Fellini's Pizza, Buckhead
33 people recommend, 5 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/Atlanta, r/Georgia, r/AtlantaEats30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 13 threads.
What people say, in short
Fellini's draws recommendations across its Atlanta outlets for affordable pizza, with Buckhead among the branches explicitly discussed. These are pooled brand opinions rather than a verdict on every outlet. Diners mention Sicilian and white pies. Criticism includes dry or disappointing slices and reheating problems; one commenter recommends ordering a whole pie instead of a slice. Historical late-night recommendations are not a guarantee of current hours.
Address
Fellini's Pizza, 2809 Peachtree Rd, Atlanta, GA 30305
At a glance
- Price
- Budget
- Signature dishes
- Sicilian pie, White pizza
- Best for
- Late night, Budget
- Opinions divided
- Yes
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/beesinabiscuit in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Commenter says they like Fellini's.
- Recommendsu/Own-Reflection-8182 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Commenter says the Buckhead location is great.
- Recommendsu/whirling_cynic in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026price
Commenter says the Candler Park location is good on price.
- Recommendsu/ssagar186 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
One person thought the Howell Mill location was among the better pizza places around Atlanta.
- Recommendsu/Drivo566 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026consistency
Commenter says the Buckhead location has always been great.
- Recommendsu/RiveredSet in r/Atlanta · Feb 2026taste
Suggests Fellini's if you like that style of pizza.
- Recommendsu/MostlyMK in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
A commenter notes the chain has several locations, all open until at least midnight and some until 2am.
- Recommendsu/KobaTheGreat in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026value
Praises the pizza as tasty and inexpensive.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/bplzizcool in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026consistency
Someone who eats at the Candler Park location says it has been their regular spot for years.
- Recommendsu/arcticlizard in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Used to be a late-night go-to.
- Recommendsu/drummerboy2749 in r/Georgia · Dec 2023
Recommended specifically for pizza among favorite city spots.
- Recommendsu/madig010 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Commenter says the Ponce location will always be their favorite.
- Recommendsu/potatoriot in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024
Listed among pizza options on the northern edge of Midtown.
- Recommendsu/No_Pension1005 in r/AtlantaEats · Dec 2025wait time
Personally prefers Fellini's and says the wait isn't bad.
- Recommendsu/RealName136 in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024
Recommends the Fellini's off Buckhead.
- Recommendsu/snail_garden in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Commenter strongly defends Fellini's against detractors.
- Mixedu/drumming4coffee in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026consistency
Commenter says slices can be overcooked but whole pies are usually good.
- Recommendsu/EyesSlammedShut in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026ambience
Commenter misses the Candler location, praising slices and beer when weather is nice.
- Recommendsu/pina_koala in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Commenter says Candler Park edges out a win.
- Mixedu/gte615e in r/AtlantaEats · Dec 2025taste
A commenter calls Fellini's great but thinks comparing it to Antico is a stretch.
- Recommendsu/ucancallmevicky in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026value
Commenter says the Sicilian is cheap for its size and amazing.
- Caveatu/Spongemage in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Says they don't like Fellini's at all.
- Recommendsu/Automatic_Bee150 in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Calls these old-school picks really good.
- Caveatu/BeardySpice89 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Calls Fellini's pizza dry.
- Recommendsu/l0ktar0gar in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Loves this quintessential Atlanta pizza spot.
- Recommendsu/PsychologicalCell500 in r/Atlanta · Jul 2024
Listed among late-night recommendations.
- Recommendsu/Sup_Moze_392 in r/Atlanta · Oct 2024taste
Loves the white pizza and that Midtown is open until midnight daily.
- Recommendsu/Huncho2454 in r/Atlanta · Mar 2024
Calls Fellini's their go-to pizza.
- Caveatu/CPG135 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026
Calls Fellini's crap.
- Caveatu/delk82 in r/Atlanta · Jan 2026taste
Calls it possibly the worst pizza they've ever had.
Also on
Fellini's Pizza, Buckhead is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Atlanta, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 11 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.