Best pizza in Miami

26 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Miami

Most who weigh in recommend Joe's Pizza, and many name the Wynwood location, the one shown on this map; the brand has other outlets too. Views on how it compares with the New York original are split: a couple say it matches or nearly matches it, and several say it falls short. A couple say it is good for a late-night slice. Other reactions: one calls it touristy but liked it, one says it is decent only when it is on form, and one says it is the only New York-style pizza they regularly buy in Miami.

Wynwood

23 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Miami, r/florida, r/Pizza

Most people who name Mister 01 recommend it, and several simply give it as their pick. It is a multi-outlet brand: the Wynwood location is the one shown on this map, and most comments do not say which outlet they mean. A couple describe it as a bar pie or craft pizza rather than traditional New York style, and one calls it the one reliably consistent spot. Caveats: one says it gets soggy quickly, one finds it good but overpriced, and one says it is not worth the time.

Wynwood

23 people recommend, 23 warn against itvia r/Miami, r/florida

Casola's draws loyal fans and blunt critics. Many people name it as their pick, one regular calls it reliably good and better than in past years, and a few tie it to late-night slices. Many others say it has declined or call it poor, mediocre or worse, one remembering it fondly only under its original owners.

15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Miami

Most people who name Lucali recommend it, and many include it among their picks. A couple go further: one calls it the best pizza in South Florida and another says it has no close second. A few place it in South Beach or Sunset Harbour, one calling it a-okay and the others good. One says there is a lot of dry crust.

South Beach

11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Miami

Many diners recommend Fratesi's, and a couple name the downtown location: one calls it great, and another suggests it for thin bar-style pies and says to order the plain pie. Caveats: one thinks it is more New Jersey than New York style and middling, one says it is fine but was not blown away, and one cites its crust as too stiff.

Downtown

11 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/Miami

Most who name Eleventh Street Pizza recommend it, and many include it among their picks for slices or elevated New York-style pizza. One says they choose it every time, and another was happy on a first visit and plans to return. Caveats: two diners avoid it because of a mandatory tip added to takeout orders, and one thinks it is not worth it beyond a delivery-app deal.

10 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Miami

Most who name Marc's Artisanal Pizza recommend it, and several include it among their Miami picks. One calls the pizza incredible and notes both thin round and thicker Roman-style pies, and one calls it the best in Miami-Dade. One says it now has a line around the block, and one says they asked for a well-done pie and were told it is not offered there.

9 people recommendcounted across its outletsvia r/Miami

People recommend Pummarola across its Miami outlets; the Midtown location is the one shown on this map, which a couple of diners name, while one mentions The Falls and another the Gables. One calls it a gem with good value, another calls it the best in Miami and perhaps the best pizza they have had anywhere, and one describes it as a strong Neapolitan-style pie.

Midtown

7 people recommendvia r/Miami

Several people recommend Pauloluigi in Coconut Grove, mostly by name. One suggests it for traditional pizza and another describes it as New York-style, one calls it the only affordable spot, and one calls it the best independent pizza place across Miami-Dade. A mixed view finds it good but sometimes too salty.

Coconut Grove

6 people recommendvia r/Miami

People recommend O'Munaciello. It has more than one outlet: one names the Coral Way location and another points to MiMo, which is the one shown on this map, and the rest do not say which they mean. Some describe it as Neapolitan or Italian-style, one calls it probably the best on their list, one suggests it for a fancier meal that is a drive from South Miami.

6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Pizza, r/Miami, r/florida

Several people recommend Pizza Bar, and a couple name its South Beach location. A few say it is good value or affordable, and a few point to its large size. Caveats: two find the slices pricey, one finds the pie unappealing to look at, and one found the first few inches of crust soft but liked the rest.

South Beach

5 people recommendvia r/Miami

Five people recommend La Leggenda, a Neapolitan-style pizzeria on Espanola Way. Two give it as their one answer, one calls it outstanding, and one who liked it says it was the only place they enjoyed nearby, though they add that its Neapolitan style does not hit the spot for a crispy-slice craving.

Espanola Way