La Giostra
32 people recommend, 22 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 27 threads.
What people say, in short
Many diners recommend La Giostra for its food, with several praising the pear ravioli and a couple recommending the tiramisu. One diner ranked the steak as the best of their week, though service gets mixed reports. Many others were disappointed, with a couple finding the pear ravioli bland or tasting of raw flour and several finding it pricey. A couple say it leans toward tourists.
Address
La Giostra, Borgo Pinti, 16 R, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
At a glance
- Price
- Premium
- Signature dishes
- Pear ravioli, Tiramisu, Steak
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to La Giostra, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/WordStream33 in r/florence · Oct 2025taste
Calls La Giostra top-tier, praising its pear ravioli, service and wine.
- Caveatu/Literally_whatever69 in r/florence · Nov 2025taste
Famous pear ravioli tasted like raw flour even after sending back; says better, cheaper Italian food exists elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/Ill_Proposal190 in r/florence · Jul 2026
Names it as a favorite restaurant recommendation.
- Caveatu/TurboAljo in r/florence · Jul 2026taste
Warned others off after a bad experience.
- Caveatu/ceruleansuperfruit in r/florence · Oct 2025taste
Found the pear ravioli bland, called it a low point of the trip, and said service was poor.
- Caveatu/HelpfulScholar222 in r/florence · Apr 2024
Says La Giostra gets lots of hype but did not impress them.
- Recommendsu/nyc2everywhere in r/florence · Mar 2025
Suggests ending a sunset outing with dinner at La Giostra after crossing a bridge.
- Mixedu/Tiny-Preference3020 in r/florence · Jun 2025value
Had a lovely visit, but says the cost is hard to justify for an experience that can be hit or miss.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Caveatu/motherofdragi in r/ItalyTravel · Apr 2025taste
Says their group's least favourite meal on a two-week Italy trip was at this restaurant.
- Recommendsu/brooklynOG in r/florence · Feb 2025taste
Concedes hype and influencer crowds, still strongly endorses it, and says the tiramisu was excellent.
- Caveatu/ExpensiveAstronaut65 in r/florence · Nov 2025
Found the meal just average at best, with nothing standing out.
- Mixedu/Adventurous-Rub7636 in r/florence · Nov 2025consistency
First visit excellent, second average; aimed at tourists and won't return.
- Recommendsu/garden_girlie in r/florence · Oct 2025taste
Visited and loved the meal, calling the pear ravioli fantastic and the visit a memorable experience.
- Caveatu/Itaney in r/florence · Apr 2025taste
Underwhelmed despite its hype.
- Caveatu/UGA150 in r/florence · Feb 2025
Strongly negative: describes a crowded, herd-like feel, poor service and unremarkable food; calls it overrated.
- Recommendsu/Evening-Sir6460 in r/ItalyTravel · Sep 2024taste
Says they visited La Giostra in Florence and recommends it for its food and the atmosphere.
- Recommendsu/Reckoner08 in r/florence · Apr 2024taste
Recommends this place for bistecca fiorentina.
- Recommendsu/maganaise in r/florence · Feb 2026
Says it is pretty good but notes it is expensive.
- Recommendsu/Cute_Telephone1418 in r/florence · Nov 2025taste
Really enjoyed the food; the steak was the best all week and service was great.
- Caveatu/vinovibez in r/florence · Jun 2025
Agrees with the criticism and says their own meal there was the worst of their trip, with the wine also poor.
- Caveatu/darkseries87 in r/florence · Feb 2025taste
Suggests skipping it if food is the priority, implying it caters more to photo-taking than eating.
- Recommendsu/LopsidedMagazine6399 in r/florence · Feb 2025
Names La Giostra among two amazing places to try, alongside Il Teatro.
- Recommendsu/BenchQuiet in r/florence · Oct 2024
Judged it far better than Buca Mario in their opinion.
- Caveatu/justkeepholding in r/florence · Feb 2024price
Advises skipping La Giostra; finds it pricey and more for tourists than locals.
- Mixedu/MutedEmu2317 in r/florence · Nov 2025value
Enjoyed the ravioli and ambience but rest unmemorable and most expensive meal in the city.
- Recommendsu/LingonberryOne5458 in r/florence · Sep 2024taste
Called it the top meal of their Italy trip, praising hospitality, freshness, pear ravioli and tiramisu.
- Recommendsu/mbkerrigan in r/florence · Apr 2024
Calls La Giostra very special.
- Recommendsu/Loveadovie in r/florence · Apr 2024taste
Loves this place and points to its dessert and a pear pasta dish as standouts.
- Recommendsu/swimbikerunnerd in r/florence · Apr 2024taste
Calls it one of the finest meals they've had.
- Recommendsu/wrk592 in r/florence · Feb 2024
Called it wonderful.
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 16 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.