Skip to content

I'Brindellone, Oltrarno

16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel18 comments cited below

What people say, in short

I' Brindellone is a small trattoria in Oltrarno, and many diners praise the steak, with two also praising the truffle pasta. Most diners recommend it, and a couple call it good value, though one diner feels its pasta is similar to pasta elsewhere. Many advise booking ahead. Two diners were less impressed: one found it just okay, and another singled it out as the exception among several listed options.

Address

I’Brindellone, Piazza Piattellina, 10, 50124 Firenze FI, Italy

At a glance

Signature dishes
Bistecca alla Fiorentina, Truffle pasta

Nearby on this map

Other places on this map closest to I'Brindellone, Oltrarno, as the crow flies.

The evidence

Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.

  • Recommendsu/dontmindme432 in r/florence · Jun 2026taste

    Praises the steak as excellent, recommends it, and says booking ahead is necessary.

  • Recommendsu/Scoutsmom-20 in r/florence · Sep 2026

    Suggests this Oltrarno spot for a meal after crossing the river.

  • Recommendsu/Lanky_Glass_7064 in r/florence · Sep 2026

    Says they always recommend I'Brindellone, identifying themselves as a Florence local and tour guide.

  • Recommendsu/lormayna in r/florence · Jan 2026

    Suggests I Brindellone for authentic Tuscan eating; it is tiny, so booking ahead is advised.

  • Recommendsu/heykyara in r/ItalyTravel · May 2024taste

    Says the truffle butter pasta was excellent and the steak also good, in a casual, family-friendly room.

  • Recommendsu/opinionated18 in r/florence · Jun 2026taste

    Calls it their favorite in the city, says the food is consistently excellent, and worries about tourist crowds.

  • Recommendsu/noaboutthepasta in r/ItalyTravel · Oct 2025taste

    Strongly recommends this simple, no-frills spot for excellent ingredients and steak at a good price; suggests booking ahead.

  • Recommendsu/aphrodiggitydite in r/florence · Sep 2026taste

    Calls it very good and always books ahead, though finds its pasta no different from what other places serve.

Show all 18 cited comments
  • Recommendsu/ItsJustMy2Cents in r/florence · Sep 2025taste

    Was turned away at first, then booked later; praises the steak as delicious and urges reserving ahead.

  • Recommendsu/Stunning-Foot8586 in r/florence · Oct 2024

    Says they really enjoyed this place, endorsing it.

  • Recommendsu/jules_kirkan4 in r/florence · Oct 2026

    Advises keeping this Oltrarno trattoria, noting locals dine there and ordering the daily menu items.

  • Caveatu/HouSoup in r/florence · Oct 2026

    Found I'Brindellone a disappointment, only just okay.

  • Recommendsu/camron67 in r/florence · Oct 2026value

    Recommends it as a less formal pick offering excellent value.

  • Caveatu/thewazbaz in r/florence · Sep 2026

    Implies the other listed options are fine, singling out I'Brindellone as the exception.

  • Recommendsu/alk0916 in r/florence · Sep 2026taste

    Ate there and the truffle pasta stayed memorable.

  • Recommendsu/Leo80xxx in r/florence · Feb 2026

    Eats there regularly and calls it a decent trattoria.

  • Recommendsu/WhiteHeartedLion in r/florence · Jan 2026

    Suggests I Brindellone as likely to suit most visitors, though not everyone would love it equally.

  • Recommendsu/Commercial_Zebra_936 in r/florence · Jan 2026taste

    Praises this small, cozy spot for phenomenal food, especially its steak.

Did this page answer your question?

Freshness

Details last checked 16 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.

Follow @mapswemade for new maps