Porgy's Seafood, Carrollton
8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans12 comments cited below
What people say, in short
Porgy's is a seafood market with a restaurant, and most diners recommend it. A couple praise its tuna muffuletta, and a couple suggest it for seafood boils, though one found the crawfish poor on two visits. One diner calls its gumbo hearty, and two were unhappy with the shrimp po-boy.
Address
Porgy’s Seafood Market, 236 N Carrollton Ave, New Orleans, LA 70119
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Tuna muffuletta
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Porgy's Seafood, Carrollton, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/JohnChurchillChaser in r/AskNOLA · Nov 2024taste
Says Porgy's seafood is excellent across preparations, its tuna muffuletta is a standout, and prefers its food to Clesi's.
- Caveatu/ColdCorpseHotSecret in r/NewOrleans · Feb 2026taste
Had poor crawfish at Porgy's on two visits and thinks that is simply their method.
- Recommendsu/TherapyHam in r/AskNOLA · Nov 2024
Lists Porgy's among the best seafood places, though not necessarily boil spots.
- Recommendsu/Dry_Finger_8235 in r/NewOrleans · Mar 2024taste
Praised the tuna and a tuna muffuletta as a new favorite.
- Mixedu/antimoustache in r/NewOrleans · Mar 2024taste
Judged the shrimp po-boy very poor.
- Caveatu/RIP_Soulja_Slim in r/NewOrleans · Feb 2026value
Calls the shrimp po-boy tiny and says Porgy's is bad.
- Recommendsu/whereyat79 in r/NewOrleans · Aug 2026taste
Recommends this Carrollton seafood spot; calls its fish legit and well-handled, with cooking good enough to sit down for.
- Recommendsu/xnatlywouldx in r/AskNOLA · Aug 2026
Suggests this Mid-City spot for seafood boil instead of Quarter sit-down places the commenter finds underwhelming.
Show all 12 cited comments
- Recommendsu/Odd_Western1426 in r/AskNOLA · Sep 2025
Agrees with the Porgy's recommendation and calls the place awesome.
- Recommendsu/kilgore_trout72 in r/AskNOLA · Sep 2025taste
Says its crawfish boil is pretty good and that boiled crab is usually offered; mentions streetcar access.
- Recommendsu/drainalready in r/NewOrleans · Aug 2025taste
Agrees with the Porgy's pick, saying the meal was very good; also praises the potato salad.
- Mixedu/adventurousintrovert in r/NewOrleans · Jun 2024value
Finds the seafood gumbo pricey but praises its oyster count and how hearty it is.
More maps in New Orleans, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 17 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.