Skip to content

La Giostra

32 people recommend, 22 warn against itvia r/florence, r/ItalyTravel30 comments cited below

The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 27 threads.

What people say, in short

Many diners recommend La Giostra for its food, with several praising the pear ravioli and a couple recommending the tiramisu. One diner ranked the steak as the best of their week, though service gets mixed reports. Many others were disappointed, with a couple finding the pear ravioli bland or tasting of raw flour and several finding it pricey. A couple say it leans toward tourists.

Address

La Giostra, Borgo Pinti, 16 R, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy

At a glance

Price
Premium
Signature dishes
Pear ravioli, Tiramisu, Steak
Opinions divided
Yes

Nearby on this map

Other places on this map closest to La Giostra, as the crow flies.

The evidence

Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.

  • Recommendsu/WordStream33 in r/florence · Oct 2025taste

    Calls La Giostra top-tier, praising its pear ravioli, service and wine.

  • Caveatu/Literally_whatever69 in r/florence · Nov 2025taste

    Famous pear ravioli tasted like raw flour even after sending back; says better, cheaper Italian food exists elsewhere.

  • Recommendsu/Ill_Proposal190 in r/florence · Jul 2026

    Names it as a favorite restaurant recommendation.

  • Caveatu/TurboAljo in r/florence · Jul 2026taste

    Warned others off after a bad experience.

  • Caveatu/ceruleansuperfruit in r/florence · Oct 2025taste

    Found the pear ravioli bland, called it a low point of the trip, and said service was poor.

  • Caveatu/HelpfulScholar222 in r/florence · Apr 2024

    Says La Giostra gets lots of hype but did not impress them.

  • Recommendsu/nyc2everywhere in r/florence · Mar 2025

    Suggests ending a sunset outing with dinner at La Giostra after crossing a bridge.

  • Mixedu/Tiny-Preference3020 in r/florence · Jun 2025value

    Had a lovely visit, but says the cost is hard to justify for an experience that can be hit or miss.

Show all 30 cited comments
  • Caveatu/motherofdragi in r/ItalyTravel · Apr 2025taste

    Says their group's least favourite meal on a two-week Italy trip was at this restaurant.

  • Recommendsu/brooklynOG in r/florence · Feb 2025taste

    Concedes hype and influencer crowds, still strongly endorses it, and says the tiramisu was excellent.

  • Caveatu/ExpensiveAstronaut65 in r/florence · Nov 2025

    Found the meal just average at best, with nothing standing out.

  • Mixedu/Adventurous-Rub7636 in r/florence · Nov 2025consistency

    First visit excellent, second average; aimed at tourists and won't return.

  • Recommendsu/garden_girlie in r/florence · Oct 2025taste

    Visited and loved the meal, calling the pear ravioli fantastic and the visit a memorable experience.

  • Caveatu/Itaney in r/florence · Apr 2025taste

    Underwhelmed despite its hype.

  • Caveatu/UGA150 in r/florence · Feb 2025

    Strongly negative: describes a crowded, herd-like feel, poor service and unremarkable food; calls it overrated.

  • Recommendsu/Evening-Sir6460 in r/ItalyTravel · Sep 2024taste

    Says they visited La Giostra in Florence and recommends it for its food and the atmosphere.

  • Recommendsu/Reckoner08 in r/florence · Apr 2024taste

    Recommends this place for bistecca fiorentina.

  • Recommendsu/maganaise in r/florence · Feb 2026

    Says it is pretty good but notes it is expensive.

  • Recommendsu/Cute_Telephone1418 in r/florence · Nov 2025taste

    Really enjoyed the food; the steak was the best all week and service was great.

  • Caveatu/vinovibez in r/florence · Jun 2025

    Agrees with the criticism and says their own meal there was the worst of their trip, with the wine also poor.

  • Caveatu/darkseries87 in r/florence · Feb 2025taste

    Suggests skipping it if food is the priority, implying it caters more to photo-taking than eating.

  • Recommendsu/LopsidedMagazine6399 in r/florence · Feb 2025

    Names La Giostra among two amazing places to try, alongside Il Teatro.

  • Recommendsu/BenchQuiet in r/florence · Oct 2024

    Judged it far better than Buca Mario in their opinion.

  • Caveatu/justkeepholding in r/florence · Feb 2024price

    Advises skipping La Giostra; finds it pricey and more for tourists than locals.

  • Mixedu/MutedEmu2317 in r/florence · Nov 2025value

    Enjoyed the ravioli and ambience but rest unmemorable and most expensive meal in the city.

  • Recommendsu/LingonberryOne5458 in r/florence · Sep 2024taste

    Called it the top meal of their Italy trip, praising hospitality, freshness, pear ravioli and tiramisu.

  • Recommendsu/mbkerrigan in r/florence · Apr 2024

    Calls La Giostra very special.

  • Recommendsu/Loveadovie in r/florence · Apr 2024taste

    Loves this place and points to its dessert and a pear pasta dish as standouts.

  • Recommendsu/swimbikerunnerd in r/florence · Apr 2024taste

    Calls it one of the finest meals they've had.

  • Recommendsu/wrk592 in r/florence · Feb 2024

    Called it wonderful.

Did this page answer your question?

Freshness

Details last checked 16 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.

Follow @mapswemade for new maps