Best restaurants in Florence
50 restaurants that people in Florence recommend on Reddit and X — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Florence restaurant recommendations, from Tuscan osterias to pizza and pasta in Oltrarno, with diners' highlights, booking advice and dissent shown together.
Drawn from real discussions in r/florence, r/ItalyTravel and on X — 50 restaurants in Florence that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around Oltrarno, Santa Croce, San Frediano and San Lorenzo.
How this map is made: Built from 510 comments and posts across 469 people in r/florence, r/ItalyTravel and on X. Last refreshed November 16, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 50 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.Trattoria Zà Zà
58 people recommend, 34 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence, X
Trattoria Zà Zà divides diners. Many call the food good or excellent, a couple mention the lively atmosphere, and a couple single out truffle dishes. Against that, many say it is touristy or mediocre, a couple describe a queue or long wait even with a booking, and several advise skipping it. Several who liked it say the tourist crowd does not spoil the food.
- RecommendsLists it as a Florence top pick and praises its lively atmosphere. r/ItalyTravel, Sep 2024
- CaveatAuthor found the bolognese and lasagna underwhelming and suggests skipping it, though the interior looked attractive. r/florence, Jun 2026
2.Vini e Vecchi Sapori
39 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Vini e Vecchi Sapori is a Florence osteria that many diners call a favorite, and a few single out the duck ragù. A few praise the atmosphere. Booking is the common difficulty: several advise reserving ahead, and a few say a table is hard to get. Dissent is limited: one diner calls it only decent, no better than comparable places, and another enjoyed the food but had a poor experience with the service.
- RecommendsSays this was the best tripe they had in Florence and possibly their favorite restaurant meal there. r/ItalyTravel, Apr 2024
- CaveatSays it lacks online booking, doesn't answer the phone, and was fully booked for about a week on an in-person visit. r/florence, Oct 2026
3.Osteria del Cinghiale Bianco, Oltrarno
32 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Osteria del Cinghiale Bianco sits in Oltrarno, near Ponte Vecchio, and most people recommend it. Several diners single out the wild boar dishes, and a few say they keep going back or that it has never let them down. One advises booking ahead. Two diners warn against it, with one finding the room touristy and the food only average and another calling it the weakest meal of their trip, while two mixed reports disagree on the steak.
Oltrarno
- RecommendsCalls it terrific and says friends who went since agreed. r/ItalyTravel, Feb 2026
- CaveatAgrees with the warning and found it the weakest meal of their trip. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2026
4.La Giostra
32 people recommend, 22 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many diners recommend La Giostra for its food, with several praising the pear ravioli and a couple recommending the tiramisu. One diner ranked the steak as the best of their week, though service gets mixed reports. Many others were disappointed, with a couple finding the pear ravioli bland or tasting of raw flour and several finding it pricey. A couple say it leans toward tourists.
- RecommendsCalls La Giostra top-tier, praising its pear ravioli, service and wine. r/florence, Oct 2025
- CaveatFamous pear ravioli tasted like raw flour even after sending back; says better, cheaper Italian food exists elsewhere. r/florence, Nov 2025
5.La Buchetta
30 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
People recommend La Buchetta, and many praise the food, with the gnocchi, steak and cheesecake among the dishes they name. Several also praise the service, and a few advise booking ahead. One visitor calls it only average, and one diner notes it costs more than the alternative they considered.
- RecommendsNamed it their best restaurant of the trip; loved the pici and went back for lunch. r/ItalyTravel, Apr 2024
- CaveatDismisses it as mid, i.e., average. r/florence, Feb 2024
6.Osteria Santo Spirito
25 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people single out the gnocchi here, especially the truffle and cheese versions. Most diners recommend it, and one calls it a highlight of their visit. A couple warn that lines can be long, and one suggests booking ahead. One diner describes it as fresh and affordable.
- RecommendsDescribes it as a strong dining spot and says the gnocchi are exceptional. r/florence, Oct 2026
- CaveatVisited off-season and found waits milder, implying lines are worse during busy periods. r/florence, May 2024
7.Gustapizza
21 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people praise the pizza, and most who mention it recommend it. Several mention long queues, though a couple say the wait is worth it, and a couple say it can feel busy and touristy. Two diners warn against it: one says to skip it if you know Neapolitan-style pizza, and another found the pesto pizza oily and soggy.
