Alley Cats, Marylebone
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itcounted across its outletsvia r/LondonFood, r/london, r/AskLondon18 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Alley Cats is recommended across its London outlets, with Marylebone directly named. Fans put it among their preferred American-style pizzas, while one Marylebone visitor particularly enjoys the marinara. Texture divides diners: one describes it as crisper than a typical New York slice, another enjoys it but finds it greasy, and a third likes the pizza overall despite wanting more flavour in the dough. One diner simply does not rate it.
Address
Alley Cats Pizza, 22 Paddington St, London W1U 5QY, United Kingdom
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Marinara pizza
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Alley Cats, Marylebone, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/HighFivePuddy in r/LondonFood · Mar 2026
Recommends Alley Cat's for NY style pizza.
- Recommendsu/johnmk3 in r/london · Apr 2024
Lists it as an honorable mention.
- Mixedu/majinz in r/LondonFood · Jun 2025
Places Alley Cats towards the bottom of a personal pizza tour.
- Recommendsu/PM-me-your-cuppa-tea in r/LondonFood · Jun 2025
Suggests Alley Cats pizza as a fun option for a family lunch.
- Mixedu/mrchososo in r/LondonFood · Jan 2026taste
Finds Alley Cats greasier than a typical NY slice, though still delicious.
- Caveatu/wine-o-saur in r/LondonFood · Jan 2026
Was not impressed by Alley Cats and prefers other NY-style spots.
- Recommendsu/Ro-see in r/LondonFood · Dec 2025
Had Alley Cats recently and really enjoyed it.
- Recommendsu/alphadelta90210 in r/LondonFood · Jun 2026taste
Is a big fan of Alley Cats pizza.
Show all 18 cited comments
- Recommendsu/RabbitContrarian in r/LondonFood · Jan 2026taste
A New York transplant found it good, though the dough lacks some flavour.
- Recommendsu/West-Entrance2399 in r/LondonFood · Dec 2025
Decent pizza in Marylebone.
- Recommendsu/THE_IRL_JESUS in r/LondonFood · Dec 2025
Named among favourite American-style pizzas in London.
- Recommendsu/Lovethosebeanz in r/LondonFood · Oct 2026taste
Recommends their marinara pizza.
- Recommendsu/GBLONDON68 in r/AskLondon · Sep 2026
Has one near them in west London and says it's very good.
- Recommendsu/Secret-Tangelo-6409 in r/AskLondon · Sep 2026
Recommends Alley Cats Pizza.
- Recommendsu/terminalterror in r/LondonFood · May 2026taste
Enjoyed the Marylebone pizzas after reserving, especially the marinara.
- Recommendsu/Usual_Stage_8677 in r/LondonFood · Mar 2026
Recommends Alley Cats, specifically the Chelsea one.
- Recommendsu/WhatWhereWhat22 in r/LondonFood · Feb 2026
Names Alley Cats Pizza as a recommendation.
- Recommendsu/Rough_Champion7852 in r/LondonFood · Dec 2025
Also seconds the Alley Cats recommendation.
More maps in London, United Kingdom
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 9 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.