Best pizza in Toronto

148 people recommend, 16 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/Pizza

North of Brooklyn draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets for New York-style pizza, including NY Cheese, Vodka Verde and Killer Bee. Diners specifically recommend the Geary outlet's Greater Good setting for pizza, beer and an arcade. Dissent centres on value and texture: some find the pizza merely average, one reports soggy pies and another wants more toppings. The named pizzas and experiences across the city are not all specific to Geary.

Geary

138 people recommend, 14 warn against itvia r/Pizza, r/FoodToronto, r/toronto, X

Fresca on College draws strong support for large slices and the garlic-and-herb finish that many fans see as its distinguishing feature. Diners repeatedly describe it as good value, with margherita and cheese slices among the picks. The garlic topping also divides opinion: some find it overpowering or think the pizza underneath falls short. Lineups are another recurring drawback, and one diner prefers its slices to its whole pies.

College

126 people recommend, 37 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto, X

Badiali's Toronto outlets attract strong praise for their slices, especially the vodka pizza, alongside a substantial debate about the queues. These citywide experiences are not all visits to Dovercourt. Several diners like the pizza but refuse a long wait; others consider the wait worthwhile or suggest pre-ordering a whole pie. Critics also report underwhelming slices and question the hype, while one visitor prefers the cacio e pepe to the vodka slice.

Dovercourt

108 people recommend, 9 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/Pizza

Descendant in Leslieville is a strongly recommended Detroit-style option, with the Canadian, Jaffna Roti and Truff Guy pizzas drawing praise. One diner particularly likes the soft chew and crisp cheese-edged crust, and another praises how well it reheats. Several commenters find the style too heavy for frequent eating or prefer competing Detroit-style shops. Price and texture draw dissent too: some consider it expensive, and critics describe excessively chewy or tough dough.

Leslieville

96 people recommend, 13 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto

Acute at Dundas and Lansdowne earns strong praise for its sourdough crust, with burrata, white mushroom and Jala Pep pizzas among the named picks. Several diners describe it as underrated and good value; one recommends it for both slices and whole pies and praises delivery. Ordinary dissent remains: one finds the sauce too sweet, others question the quality, and another says requests for a longer bake have not worked out.

Dundas W Lansdowne

93 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Mac's near Dovercourt and Bloor draws strong support for thin, New York-style slices, with Lemonhead, White Pie and Tye Dye repeatedly singled out. The lemon slice is a distinctive draw, though one visitor preferred the White Pie and found the vodka pepperoni less convincing. Several commenters question slice size for the price. One reports sparse toppings, and others prefer competitors. A diner seeking a more formal dinner finds the setting too casual.

Bloor

71 people recommend, 12 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Revolver draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets, including St. Clair. Citywide favourites include the pistachio, sausage and rapini, and mushroom pizzas; those dish recommendations are not all tied to St. Clair. A slice regular praises that branch, while other visitors are disappointed. Other criticism concerns burnt-looking crusts, inconsistent cooking and value, so the broad support is not unanimous approval of every outlet.

St Clair

67 people recommend, 8 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Slowhand's sourdough pizza draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets. Fans name the mushroom pizza, and one recommends the Peter Piper. At the King West outlet on Waterloo Terrace, a visitor praises a collected pizza but describes the location as hidden and without seating. Another found the newer branch's crust ordinary. Citywide comparisons are mixed: some prefer Slowhand to Detroit-style rivals, while one diner reports an overcooked order and others prefer competitors.

King West

58 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Gram's on Dupont draws strong recommendations for slices and whole pies, with vodka, mushroom and spicy options among the orders diners name. One visitor describes a structured, crisp-leaning crust, while another recommends taking a pie to the nearby park. A negative tasting report found the spicy Hawaiian slice fell apart and was only average; other diners say that did not match their experience. Some like it without ranking it among the city's very best.

Dupont

48 people recommend, 13 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Maker's Toronto outlets draw praise for distinctive pies including Original Dr. Pepperoni, Frank's Best and Tropic Thunder. A diner specifically recommends the location just west of Spadina, near Cameron Street, while most dish opinions do not specify a branch. One fan likes the pillowy dough, and others praise the garlic dip. Critics question the value, two find it too salty, and one calls it too greasy; several prefer other pizzerias.