- RecommendsSays the hype was justified, the food was delicious, and they were seated right away on an early dinner. r/florence, Jun 2026
- CaveatRecommends dropping it after a long queue and a soggy, oily pesto pizza. r/florence, Jun 2025
8.4 Leoni
17 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Most diners recommend 4 Leoni, with a couple pointing to the pear pasta and two praising the steak. A few also say the service is good, though one diner found it lacking. Two diners say it can be skipped or rank it among the weakest picks, and one diner found the menu uninspiring and the meal pricey for what they got. Opinions on value and taste are mixed: one diner sees it as a budget-friendly option that is just as good, while another thought the pasta could take some getting used to.
- RecommendsIncluded in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2025
- CaveatCalls 4 Leoni one of the worst choices on the list. r/florence, Sep 2025
9.Il Santo Bevitore
16 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many people recommend Il Santo Bevitore in Florence, and several say they enjoyed it, with one calling it their best meal there. A few describe its cooking as a modern or refined take on Tuscan classics, and one says it draws both tourists and locals.
- RecommendsIncluded in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2025
10.Buca Mario
16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Most people recommend Buca Mario, and many single out the bistecca fiorentina. A couple of diners say the plain-looking front hides good food, and one calls the ravioli the best pasta they have had. One diner found it hot inside and overpriced, saying similar food is available elsewhere, and another feels it is aimed at tourists, while another found it a bit pricey but thought it could be worthwhile. One diner says dinner books up quickly, so they went for lunch instead.
- RecommendsCalls Buca Mario their favorite meal from a past Florence trip. r/florence, May 2024
- CaveatFound it hot inside and overpriced, with food they say can be matched or bettered elsewhere. r/florence, Oct 2024
11.I'Brindellone, Oltrarno
16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
I' Brindellone is a small trattoria in Oltrarno, and many diners praise the steak, with two also praising the truffle pasta. Most diners recommend it, and a couple call it good value, though one diner feels its pasta is similar to pasta elsewhere. Many advise booking ahead. Two diners were less impressed: one found it just okay, and another singled it out as the exception among several listed options.
Oltrarno
- RecommendsPraises the steak as excellent, recommends it, and says booking ahead is necessary. r/florence, Jun 2026
- CaveatFound I'Brindellone a disappointment, only just okay. r/florence, Oct 2026
12.Trattoria Sabatino, San Frediano
16 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Overall people recommend it: many diners say the food tastes good, and many call the prices budget-friendly, with one describing the cooking as home-style Italian. Several people say locals eat here, and one diner praises the hospitality. Expect a crowd: many mention a queue, and one person found the line full of visitors filmed for social media rather than locals. One person found it disappointing, and another diner thinks it is good but not especially special.
San Frediano
- RecommendsVisited this long-running Florence trattoria and found the cooking excellent. r/ItalyTravel, Apr 2024
- CaveatFound this place disappointing. r/florence, Jul 2026
13.Il Latini
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Most diners recommend Il Latini, and several single out the steak. Two diners praise the tasting menu, and one advises booking ahead since it fills up. One diner warns that the steaks come rare, and one found a single steak portion more than enough. One diner, who says it is only their view, found the food just okay and the service lacking.
- RecommendsJudges Latini as a good pick from the list. r/florence, Feb 2024
- CaveatDoesn't see the hype; found the food just okay and service lacking, while noting it's only their view. r/florence, Oct 2024
14.Cibrèo Trattoria, Sant'Ambrogio
14 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Cibrèo Trattoria is the casual trattoria of the Cibrèo family (which also runs a formal restaurant and a cafe nearby); most diners who name an outlet mean the trattoria, and a few just say Cibrèo. Many people recommend it, several call the food excellent or amazing, and one picks the lasagna as exceptional. A few diners were less impressed, calling it a letdown, mediocre or so-so.
Sant'Ambrogio
- RecommendsLoved their meal there; sees it as a tribute to classic Tuscan home cooking. r/florence, Sep 2024
- CaveatFound it a complete let down. r/florence, Nov 2025
15.Buca Lapi
13 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Most people recommend Buca Lapi, with many singling out the steak and a few praising the service and the atmosphere. A couple find it pricey, though one says the whole experience makes it worth the cost, while another found the steak only okay and the service stiff. One diner ranks its food below Buca Mario's, even as they describe it as the most upscale of the places they tried.
