Thrift stores in Chicago
16 thrift stores that Chicago locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Chicago thrift and resale recommendations, with the listed shop distinguished from praise for a chain's other branches.
Drawn from real discussions in r/AskChicago, r/chicago and r/ThriftStoreHauls — 16 thrift stores in Chicago that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around Andersonville, Lakeview, Logan Square and Avondale.
How this map is made: Built from 209 Reddit comments across 195 people in r/AskChicago, r/chicago and r/ThriftStoreHauls. Last refreshed November 16, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 16 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.Village Discount Outlet, Andersonville
91 people recommend, 20 warn against itvia r/chicago, r/AskChicago
People recommend the Village Discount Outlet shops across Chicago; this is the Andersonville one on Clark Street, though commenters also name the Roscoe Village, Armitage and Milwaukee, and Western stops. Many call them budget-friendly, and several say good finds take digging through racks. Many also say prices have crept up, and a few say it is no longer cheap.
Andersonville
- RecommendsSays they can find low-priced items there and lists it alongside a few other shops. r/chicago, Dec 2025
- CaveatSays the shop raised its prices and is no longer affordable for them. r/chicago, Dec 2025
2.The Brown Elephant, Andersonville
72 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
People recommend the Brown Elephant shops; this is the Andersonville one on Clark Street, and others name the Belmont and Halsted shop in Lakeview. A couple of people point to its furniture, a couple praise its vintage finds, and several list it among the Andersonville stores along Clark Street. Caveats: a couple of people say selection is hit or miss, and a few say it costs more than other thrift shops.
Andersonville
- RecommendsSays it's a good place to shop for furniture. r/AskChicago, Jun 2025
- CaveatConsiders Brown Elephant overpriced. r/AskChicago, Jun 2025
3.The Salvation Army, Clybourn
27 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskChicago, r/ThriftStoreHauls, r/chicago
Many people recommend the Salvation Army shop on Clybourn in Lincoln Park (this one); a couple name the Montrose and Broadway shop and a couple the Devon shop. Many call the Clybourn shop a favorite or go-to spot, and several praise its selection of quality clothing. Price is the main caveat: many find it pricey, with a few calling it overpriced or aggressively priced.
Clybourn
- RecommendsCustomer suggests this Lincoln Park branch as a strong pick for finding good items. r/AskChicago, Nov 2025
- CaveatCalls the store's pricing aggressive. r/ThriftStoreHauls, Oct 2026
4.Unique Thrift, Elston
27 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/chicago, r/AskChicago
People recommend Unique Thrift; most who name a shop mean the one on Elston near Kimball (this one), while several name the Halsted shop in Bridgeport. A few say it is well organized, and several mention its clothing selection. Many say prices are high for a thrift shop, and one says most items are not worth buying. One commenter says the Uptown shop has closed.
Elston
- RecommendsLists this Elston shop among places where they find low-priced items. r/chicago, Dec 2025
- CaveatSays the shop is overpriced. r/AskChicago, Apr 2026
5.Habitat for Humanity ReStore, North Park
18 people recommendvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
Many people recommend Habitat for Humanity ReStore for secondhand furniture; most who name a shop mean the Pulaski and Peterson one on the North Side (this one), and a few mention other branches. Several call it the best place for used furniture, and a couple call it a budget-friendly way to furnish a home. One commenter says it has good tables, chairs, desks and dressers but would skip used couches and soft goods.
North Park
- RecommendsSuggests this North Side ReStore for particular furniture or household items. r/AskChicago, Jun 2025
6.Goodwill, West Loop
16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskChicago
Most commenters recommend Goodwill, and most who name a shop mean the West Loop one on Washington (this one); a couple name the Grand Avenue shop. A few say it has higher-quality stock than typical thrift shops, and one calls it elite. Caveats: one commenter says resellers crowd the store and take the best items, another found it disorganized with merchandise scattered, and one says it costs more than other thrift shops they have tried.