46 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto

Beast on Tecumseth earns recommendations for its crust and creative toppings, with pepperoni, Aloo Gobi and mushroom pizzas among the named favourites. Fans particularly praise the crust, and one describes it as crisp and airy. Commenters also recommend the sit-down experience. The main caveat is value: several find it expensive against other pizzerias, and one fan says the niche topping selection will not appeal to everyone.

41 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/toronto, r/askTO, X

King Slice earns recommendations across its Toronto locations for large slices and garlic oil, with arrabiata a recurring favourite. Diners specifically name the Bloor outlet as well as Queen West. Several praise the value, but others prefer competing slice shops or report disappointing cooking and a decline in quality. A visitor calls the slices solid rather than the best of a pizza outing. Not every dish or experience described is tied to Bloor.

Bloor

32 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto

Libretto draws recommendations across Toronto for Neapolitan-style pizza, including vegan margherita and mushroom pies. Not all of those experiences are at Ossington. A commenter specifically praises Ossington's pizza but dislikes the renovated setting. Another diner recommends the brand for eating in, and a separate fan describes it as dependable. The criticism includes reports of declining quality, expensive slices and crusts that did not meet expectations.

Ossington

32 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Afro's draws support for its distinctive, Detroit-style-inspired pizza and unusual toppings. Named favourites include a seasonal goat birria pizza, King Bacon Cheeseburger and chicken-and-waffle; availability of a seasonal special should not be assumed. Diners praise the crust and flavour combinations, but the response is not unanimous. Several question the price, one visitor found two orders wet and greasy, and another liked the jerk chicken pizza more than the chicken-and-waffle option.

31 people recommend, 9 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/Pizza

The Fourth Man in the Fire is widely recommended for pizza, with margherita, pepperoni and Hawaiian pies among the named picks. Diners also suggest it for a sit-down meal, and one mentions a patio. The dissent is broader than a single bad visit: a critic dislikes the sauce, another the takeout pizza, two report frustrating service, and others consider it underwhelming. One visitor was turned away near closing, so the praise is not a promise of late service.

24 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto, X

Danny's on College draws recommendations for Chicago tavern-style, cracker-crust pizza rather than deep dish. The clam pie has more than one fan, and a visitor recommends the sit-down setting alongside salads and cocktails. Critics find some pizzas underwhelming or burnt, with the Cacio Pepe drawing particularly mixed reactions. One repeat visitor would not reorder that pie and thinks the restaurant has better options. The overall support is positive, but neither the style nor every order suits everyone.

College

23 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Junior's on Dundas West near Roncesvalles draws recommendations for generous pepperoni, cheesy square slices and good value. One diner calls the square pepperoni slice especially rich and filling, while another singles out All the Pepperoni. Others are less convinced: several dislike the crust, one finds the sauce salty and sour, and one visitor had an order their household did not enjoy. A diner who dislikes the texture on delivery prefers it reheated.

Roncesvalles

19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Pizza, r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Renaissance on Dundas West is repeatedly recommended for Detroit-style pizza. One diner praises the paneer tikka, another the mushroom pizza, and others point to its slices. A visitor who brought a group found the food solid and liked the patio setting. Not everyone agrees: one diner finds it too rich and cheesy despite enjoying the crisp edges, and another directly dislikes the pizza.

19 people recommend, 9 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Bitondo's on Clinton Street draws recommendations for old-school, substantial pizza and budget-friendly value. Its popularity is not an uncontested verdict on quality. Several commenters say it has declined, some find it clearly weaker than other slice shops, and critics compare a pictured slice to frozen pizza. Fans continue to recommend the greasy, traditional style, while another diner enjoys the nostalgia without finding it easy to judge on taste alone.

Little Italy

17 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/Pizza

Nice Slice draws recommendations for New York-style pizza, particularly the vodka pepperoni and zaatar options. One diner puts it among their top three Toronto picks, and another rates its vodka slice above Badiali's, but those are individual comparisons rather than a consensus ranking. A first-time visitor liked the pepperoni slice while finding the bottom crust unexpectedly crunchy. A separate diner describes the pizza as solid.