- RecommendsIncluded in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2025
- CaveatFound the steak fine but overpriced and service stiff; the cellar room felt great. Group agreed. r/florence, Aug 2026
16.Trattoria Sergio Gozzi, San Lorenzo
13 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Most people who write about this trattoria recommend it as a casual lunch spot close to San Lorenzo, and a few say it draws locals. A few praise the food, with one calling it outstanding and another naming the steak, peperonata and beans as one of their best meals. One notes there are no reservations, so expect a wait. One commenter finds it less impressive than other restaurants they name and overhyped, while another warns it is easy to walk past.
San Lorenzo
- RecommendsSuggests this trattoria on the piazza beside San Lorenzo as an alternative option. r/florence, Sep 2025
- CaveatFinds it less impressive than two other restaurants they name and considers it somewhat overhyped. r/florence, Jun 2024
17.Sostanza
12 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people recommend Sostanza, a trattoria in Florence, and several single out its pollo al burro (butter chicken). One diner found the vegetarian artichoke pie excellent and felt the place was popular with tourists yet still traditional and authentic. Several people find reservations hard to get. One visitor thinks you would enjoy it but suggests skipping it if booking keeps failing, since good food is easy to find almost anywhere in Florence.
- RecommendsRecommends the chicken breast there as wonderful. r/florence, Sep 2025
- MixedWishes booking were less hard, implying they'd like to dine there, with reservations as the drawback. r/florence, Sep 2026
18.I' Girone de' Ghiotti
12 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people recommend I' Girone de' Ghiotti, a sandwich shop in Florence, and several single out its schiacciata sandwiches, with one describing the bread as thin and crisp. One diner calls the porchetta among the best things they have eaten, and a couple of people say the sandwich is the best they have had. Expect a lunch line, though another diner says it moves quickly. One visitor says there is essentially no seating and suggests going off-peak.
- RecommendsSays they enjoyed this shop's traditional schiacciata and suggests it to the asker. r/florence, Jul 2024
19.Trattoria Cammillo
12 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Trattoria Cammillo is a trattoria that many diners recommend, and a few praise the food itself. One calls it a local classic, another says it feels a little off the usual tourist path, and one would pick it for a group. A couple advise booking ahead, and a couple note it costs more, though one feels it is worth it.
- RecommendsIncluded in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2025
20.Trattoria Mario
11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Most people who write about Trattoria Mario recommend it, and many praise it, with a few singling out the steak. A couple call it casual and no-frills, and a couple find it good value. Caveats include one diner finding the steak served very rare in a brusque, fast-paced setting, one finding a stew far too salty, and one who enjoyed the meal but would not go back. One suggests booking in advance.
- RecommendsOffers Trattoria Mario, right beside Za Za, as a nearby alternative. r/florence, Sep 2025
- CaveatTried their Florentine-style stew and found it far too salty; ate only half. r/florence, Mar 2025
21.Acqua al 2, Santa Croce
11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners praise the food, with several singling out the blueberry steak and a couple praising the ravioli. One diner who has eaten in Florence calls the food excellent. One person calls it delightful but says it has become a tourist spot, and another has crossed it off their list without giving a reason.
Santa Croce
- RecommendsOffers it as a more local pick that impressed them. r/ItalyTravel, Oct 2025
- CaveatSays they are crossing Acqua al 2 off their list, with no reason given. r/florence, Sep 2026
22.Osteria dell'Enoteca
10 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
People recommend this Florence osteria, and many praise the meal. A couple single out the steak, a couple suggest it for romantic or fancier evenings, and a couple advise booking ahead.
- RecommendsReports a standout steak dinner here during their Florence stay and calls it the best bistecca of the trip. r/ItalyTravel, Jan 2025
- MixedVisited and was given olive oil free on request, without being pushed to buy it. r/florence, Oct 2026
23.Osteria Pastella
10 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners recommend it, and several single out the truffle pasta served in a cheese wheel tableside. One diner says it is the best pasta they have eaten, and another finds the wild boar pasta very delicious. Worth knowing: one diner says the flaming cheese-wheel show may not suit everyone, and another says the early seating draws tourists while the late slot draws locals.