West Loop
- RecommendsSuggests checking out the West Loop Goodwill branch as a spot to find secondhand items. r/AskChicago, Apr 2025
- CaveatCustomer says resellers crowd this Goodwill and grab the best items, so they've stopped going. r/AskChicago, Nov 2025
7.Buffalo Exchange, Andersonville
12 people recommendvia r/AskChicago
Many people recommend Buffalo Exchange; this is the Andersonville shop on Clark Street, and several others name the Wicker Park shop on Milwaukee Avenue. Several list it among the Andersonville thrift shops within walking distance on Clark Street, and a couple call it great. A couple say its stock is curated, and one says it costs more than a traditional thrift shop.
Andersonville
- RecommendsLists this shop's Milwaukee Ave location among the places to check out near Damen and Division. r/AskChicago, Jul 2026
8.Out of the Closet, Lakeview
11 people recommendvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
People recommend Out of the Closet, a thrift shop on Halsted in Lakeview and Boystown; one commenter also mentions a Hyde Park shop. A few describe it as affordable, and one says it is hit or miss.
Lakeview
- RecommendsSuggests Out of the Closet as another Lakeview spot to try. r/AskChicago, Dec 2025
- MixedCalls it inconsistent but fairly priced; might find something there. r/AskChicago, Jun 2025
9.Mount Sinai Resale Shop, Lakeview
11 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
Many commenters recommend Mount Sinai Resale Shop on Clark in Lakeview, and a couple point to its furniture. Two commenters say prices are too high, and one says the Clark shop is less orderly and roomy than the Out of the Closet shop.
Lakeview
- RecommendsListed under East Lakeview as a good secondhand shopping option. r/AskChicago, Jul 2024
- CaveatSays the store should fix its pricing, since it gets clothes still new with tags and marks them down only slightly. r/chicago, Mar 2024
10.Monarch Thrift, Avondale
10 people recommendvia r/AskChicago
Monarch Thrift is a thrift shop in Avondale that many people recommend, and several list it among the Avondale shops along Milwaukee Avenue. A couple describe it as low-priced or good value, and one says it sells household items and clothes.
Avondale
- RecommendsNames Monarch as a good stop along the same Milwaukee Avenue walk. r/AskChicago, Nov 2024
11.Kokorokoko, Wicker Park
10 people recommendvia r/AskChicago
Kokorokoko is a vintage clothing shop on Milwaukee Avenue in Wicker Park that many people recommend. A few say it focuses on 80s and 90s pieces, and one calls it one of the oldest well-regarded vintage stores. One commenter says it is curated rather than thrift-priced and also sells collectibles.
Wicker Park
- RecommendsCalls Kokorokoko a favorite spot for vintage finds, in a Wicker Park context. r/AskChicago, Jul 2026
12.Green Element, Edgewater
10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
Many people recommend Green Element, a resale shop on Broadway in Edgewater; one calls it a real thrift store with plenty of clothing, furniture and books, and one calls it a hidden gem. One says it has plenty of kitchen items and home supplies. On price, one says most items are inexpensive and one finds the furniture priced too high.
Edgewater
- RecommendsA customer loves Green Element, a real thrift store with plenty of clothing, furniture and books. r/AskChicago, Jan 2024
- CaveatSays the store's furniture is priced too high. r/AskChicago, Aug 2025
13.Lost Girls Vintage, Logan Square
9 people recommendvia r/AskChicago
Lost Girls Vintage is a vintage clothing shop that many people recommend; commenters mostly mean the Logan Square shop on Sawyer Avenue, one of its two shops (the other is on Division Street), and a few list it among the vintage stops along Milwaukee Avenue. One calls it great for vintage dresses, another says it is organized by decade, and one says it carries both new and vintage items. One commenter finds it somewhat pricey.
Logan Square
- RecommendsNamed as the end point of a run of organized vintage shops along Milwaukee Ave. r/AskChicago, Jul 2026
- MixedCalls Lost Girls good but found it somewhat pricey, depending on what a shopper is looking for. r/AskChicago, Nov 2024
14.El Dorado Thrift, Logan Square
7 people recommendvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
Many people recommend El Dorado, a thrift shop on Milwaukee Avenue in Logan Square, and a couple say it is reasonably priced. One says it is small and hit or miss but has some great pieces, and one notes it is mostly women's items with a decent men's section.