17 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Mark's on Old Kingston Road in Scarborough draws strong recommendations, including for its hot pepperoni slice and a pepperoni-and-mushroom pizza with truffle cream. A diner also praises its Roman-style slices, and another plans nearby appointments around a meal there. The east-end location suits local fans, though one visitor finds it a long trip. A critic finds the pizza often dry and overcooked rather than exceptional.

Scarborough

16 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/Pizza

Bar Sugo draws repeated recommendations for a sit-down pizza meal, with whole pies from a wood-burning oven and a zucchini pizza among the named draws. One diner specifically recommends it for full pies rather than slices. Another calls the pizza phenomenal, especially on off-peak visits. A visitor who likes the pizza finds the music too loud for catching up, making the atmosphere a consideration alongside the food.

14 people recommendvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto

Via Mercanti in Kensington Market draws recommendations for Neapolitan-style pizza and a sit-down meal. One diner who has spent time in Naples considers it the closest local match they have found. Another likes the dining room and counter seating for a solo visit. Some broader brand recommendations do not specify a location. A former regular is unsure about current quality, and one visitor enjoyed it while still preferring another pizzeria.

Kensington Market

13 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto

Martino's on Dupont draws recommendations for the unusual General Tao chicken pizza as well as more conventional pies. Several diners have fond memories of the shop, while current visitors praise its slices and value. One fan rates it among their favourite city pizza spots; another likes the supreme with hot honey. The combination is not for everyone: one diner finds the General Tao pizza too saucy, and another calls the plain margherita less interesting.

13 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

No. 900's Beaches outlet draws praise for Neapolitan-style pizza, including its dough and ingredients. One visitor enjoyed a vegan pizza there, and another liked both the sausage and fig-and-pancetta pies. The texture divides opinion: some defend the soft Neapolitan style, while others report soggy or insufficiently baked pizzas. Several visitors were disappointed overall. Comments are uncertain about walk-in slices, so this is not a guarantee that slices are available.

Beaches

11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto, r/toronto

CiCi's in Parkdale draws recommendations for old-school slices, with diners praising the substantial portions and value. One commenter specifically recommends its pick-up pizza special, while another likes it for delivery within range. Two diners rate it above other local shops, though those are individual comparisons rather than a shared ranking. A former regular says the pizza has declined, so the nostalgia and value do not amount to unanimous praise of current quality.

Parkdale

10 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Ambassador on Bloor draws recommendations for Windsor-style pizza. One visitor describes a cornmeal-studded crust, julienned pepperoni and Galati mozzarella, while another praises the large slices and their value. Diners also name it among their favourite Toronto pizza spots. The comparisons with Windsor are mixed: one commenter endorses the resemblance, while another enjoyed it but preferred a pie eaten in Windsor. A separate visitor finds it a little oily despite a satisfying crunch.

10 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Frank Ranalli's in Kensington Market draws recommendations for its pizza, with the eggplant, honey and chili-crisp combination receiving praise from more than one diner. A separate fan singles out the mushroom pie, and others name it as a worthwhile slice stop in the market. The support is not a unanimous top ranking: one visitor found it solid without being particularly impressive. It is a market option with a smaller following than Toronto's most-discussed shops.

Kensington

10 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Salt and Tobacco on Parliament draws recommendations for its pizza, with the Funghi slice and a vegan slice among the orders people name. One diner recommends a smoked-ham pizza with pineapple, describing it as less sweet than the canned-pineapple style. A regular considers the slices expensive but still enjoys the pizza. A visitor recalls a limited window for slices but is unsure of the arrangements, so check before relying on slice service.

Parliament

10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/toronto, r/askTO

8 Mile is recommended for Detroit-style pizza near Yonge and Bloor. One diner praises its sauce, and another singles out the truffle pizza. Several compare it favourably with other Detroit-style shops in the city, but that preference is not universal. One visitor who had lived in Michigan found it good rather than great, while another dismissed it as mediocre. It is a thicker-style option with a genuine split in expectations.

10 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO, r/toronto

Chito's at Bloor and Lansdowne draws recommendations for shawarma-topped pizza slices and budget-friendly value. Diners describe choosing a slice and having chicken shawarma added, while two commenters recommend it for a late-night bite. One critic disputes the late hours and finds the pizza tasteless and the shawarma rubbery. Another strongly dislikes the pizza, and one reports higher prices. Check current hours rather than relying on the conflicting late-night reports.