- RecommendsCalls it a touristy spot that was still delicious. They tried several dishes, all good, and liked the truffle pasta prepared in a Parmesan wheel. r/ItalyTravel, Jun 2024
24.Trattoria Marione
10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many diners recommend Trattoria Marione, and a few single out the potatoes. One diner calls the potato tortellini amazing, one recommends the ribollita, and a couple recommend the steak. A couple note that it does not take bookings, so people arrive when it opens or put their name in and wait. One diner found the steak rarer than the menu indicated and the lasagna dry.
- RecommendsSuggests adding Marione to the list. r/florence, Sep 2025
- MixedLoved the potatoes, but the steak came more rare than the menu warning implied and the lasagna was dry. r/florence, Oct 2026
25.Trattoria da Tito
8 people recommendvia r/florence
Most diners recommend Trattoria da Tito, and a couple describe it as an authentic, local place. One says the dishes are outstanding, one says the steak is the best they have had, though it is very traditional and best suited to people who like it medium rare, and one praises both the service and the food. One diner found the meal good but very filling, and a couple note it sits a little out of the centre.
- RecommendsRecommends Trattoria da Tito for a genuine local feel and outstanding dishes. r/florence, Sep 2025
- MixedCalls this spot much quieter than Za Za, though slightly out of the centre. r/florence, Aug 2026
26.Osteria del Gatto e la Volpe
8 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Commenters recommend this osteria, and several diners say the food is good. One diner calls it an unassuming spot and singles out the spicy pasta; another points to the pici, especially in tomato season, and a commenter suggests the pesto gnocchi. A commenter finds the prices great, and one diner says they returned to it on a later trip.
- RecommendsCalls this small, unassuming spot a favourite with excellent food, especially its spicy pasta. r/florence, Feb 2025
27.L'Ortone, Santa Croce
8 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people recommend L'Ortone. One diner found the food interesting and well conceived, one describes a cozy, romantic atmosphere, one still thinks fondly of the gnocchi, and one found the vegetarian dishes amazing. One diner found it good but slightly disappointing overall.
Santa Croce
- RecommendsNames this as one of two picks offered to the asker. r/florence, Sep 2026
- MixedFound L'Ortone good but somewhat disappointing overall. r/florence, Nov 2025
28.Trattoria La Casalinga
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence
Many people recommend Trattoria La Casalinga, and a few diners praise the food, including the chicken and potatoes and the duck ragu pasta. Two diners raise concerns about service: one calls it awful, and another left after ordering when their food never arrived while other tables were served. A third diner found the food good but less impressive than expected. One diner suggests booking ahead.
- RecommendsRecommends this trattoria by name with no further detail. r/florence, Feb 2024
- CaveatLeft after ordering because other tables were served while theirs never arrived; discourages going. r/florence, May 2025
29.Nugolo
8 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people recommend Nugolo, and a few praise its tasting menus, with one saying the vegetarian tasting menu was amazing. One diner called it an outstanding meal, and another says the food they ate was excellent. One diner found it very underwhelming, with most other meals better, and another was only lukewarm though someone in their party loved it.
- RecommendsCalled it an outstanding meal and wished they had returned there every night of the trip. r/florence, Sep 2026
- CaveatVisited Nugolo on forum recommendations and found it very underwhelming, with most other meals better. r/florence, Sep 2026
30.Alla Vecchia Bettola
7 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners recommend Alla Vecchia Bettola. One calls its bistecca fiorentina the best, with fried porcini in autumn as a suggested side, one praises the vodka penne, and another praises the pasta, the arista and the house wine. One diner calls it fun and tasty even outside the center.
- RecommendsIncluded in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants. r/ItalyTravel, Mar 2025
31.Trattoria dei 13 Gobbi
7 people recommendvia r/florence
Many diners recommend Trattoria dei 13 Gobbi, and several praise the food, with one saying the veal chop is worth ordering. Another says it may have been their favorite meal in Florence. One diner said reservations were needed during their visit.
