Buca Mario
16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel19 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people recommend Buca Mario, and many single out the bistecca fiorentina. A couple of diners say the plain-looking front hides good food, and one calls the ravioli the best pasta they have had. One diner found it hot inside and overpriced, saying similar food is available elsewhere, and another feels it is aimed at tourists, while another found it a bit pricey but thought it could be worthwhile. One diner says dinner books up quickly, so they went for lunch instead.
Address
Ristorante Buca Mario, Piazza degli Ottaviani, 16r, 50123 Firenze FI, Italy
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Bistecca fiorentina
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Buca Mario, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/0mega2022 in r/florence · May 2024
Calls Buca Mario their favorite meal from a past Florence trip.
- Recommendsu/Confident-Put2175 in r/florence · Aug 2026taste
Says the food was among the best they have had, with great atmosphere despite a plain exterior.
- Recommendsu/Reckoner08 in r/florence · Apr 2024taste
Recommends this place for bistecca fiorentina.
- Recommendsu/babycattequila in r/florence · Aug 2026
Enthusiastically recommends Buca Mario, without further detail.
- Recommendsu/bazokalino in r/florence · Jan 2026
Had a better experience here than at ZaZa, so recommends it over that option.
- Recommendsu/jjr4884 in r/florence · Oct 2025taste
Suggests splitting a steak here, as an alternative to Trattoria dall'Oste.
- Recommendsu/Ok_Fish_4734 in r/florence · May 2025
Calls Buca Mario the best and praises the service there.
- Mixedu/ChefMark85 in r/florence · May 2025value
Says it was on their list and seemed somewhat expensive, but suggests it may be worth it.
Show all 19 cited comments
- Recommendsu/betermcshpee in r/florence · May 2025taste
Ate there on both Florence visits; found the steak's flavor varied bite to bite, all excellent, and ranked it among top dining experiences.
- Recommendsu/penautsandcaramel in r/ItalyTravel · Apr 2025taste
Listed among the family favourites, singled out for its bistecca fiorentina.
- Caveatu/BenchQuiet in r/florence · Oct 2024value
Found it hot inside and overpriced, with food they say can be matched or bettered elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/EfficientDig9 in r/florence · Sep 2024
Says they ate there and highly recommend it, with good food and terrific service.
- Recommendsu/bakersmt in r/florence · May 2024taste
Says a past Florence visit gave them a great Florentine steak at Buca Mario.
- Recommendsu/Born_Operation9271 in r/florence · Sep 2026taste
Would like to return; says it looks modest but puts the focus on food.
- Recommendsu/buthol123 in r/florence · Feb 2026ambience
Suggests trying to get this restaurant's private room.
- Caveatu/Levistrauss81 in r/florence · Jan 2026
Feels it is aimed at tourists and says cheap tortellini can be bought at a supermarket instead.
- Recommendsu/Illustrious_Win8676 in r/florence · Oct 2025taste
Has eaten at all three and ranks Buca Mario's steak and food above the others.
- Recommendsu/Nessie3765 in r/florence · Sep 2024taste
Calls its ravioli the finest pasta they've had anywhere; suggests steak and lunch since dinner books up.
- Recommendsu/beanfarmer314 in r/florence · Jun 2024taste
Recommends ordering the Florentine steak there.
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 16 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.