Bloor and Lansdowne

9 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Lorenzo's on Pape draws recommendations for New York-style pizza, with diners praising the crust and foldable slices. One fan particularly recommends the nduja, sausage and fig pie. There is practical dissent as well as praise: a visitor reports repeated sellouts, and another cautions against travelling without knowing that risk. A different diner finds it merely okay and breadier than a New York slice. Past ordering reports should not be treated as a current availability guarantee.

East End

9 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Pi Co draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets for quick, customizable pizza. A diner specifically describes the Carlton and Church branch as a good pick-up option and says it stays open late; check current hours before relying on that. Another likes choosing toppings, and a separate fan orders a margherita to finish with toppings at home. Those broader brand experiences are not all at Carlton and Church, and some praise is more modest than enthusiastic.

Carlton and Church

9 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Pizza Gigi on Harbord draws recommendations for straightforward neighbourhood pizza, including a Sicilian slice one diner was enjoying and pepperoni another finds distinctive. Diners also name it as an answer to pizza requests. The ordinary criticism remains mixed: one diner calls it hit and miss but still worthwhile, another thinks it was better in the past, and a separate critic strongly dislikes it. Its local following is not unanimous approval.

Harbord

8 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/FoodToronto

Mattachioni draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets for Neapolitan-style pizza and sourdough crust. Diners name Dupont as well as Gerrard; experiences at Gerrard are not visits to Dupont. Two people offer it as their answer to a sourdough-pizza question, and a separate diner calls it wonderful. Another recommends the Neapolitan-style pizza specifically in the Junction Triangle area. The citywide support includes both named branches and comments that do not identify an outlet.

8 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Pizzeria Defina on Roncesvalles draws recommendations for wood-oven pizza. One diner singles out the Pumba with wild boar and garlic confit, and another recommends the pizza and romantic atmosphere for a date. Other visitors name the Roncesvalles outlet as a favourite or include it in their personal city pizza rankings. The particular dish and date-night recommendations are individual experiences alongside those broader endorsements.

Roncesvalles

8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Danforth Pizza House draws recommendations for a classic, cheesy style of pizza. One long-time fan recommends the house special, and another names the vodka sauce pie or Angry Bee. A diner likes it as a well-cheesed version of traditional delivery-style pizza but says the business itself does not deliver. Others are less enthusiastic: one finds it mediocre and expensive against nearby shops, while another still likes it but preferred the pizza in earlier years.

7 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

General Assembly draws recommendations for its pizza, with Certified Lover Boy and the vegan Fern Gully among the named favourites. One diner likes it specifically for eating in before a nearby cinema visit, but finds the takeout pizzas weaker. Other commenters name it as a favourite or say they love the pizza. The dine-in versus takeout comparison is one diner's experience rather than a verdict on every order.

7 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto

Terroni draws recommendations across Toronto for pizza, including capricciosa and Buffalina. Two commenters suggest the Adelaide restaurant for a sit-down pizza meal, and one likes the old-courthouse setting. Other pizza and value comments do not specify Adelaide. A commenter still considers the brand good value, while another remembers the early years more fondly. The named pizzas are individual favourites, rather than a shared verdict about one outlet's menu.

Adelaide

7 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto

Cosmic draws recommendations across its Toronto outlets, including College Street. A visitor specifically rates the College location above the large chains but below nearby independent slice shops. Another praises substantial slices and value, while a separate diner recommends a donair slice late at night without specifying an outlet. A critic finds the slices short on sauce. Those broader dish and occasion comments are not necessarily College-specific experiences.

7 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto

Piano Piano draws recommendations across Toronto for sourdough pizza, including a Harbord visitor who praises both the pizza and the roomy setting. Other comments about decor refer to the brand or another branch. One diner finds the mushroom pizza particularly good, while another enjoys the flavour but calls it expensive and notes that sourdough is not everyone's preference. Diners suggest it for eating in rather than only grabbing a slice.

Harbord

7 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Slow South draws several independent recommendations in Toronto pizza discussions. One visitor particularly likes the light-tasting sauce, generous cheese and basil, although the crust did not stand out and the pie felt expensive. That diner still planned to return, while other commenters simply name the shop as their pick or say they love it. The detailed appeal is a rich cheese pizza, not a claim of universally exceptional crust or value.