- RecommendsCalled it delicious. r/florence, Oct 2026
32.Pino's Sandwiches
7 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Pino's Sandwiches is a sandwich shop in Florence, and several people praise the sandwiches. One commenter calls the paninis the best, another went back a second time, and one suggests it over the better-known All'Antico Vinaio. One diner finds the prices very reasonable and the house wine affordable.
- RecommendsTheir family found the sandwiches so good that they went back a second time. r/ItalyTravel, Apr 2025
33.Ristorante Dei Rossi
6 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners recommend Ristorante dei Rossi, and several praise the food. Dei Rossi has two restaurants, near Ponte Vecchio (pinned) and in Santo Spirito; one diner's steak was at the Santo Spirito one. One diner found the house specials excellent, and one found the Ponte Vecchio restaurant not touristy and mildly upscale rather than pretentious.
- RecommendsSays it was their favorite Florence restaurant, with excellent food from the starters through dessert. r/ItalyTravel, Jun 2024
34.La Fettunta
6 people recommendvia r/florence
Many diners say the meal was good, and two mention generous portions. One diner remembers tasty food and good wine, and one visitor called it their favorite restaurant of the trip and went back for a second night. Another finds it good value. One commenter notes the street is busy, though the place itself is very nice.
- RecommendsDescribes it as a good small, authentic spot for lunch. r/florence, May 2025
35.Zeb
6 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend Zeb. Several praise the food, with two calling it excellent or among the most authentic meals in Florence, and one likes the house wine. One diner found the pear ravioli delicious and better value than at La Giostra.
- RecommendsAgrees with the Zeb pick; says the food is excellent and the house wine is good. r/florence, Aug 2025
36.Braceria all'11
6 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Several diners praise the food here, and a few single out the steak; one says the truffle-topped bistecca may be the top steak they have tried. Several also describe the staff and service as good, and two suggest it over La Giostra when food matters most. None warn against it.
- RecommendsAte steak there while visiting; found it great, appreciated the menu's meat explanations, and enjoyed the meal and service. r/florence, May 2025
37.Golden View
6 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Golden View is a riverside restaurant that several diners recommend for its Arno and Ponte Vecchio views. A couple praise the tasting menu, and one mentions a strong wine list. Cost is the main caveat: one calls it the priciest meal of their trip, though two others say it was worth the cost or good value.
- RecommendsSays the view and service feel Michelin-level and that it is good value for the money. r/florence, Aug 2025
38.Osteria Vecchio Cancello
6 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners recommend Osteria Vecchio Cancello, with one calling it the highlight of a short Florence trip and another finding the dinner incredible. One commenter calls it the best steak place they have visited and praises its volcanic black salt.
- RecommendsSuggests trying Osteria Vecchio Cancello when asked for restaurant recommendations in Florence. r/ItalyTravel, Apr 2025
39.Il Morellino
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend Il Morellino. One diner says it was their favourite meal in Italy, another says the balsamic filet is outstanding, as are the pasta dishes, and a visitor says it is especially good for pasta. Not everyone is won over: one diner found the dishes hit or miss, with the truffle pasta standing out and the rest underwhelming.
- RecommendsHad a lovely dinner and recommends the octopus and Tuscan spaghetti. r/florence, Sep 2026
- MixedFound the dishes uneven: the truffle pasta stood out, while the other dishes felt underwhelming. r/florence, Sep 2026
40.Rocco, Sant'Ambrogio Market
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend Rocco, a trattoria at the Sant'Ambrogio market, and a couple point to it as a lunch spot. One calls it a hidden gem for authentic local dishes eaten alongside Florentine diners, one praises the food and communal seating, and one found both dishes they tried good. One diner found the lunch pretty good but remembers a stronger visit in the past.
Sant'Ambrogio Market
- RecommendsCalls it a hidden gem for authentic local dishes, eaten alongside Florentine diners. r/florence, Sep 2025
- MixedHad lunch there and found it pretty good, though remembers a stronger experience about a dozen years back. r/florence, Jan 2026
41.Il Pizzaiuolo
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend Il Pizzaiuolo, and a couple point to its pizza. One diner found the food and house wine excellent, including the pasta, salad and dessert. One visitor counted it among their best meals of a trip.
