Barberian's Steakhouse, Elm St

Agrees with the earlier suggestion of Barbarian's.

Recommends Barberian's and says it justifies travelling downtown.

Has been to both and picks Barberian's for its ambience and better food.

Suggests Barberian's as a different pick and describes it as a classic old-school spot.

Suggests Barberians as a better steakhouse choice.

Names Barberian's steak house as the answer.

Backs Barbarian's, praising its dim lighting and excellent steak.

Gives a one-word answer naming this steakhouse to the steak question.

Rates Barberian's as having the best steaks and drinks selection among the places listed.

Calls Barbarians a worthy option and suggests walking to Massey Hall afterwards.

Didn't enjoy it; found service lacking and the decor unappealing.

Says dining there feels like a Sopranos scene, with the nicest steak and best service.

Calls it the best steakhouse around and suggests splitting the chateaubriand.

Suggests Barbarians as a steakhouse option in reply to the request.

Lists Barberians as a suggested steakhouse.

Names Barbarian as a favourite steak spot, with consistently excellent food and an old-school feel.

A birthday visit exceeded expectations and made this a favourite for a fancy steak dinner.

Big fan of Barberian's, calling it a great steakhouse with an excellent wine list.

Says Barberian's is very good but its old-school style is more than they can take.

Calls this a classic steakhouse that costs less than some peers, though it is still fairly expensive.

Did not enjoy the dark, old-school atmosphere or the steak at Barberian's.

Visited once and found Barberian's overrated and overpriced, pushing back on the praise.