7 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Bello draws pizza recommendations across its Toronto locations, including Waterworks. A fan calls the pepperoni pizza a personal favourite, and another specifically praises the Waterworks shop's generous slices and garlic dip. Not everyone agrees about value: several find it expensive or unjustified, while a diner who liked the substantial slices wanted a chewier crust. Comments about a former Bloor outlet are not experiences at Waterworks.

Waterworks

6 people recommendvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto

Milano's in Etobicoke draws recommendations for an unfussy slice, with Six Points specifically named by a commenter. One diner says a workplace pizza order pleased everyone, while another calls it a local staple with affordable pies rather than their absolute favourite. A visitor enjoys the slices but wants more cheese. Its fans describe a neighbourhood option rather than an elaborate specialist pizza experience.

Etobicoke

6 people recommendvia r/askTO

Il Fornello draws recommendations across its locations for pizza, particularly from people seeking plant-based choices. A diner specifically recommends the Danforth restaurant in a vegan-pizza discussion; broader menu comments do not all identify a branch. Another describes the pizza as decent. Other commenters name the chain as a regular pizza option or point to its plant-based pizza range. The enthusiasm is individual rather than a unanimous ranking above specialist pizzerias.

5 people recommendvia r/askTO, r/FoodToronto

Bar Poet receives independent pizza recommendations, with the Hawaiian and the pineapple-topped 5.0 among the named picks. One diner likes the roasted pineapple on the 5.0, and another describes the Hawaiian as decent and suggests the setting for a date. A visitor who liked the pizza describes the crust as cauliflower-like; that is a texture comparison, not an ingredient or dietary guarantee. Other commenters simply recommend the pizza without naming an order.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Longo's earns recommendations for its prepared pizza, including a commenter who specifically calls the First Canadian Place shop surprisingly good. Broader brand recommendations include a whole pizza on a budget and a diner who regularly craves its double-cheese pizza. Two people highlight value, though their historical deal descriptions are not a promise of current promotions. Those general brand experiences do not all identify First Canadian Place.

5 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Il Paesano on Browns Line draws recommendations for old-school pizza in Etobicoke. One diner describes it as deliberately greasy and unfussy; another remembers visiting regularly while living nearby. Other commenters independently name the same business as a pizza pick. A visitor also mentions a full bar. Its appeal to these fans is a traditional neighbourhood pizza rather than a fashionable slice-shop experience.

Browns Line

5 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/toronto, r/askTO

Pizza on Fire in Scarborough receives several direct recommendations, including from a diner who calls it their regular choice and another who independently backs that pick. One commenter singles out the tandoori chicken pizza, describing a substantial, bready pizza with chicken, avocado and mozzarella. Others name it as a place to try, but do not describe particular orders. The detailed dish description comes from one diner, not a shared verdict about every topping.

5 people recommendvia r/toronto, r/FoodToronto, r/Pizza

Venga Cucina in the Junction draws recommendations for Roman-style pinsa as a different option from the city's more common pizza styles. A visitor who stumbled on it during a Toronto trip enjoyed the pinsa, and another independently praises the pizza in a west-end restaurant discussion. One commenter suggests it for a fancier sit-down meal, while another calls it a little pricey. The recommendation rests on those experiences, not an unverified international award claim.

Junction

5 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/toronto

850 Degrees in Etobicoke receives independent pizza recommendations, including a visitor who names it as a favourite in the city. Another singles out the Long Branch and Vancouver pizzas, while a third recommends the Lakeshore pizzeria for its Canadian-themed approach. A diner also points to its unusual toppings and themed names. The specific pizzas are personal picks alongside broader recommendations for a west-end meal.

Etobicoke

5 people recommendvia r/FoodToronto, r/askTO

Oakwood Pizzeria is recommended as an old-school, unfancy neighbourhood option. One diner describes good pizza at a lower price than more hyped shops, and another recommends a party-size pizza when asked for value. A separate commenter likes its straightforward style, while two others directly recommend the business. Fans focus on substantial, traditional pizza and value rather than an elaborate modern slice-shop experience.