NY Pie
20 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/nashville22 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Most people recommend NY Pie, with many saying it serves good New York-style pizza and a few singling out the Sriracha chicken pie. One commenter says the white pizza is the standout on the menu. Views on price are split: one commenter calls it pricey, while a couple of others find it budget-friendly. One says they have repeatedly been let down by it.
Address
NY Pie (Nashville), 6800 Charlotte Pike #105, Nashville, TN 37209
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Sriracha chicken, White pizza
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/partyhatsmileyface in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Grandma slice arrived very hot with flavorful sauce and a great cheese pull; char could be crisper.
- Recommendsu/Valiant-For-Truth in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Says the commenter and their spouse really like NY Pie.
- Recommendsu/Shade2001 in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Recommends NY Pie for a New York-style slice.
- Recommendsu/Pitiful-Toe-6988 in r/nashville · May 2026
Gives a terse one-line endorsement of NY Pie.
- Recommendsu/catmama1713 in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Calls NY Pie their household go-to and likes it more than Five Points.
- Recommendsu/Chris__P_Bacon in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Says NY Pie is overlooked and its white pizza is its best dish.
- Recommendsu/MissionSalamander5 in r/nashville · Nov 2023taste
Strongly favors NY Pie, both its American-style and New York-style pizzas.
- Recommendsu/peezuhparty in r/nashville · Nov 2023taste
Suggests NY Pie for New York-style pizza.
Show all 22 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Mets081234 in r/nashville · Nov 2024
NJ native says NY Pie feels closest to home and would rank it highest of these.
- Recommendsu/BootlegBabyJsus in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Says NY Pie's sriracha chicken is also very good.
- Caveatu/citylimitband in r/nashville · May 2025price
Says NY Pie is priced above comparable NYC shops.
- Recommendsu/PashaCello in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Rates NY Pie more favorably than the pizza comparison being discussed.
- Recommendsu/erichimmelreich in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Emphatically endorses NY Pie.
- Caveatu/s_l_e_e_p_y_g_a_l in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Repeatedly disappointed by NY Pie.
- Recommendsu/jeshaffer2 in r/nashville · Nov 2023taste
Endorses NY Pie and recommends its Sriracha chicken.
- Recommendsu/jonneygee in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Likes NY Pie and rates it in the top tier.
- Recommendsu/TheSupremeHobo in r/nashville · May 2026taste
Says NY Pie is somewhat cheaper and far better in their view.
- Recommendsu/lonekthx in r/nashville · May 2025value
Calls NYPie solid and a bit more affordable.
- Recommendsu/count_montecristo in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Says NY Pie is where they got their fix and they love its Sicilian style.
- Recommendsu/scottydanger22 in r/nashville · Nov 2024
Calls NY Pie the best in town and suggests ordering it well done.
- Recommendsu/Thedevilspizza in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Calls NY Pie their personal favorite, nearest to authentic New York pizza, good enough to curb cravings.
- Recommendsu/spred_browneye in r/nashville · Nov 2024taste
Urges a return visit to NY Pie for its chicken-sriracha pie, promising satisfaction.
Also on
NY Pie is on another map too, with what people said about it there.
More maps in Nashville, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 4 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.