- RecommendsRecommends it as a solid pick among the pizza options. r/florence, Oct 2026
42.Osteria Pepò
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Osteria Pepò is a small osteria, and one diner advises booking ahead. Many people recommend it, and a couple of diners single out the lasagne, while another says the fried polenta, spinach flan and grilled figlietta were delicious. One visitor found it quieter than a busier spot right beside it and liked the food.
- RecommendsRates the lasagna among the best in Florence and says guests they brought enjoyed the meal. r/florence, Oct 2025
43.Trattoria Pallottino
5 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many people recommend Trattoria Pallottino, a couple of blocks west of Santa Croce. Two diners single out the food, and one describes the place as modest in appearance with food as the priority. Two diners report eating there more than once, and one found it full of locals and reasonably priced.
- RecommendsRecommends Trattoria Pallotino, located a short walk west of the Santa Croce square. r/ItalyTravel, Oct 2024
44.Trattoria Palle d'Oro
5 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many people recommend Trattoria Palle d'Oro, a trattoria near the San Lorenzo market in the centre of Florence. One commenter names it among the better places to try peposo, a slow-cooked peppery stew, and adds that it is less of a tourist spot, while another recommends the tortellini al ragù eaten standing up at lunch. One visitor found the meal cozy and friendly, and the place full of locals.
- RecommendsRecommends Palle d'oro near San Lorenzo market for peposo, calling it very good. r/florence, Sep 2025
45.Ciro & Sons
5 people recommendvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel
Many diners recommend Ciro & Sons, and a few praise the food, including the pizza and a hearty ravioli dish. One diner praises the staff highly, and another praises the service. A few diners mention needing reservations: one had to wait for a table, and another saw people sent away when space ran out.
- RecommendsPraised the food and service; suggests reserving, since they got a table after roughly twenty minutes. r/florence, Jun 2025
46.L'Arte di Dory, Oltrarno
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend this Oltrarno trattoria. One diner rates its pasta among the finest they have eaten, and another calls the ribollita outstanding and says the rest of the menu is good as well. A diner who stayed nearby called the food and the people wonderful.
Oltrarno
- RecommendsSuggests this Oltrarno trattoria as a dinner option. r/florence, Sep 2026
47.Ristorante Natalino
5 people recommendvia r/florence
Many people recommend Ristorante Natalino, and two of them single out its Florentine steak. One diner says it is great for that steak and is a favorite with locals as well, while another diner says they had a good one there. A visitor who ate there calls the meal great and recommends it.
- RecommendsSays Natalino is good too. r/florence, Sep 2025
48.Antico Noè
5 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Many diners recommend Antico Noè in Florence, and one diner found the meal delicious while another praised the food overall, especially the bolognese. One diner prefers its sandwiches for their flavour. A commenter lists it among trattorias they say are all very good. One diner booked a table ahead of time.
- RecommendsPrefers it for sandwiches with more flavour. r/ItalyTravel, Feb 2025
49.La Schiacciata
5 people recommendvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence
Everyone who writes about it recommends it, and several people say La Schiacciata is a better pick than the well-known sandwich shop nearby. Two people praise the sandwich itself, and several report much lighter crowds with little or no wait. People focus on the sandwich and the short lines, with nothing said about the rest of the menu.
- RecommendsPraises it as an excellent sandwich place across from the famous shop, with much less crowding. r/ItalyTravel, Feb 2025
50.Borgo San Jacopo
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/florence
Borgo San Jacopo is a Michelin-listed fine-dining restaurant, and several diners recommend it, with a couple praising its views. One calls it their favorite meal in Florence, one suggests asking for a terrace seat, and one says the food could pass for a higher-rated Michelin restaurant. One diner found the dishes underwhelming and the service mixed.
- RecommendsTheir go-to whenever visiting Florence; valued for its river and bridge views. r/florence, Jun 2025
- CaveatFound the dishes underwhelming and the service mixed on their visit. r/florence, Sep 2026
Questions people ask
- Which restaurants do people in Florence recommend most on Reddit and X?
- Right now the most-recommended are Trattoria Zà Zà, Vini e Vecchi Sapori and Osteria del Cinghiale Bianco, Oltrarno, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public discussions on Reddit and X — 510 comments and posts from 469 people in r/florence, r/ItalyTravel and on X. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 16, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?