Casola's Pizza
23 people recommend, 23 warn against itvia r/Miami, r/florida30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 16 threads.
What people say, in short
Casola's draws loyal fans and blunt critics. Many people name it as their pick, one regular calls it reliably good and better than in past years, and a few tie it to late-night slices. Many others say it has declined or call it poor, mediocre or worse, one remembering it fondly only under its original owners.
Address
Casola's, 2437 SW 17th Ave, Miami, FL 33145
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- NY style pizza
- Best for
- Late night
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Casola's Pizza, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Mixedu/vcsuviking10 in r/Miami · Oct 2026consistency
Remembers a cheese slice here as a late-night go-to, but only under its original owners.
- Recommendsu/rabidbyte in r/Miami · Jun 2024
Recommends Casola's Pizza.
- Caveatu/Big_Mike_305 in r/Miami · Oct 2024consistency
Says the place was much better before COVID, implying it has declined since.
- Recommendsu/deltastag94 in r/Miami · Sep 2024
Names Casola's as their pick.
- Caveatu/South_Bother_2498 in r/Miami · Jun 2026
Says the place has been poor for about ten years, pushing back on the praise.
- Caveatu/SnooHabits8782 in r/Miami · Mar 2026taste
Says Casola's is dogshit.
- Recommendsu/wehwhy in r/Miami · Jun 2026
Gives Casolas as a direct answer, with no detail.
- Caveatu/millionmilegoals in r/Miami · Oct 2024taste
Relays the article's harsh write-up of Casola's, citing its unflattering description and low ranking; not personal experience.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Caveatu/IceColdKila in r/Miami · Oct 2024taste
Calls Casola's bad and says they keep returning for the soda refills anyway.
- Caveatu/stephanproctor in r/Miami · Apr 2024taste
Calls Casola's garbage.
- Recommendsu/traylerswift in r/Miami · Jun 2026
Says they will stick with Casola's for life; a loyal fan.
- Caveatu/MusicianThin217 in r/Miami · Jun 2026
Has been to Casola's and says it was not their favorite.
- Caveatu/x_von_doom in r/Miami · Oct 2024consistency
Warned others off after a bad experience.
- Caveatu/FormalHappy2606 in r/Miami · Apr 2024consistency
Says Casola's has declined a bit in recent years.
- Caveatu/SeekerStudent101 in r/Miami · Dec 2023
Regrets Casola's decline and says it used to rank among Miami's top pizza spots.
- Recommendsu/mosasamo1310 in r/Miami · Oct 2026
Agrees with the post and endorses a Casola's slice as a good pick.
- Caveatu/biggesthoss in r/Miami · Jun 2026taste
Calls Casola's mediocre and says it falls well short of another NY-style spot.
- Caveatu/sinproph in r/Miami · Oct 2024
Says the score given to Casola's is the most generous it deserves.
- Caveatu/MamaGuava15 in r/Miami · Sep 2024hygiene
Warned others off after a bad experience.
- Mixedu/Vampire6King9 in r/Miami · Jun 2024taste
Heard the recipe changed, yet still calls it their favorite.
- Recommendsu/Cute-Character-795 in r/Miami · Aug 2026
Says the spot beyond the Metro Rail is unbeatable late at night.
- Recommendsu/crsmiami99 in r/Miami · Jun 2026
Points to Casola's, placing it just south of downtown.
- Recommendsu/Ok-Possibility-1206 in r/Miami · Jun 2026taste
Says the place near the Grove is fantastic and nothing else comes close for New York-style pizza.
- Recommendsu/Syria1911 in r/Miami · Sep 2024
Calls Casola's a staple for Grove locals.
- Recommendsu/Jakpot24 in r/Miami · Jun 2024taste
Stops by whenever visiting their aunt and says it's so good.
- Caveatu/gwizone in r/Miami · Dec 2023taste
Says the greasy slice only seems good late at night when very drunk.
- Recommendsu/snoopy_90s in r/Miami · Dec 2023consistency
Orders weekly and finds Casola's reliably good, better than in past years.
- Recommendsu/doyouevenbr0 in r/Miami · Sep 2024
Names Casola's as their answer.
- Recommendsu/HelpfulLog5706 in r/florida · Mar 2024portion
Notes the place offers a 24-inch size and calls it great.
- Recommendsu/blue_strawberryx in r/Miami · Dec 2023
Names Casola's as an answer to the best-pizza question.
More maps in Miami, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.