Logan Square
- RecommendsCustomer describes this Logan Square shop as a cute boutique-style thrift with reasonable pricing. r/AskChicago, Nov 2025
15.Elliott's Consignment, Lakeview
5 people recommendvia r/AskChicago
Five people recommend Elliott's Consignment, which commenters say has shops in Lakeview and Lincoln Park; this is the Broadway shop in Lakeview. One says its quality and selection beat typical thrift stores, one says it has plenty of formal wear, and one has found men's designer shirts there. One says items are pricier than at a thrift store.
Lakeview
- RecommendsLists this consignment store's Lincoln Park location among suggestions. r/AskChicago, Sep 2024
16.Ragstock, Belmont
5 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskChicago, r/chicago
Five people name Ragstock, a clothing store on Belmont in Lakeview that commenters list among Chicago's thrift stores; it also sells new clothing. One has found good items there and one lists it as an option that sometimes has sports merchandise. One commenter says it has become pricier than a big-box chain.
Belmont
- RecommendsNamed among the top thrift stores in the city, as a suggestion for someone seeking thrift shopping. r/AskChicago, Jan 2026
- CaveatSays the shop used to offer good deals but now costs more than a big-box chain. r/chicago, Dec 2025
Questions people ask
- Which thrift stores do Chicago locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are Village Discount Outlet, Andersonville, The Brown Elephant, Andersonville and The Salvation Army, Clybourn, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 209 comments from 195 people across r/AskChicago, r/chicago and r/ThriftStoreHauls. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 16, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
Chicago
Best burgers
Chicago burger recommendations, from smash burgers to tavern picks, with source conversations, outlet context and caveats.
Open the mapChicago
Best cafés
Chicago cafés and coffee shops discussed for espresso, pour-over and coffee stops, with the original recommendations and caveats.
Open the mapChicago
Best breakfast
Chicago breakfast recommendations covering diners, pancakes, skillets and morning meals, with cited local opinions and reservations.
Open the mapChicago
Best bars
Chicago bar recommendations spanning whiskey, cocktails and beer, with the original praise and caveats for each place.
Open the mapChicago
Best sushi
Chicago sushi recommendations, from all-you-can-eat restaurants to omakase, with the cited reasons and mixed views behind each pick.
Open the mapChicago
Indian restaurants
Chicago-area Indian restaurant recommendations, from tasting menus to spicy neighborhood favorites, with cited dish suggestions and the disagreements diners report.
Open the mapChicago
Best brunch
Chicago brunch recommendations, including French toast, grits and breakfast pastries, with diners' own praise and reservations about the food and setting.
Open the mapChicago
Best seafood
Chicago-area seafood recommendations, from oyster bars to smoked-fish counters, with cited dish suggestions and mixed opinions on particular orders.
Open the mapChicago
Bookstores
Chicago bookshops for used-book browsing and out-of-print finds, with cited opinions on selection, shop layouts and differences between locations.
Open the mapChicago
Parks
Chicago parks and green spaces, including conservatory visits and riverside trails, with cited recommendations for family outings and differing reports on crowds.
Open the mapChicago
Best steak
Chicago steak recommendations, from classic steakhouses and Argentinian grills to breaded steak sandwiches, with the disagreements behind each pick.
Open the mapChicago
Museums
Chicago museum recommendations, from major art and natural-history collections to smaller neighborhood museums, with the source discussions and caveats behind each pick.
Open the mapChicago
Best pizza
Chicago pizza recommendations, from deep dish and caramelized pan crusts to thin-crust slices, with the source conversations and disagreements behind each place.
Open the mapChicago
Best ramen
Chicago ramen recommendations, including Akahoshi, Wasabi and Oiistar, with the source discussions about bowls, noodles and broth.
Open the mapChicago
Best restaurants
For a Chicago meal, people suggest Bavette's for its steakhouse atmosphere (though not everyone prefers the steak), Red Hot Ranch for a late-night burger, Paulie Gee's for Detroit-style pizza, Lou Mitchell's for breakfast and donut holes, Daisies for fresh pasta and La Scarola for generous portions.
Open the mapChicago
Places to visit
Chicago picks start at the Art Institute, for the Impressionists, the arms and armor galleries and the Chagall windows, and run to the free Lincoln Park Zoo and its winter lights, the Wrigley Field bleachers even if you don't follow baseball, the iron lung at the Museum of Surgical Science and summer strolls on the Chicago Riverwalk.
Open the map