Vini e Vecchi Sapori
39 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/ItalyTravel, r/florence30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 31 threads.
What people say, in short
Vini e Vecchi Sapori is a Florence osteria that many diners call a favorite, and a few single out the duck ragù. A few praise the atmosphere. Booking is the common difficulty: several advise reserving ahead, and a few say a table is hard to get. Dissent is limited: one diner calls it only decent, no better than comparable places, and another enjoyed the food but had a poor experience with the service.
Address
Vini e Vecchi Sapori, Via dei Magazzini, 3/r, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Duck ragù
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Vini e Vecchi Sapori, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/Hoppy_Smoker in r/ItalyTravel · Apr 2024taste
Says this was the best tripe they had in Florence and possibly their favorite restaurant meal there.
- Recommendsu/Fun-Sheepherder-8637 in r/florence · Oct 2026
Presents this traditional restaurant as worth a visit, citing guests who recommend it, and suggests booking ahead.
- Recommendsu/jigolden in r/ItalyTravel · Mar 2025
Included in the commenter's list of personal favorite Florence restaurants.
- Recommendsu/ap04117 in r/ItalyTravel · Feb 2025taste
Calls it a must-visit and says the duck ragu stays on their mind.
- Recommendsu/True_Blue12 in r/florence · May 2025ambience
Says it felt less touristy than other places they tried, with friendly people running it; advises booking ahead.
- Caveatu/RewardingGoblin in r/florence · Oct 2026wait time
Says it lacks online booking, doesn't answer the phone, and was fully booked for about a week on an in-person visit.
- Recommendsu/chr0103 in r/florence · May 2026
Loved the place enough to return for a second meal, the only restaurant they revisited on the trip.
- Recommendsu/Shelpooner in r/florence · Jul 2026
Says it is popular for a reason, including with locals, and defends it against the critic.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Otherwise-Relief2248 in r/florence · Jul 2026
Recommends it as a favorite osteria.
- Recommendsu/omgggitssteph in r/florence · Sep 2025
Calls Vini e Vecchi their best dinner of a three-week Italy trip, a must despite phone-booking hassle.
- Recommendsu/AspiringSkiBum in r/florence · Jul 2024
Recommends this place as a better choice after a disappointing meal elsewhere.
- Recommendsu/musashi66 in r/florence · Jun 2024
Recommends it, advising you to try to secure a reservation first.
- Recommendsu/Mamac911 in r/florence · Oct 2026taste
Found it a fun experience and rated the pasta highly.
- Recommendsu/Due-Advantage-4755 in r/florence · Sep 2026taste
Ranked their zucchini flower dish as the finest pasta eaten during the whole trip.
- Caveatu/EndroF12 in r/florence · Sep 2025service
Says this place is notoriously hard to book and suggests asking a concierge to handle it.
- Recommendsu/dankmangos in r/florence · May 2025taste
Agrees and says they had to reorder the duck ragù pappardelle because it was so good.
- Caveatu/Narrow-Pea-9726 in r/florence · Sep 2026taste
Found it crowded with tourists and the food only average.
- Recommendsu/LatterInvestment8405 in r/florence · Aug 2026
Pushes back, calling it among the finest in town with excellent staff, and suggests the critic is at fault.
- Recommendsu/aaronstasis in r/florence · May 2026
Says it impressed them, especially the duck ragù and the atmosphere.
- Recommendsu/croissantfufu in r/ItalyTravel · Feb 2026
Says they really loved their own meal at this restaurant.
- Recommendsu/90percentofacorns in r/florence · Feb 2026
Offered as the second of two dinner suggestions, without detail.
- Recommendsu/thepuckstop in r/florence · Jan 2026taste
Calls it a must, praising the food, service and atmosphere; it was their favorite Florence meal.
- Mixedu/thewazbaz in r/florence · Sep 2025
Dismisses the praise as hype; calls the place only decent, no better than comparable spots.
- Recommendsu/RevolutionarySky6344 in r/florence · Jun 2025
Agrees, says they ate there three times and that reservations are needed.
- Recommendsu/stingone in r/florence · Jun 2025
Agrees, says it may be their favorite in Florence, and they visit it whenever they are in the city.
- Recommendsu/exp6261928 in r/florence · May 2025
Agrees and calls it their favorite Florence restaurant, praising the food and vibe; suggests ordering the pici.
- Recommendsu/notveryvery in r/ItalyTravel · Feb 2025
Says it is their favorite restaurant anywhere.
- Recommendsu/suchgarbage in r/ItalyTravel · Sep 2024taste
Ate there twice on a three-night stay; loved the pasta and the friendly staff.
- Recommendsu/leanderdsg in r/florence · Jun 2024
Suggests it as a second choice after Cammillo, implying it is also a good option.
- Mixedu/Alternative_Gap_2517 in r/florence · Aug 2024service
Visited; food was good, but had a poor experience with the waitstaff.
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 16 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.