is not a promise of late service.
Address
The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria, 832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, Canada
At a glance
- Best for
- Dine-in
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Fourth Man in the Fire, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Depp1990 in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2025taste
Ranks this margherita second-best of the five pictured.
- Recommendsu/NeitherStay2205 in r/askTO · Jan 2024ambience
Agrees with the Fourth Man suggestion and says you can dine in there properly.
- Recommendsu/tangmichael88 in r/FoodToronto · Jan 2026
Gives this spot as their direct answer to the question.
- Recommendsu/Cipher_null0 in r/FoodToronto · May 2025
Names this pizzeria as their second choice after another favourite spot.
- Recommendsu/the-mongoose- in r/askTO · Oct 2026
Lists it among favourite spots in the city.
- Recommendsu/93LEAFS in r/askTO · Apr 2026taste
Says it's a short stroll away and good.
- Recommendsu/Sea-Professional8759 in r/FoodToronto · Aug 2026
Lists this as one of the top picks alongside Acute Pizzeria.
- Recommendsu/TittiesAreMyTherapy in r/FoodToronto · Apr 2026
Names it among their top five pizza places.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Mixedu/PrailinesNDick in r/FoodToronto · Mar 2024taste
Says the pizzas there aren't their favourite, but praises other menu items.
- Recommendsu/ArgyleNudge in r/FoodToronto · May 2025
Ranks it a distant second in their list.
- Recommendsu/corn_niblet in r/FoodToronto · Sep 2025
Names this spot for slices and adds separate praise for its donuts.
- Caveatu/phuckdub in r/FoodToronto · Mar 2025service
Found the ordering and payment system frustrating and never went back, though the pizza was fine.
- Recommendsu/TabootLlama in r/FoodToronto · Mar 2025taste
Praises its Hawaiian pizza and side breads; says the kitchen can cook despite the author's bad experience.
- Recommendsu/sgl35 in r/askTO · Sep 2025
Names it among several pizza picks.
- Recommendsu/Bakerbot101 in r/FoodToronto · Feb 2026
Lists their pepperoni pizza among favourites.
- Recommendsu/hagopes in r/FoodToronto · Feb 2026taste
Calls their regular Margherita S-tier.
- Caveatu/twicescorned21 in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2025taste
Expected more and came away unimpressed.
- Caveatu/celerypooper in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2025taste
Dislikes the sauce, saying it tastes like plain marinara from a chain.
- Caveatu/RaffyGiraffy in r/FoodToronto · Mar 2025
Tried it twice and was not impressed either time.
- Recommendsu/sebabmw77 in r/FoodToronto · Jul 2024ambience
Suggests this place as a dine-in option and calls its patio decent.
- Recommendsu/Optimal-Company-4633 in r/FoodToronto · Feb 2026
Considers it one of their favourite places for pizza in the city.
- Recommendsu/tubadsouza in r/FoodToronto · Feb 2024taste
Calls it a solid pick with tasty slices.
- Recommendsu/Spirited_Comedian225 in r/FoodToronto · Mar 2026taste
Praises the cheese slice there as a standout.
- Recommendsu/TimBergling91 in r/FoodToronto · Jan 2026
Gives this same spot as their pick.
- Caveatu/hudsonsdangerzone in r/FoodToronto · Jan 2026taste
Says quality here has dropped sharply too.
- Caveatu/HappyHawlucha in r/FoodToronto · Apr 2025
Complains about its early closing time, with an angry emoji.
- Caveatu/ge23ev in r/FoodToronto · Apr 2025service
Wanted to try it for ages but was turned away at closing time; says restaurants should post last-order times.
- Recommendsu/Ants416 in r/FoodToronto · Aug 2024
Recommends it.
- Recommendsu/mclaryst in r/Pizza · Dec 2023
Names it as one of their favourite Toronto pizza places.
- Recommendsu/bounce7 in r/askTO · Mar 2026
Ranks 4th man third in their list of compared spots.
More maps in Toronto, Canada
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.