Best seafood in New Orleans
31 seafood restaurants that New Orleans locals recommend — the real reasons, and the caveats.
Seafood restaurants in New Orleans recommended in local discussions, with the cited reasons and catches for each place.
Drawn from real discussions in r/AskNOLA and r/NewOrleans — 31 seafood restaurants in New Orleans that people actually recommend. Each one shows why people rate it, the caveats they raised, and a link straight to the original comment — so you read the source yourself instead of trusting a laundered rating. Places cluster around French Quarter, Mid City, Bywater and Carrollton.
How this map is made: Built from 338 Reddit comments across 293 people in r/AskNOLA and r/NewOrleans. Last refreshed November 17, 2026. We paraphrase — never copy — and never take payment for a place. How we make our maps
Showing 31 places
Filters
Map
The map and place list use the same cited directory records. Every public entry has a stable Maps We Made ID and geopoint.
Places
1.Felix's Restaurant & Oyster Bar, French Quarter
25 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Most diners recommend Felix's, and many praise its chargrilled oysters, while several like sitting at the oyster bar for raw ones. A few say the entrees and other dishes are middling, one calls its BBQ shrimp po-boy a poor version of the dish, and a couple dislike or find its oysters mediocre. Felix's has a French Quarter restaurant and a Lakefront outlet; the listing here is the French Quarter one, and a couple of commenters name the Lakefront outlet instead.
French Quarter
- RecommendsPraises Felix's chargrilled oysters and says they are hard to stop eating. r/NewOrleans, Dec 2024
- CaveatCalls this BBQ shrimp po-boy a very poor version of the dish. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2024
2.Parkway Bakery & Tavern
22 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend Parkway, and many single out its fried shrimp po-boy, with several also praising the barbecue shrimp version. Several like the surf and turf. One diner says the shrimp is far from the best, and another notes that weekend lines are long and suggests a weekday lunch.
- RecommendsSays the fried BBQ shrimp po-boy stays moist from its sauce, even when ordered without mayo. r/AskNOLA, Jun 2025
- CaveatLikes Parkway's roast beef but thinks its shrimp is far from the best. r/AskNOLA, May 2024
3.Pêche Seafood Grill
22 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend Pêche, and a few praise its gumbo, its whole fish and its raw oysters. A few call it overrated, underwhelming or in decline. One diner finds the meal only okay unless ordering the whole fish with green sauce, and one notes the catfish and greens portion is small.
- RecommendsNames it among the better-liked places for grilled Gulf fish. r/AskNOLA, Jan 2025
- CaveatEndorses the earlier negative take and calls the place overrated. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2024
4.GW Fins, French Quarter
20 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend GW Fins, and many name it as a top seafood restaurant in the city. A couple each point to the lobster dumplings, the snapper wings and the Scalibut, and a couple praise its tuna dishes. One diner found it just fine and below what they expected.
French Quarter
- RecommendsCalls GW Fins a generally liked upscale option for grilled gulf fish. r/AskNOLA, Jan 2025
- CaveatFound GW Fins just fine and below expectations, and sent the smoked tuna dip back. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2025
5.Domilise's Po-Boy & Bar
16 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend Domilise's, and many name its shrimp, especially the shrimp po-boy. A few also point to the oyster po-boy. One diner found the food poor and the catfish po-boy disappointing, and one calls the shrimp pricey but worth it.
- RecommendsExpresses enthusiasm for Domilise's when it comes to seafood. r/AskNOLA, Feb 2026
- CaveatFound the food poor and the catfish po-boy disappointing. r/NewOrleans, Jan 2026
6.Mr. B's Bistro
15 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend Mr. B's, and many single out its barbecue shrimp, while a few also mention its gumbo ya ya. One diner calls a wedge-salad order with fried oysters on half a loaf their best oyster po-boy. Opinions on the shrimp and grits are split: one diner calls it the best they have had and another found it too sweet.
- RecommendsNames Mr. B's among seafood options to choose. r/AskNOLA, Sep 2025
- CaveatFelt the dish was overly sweet and didn't enjoy it. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2025
7.Liuzza's by the Track
15 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Most commenters recommend Liuzza's by the Track, and many praise the BBQ shrimp po-boy, while a couple also point to the garlic oyster po-boy. Several like the gumbo, though one finds it lighter and better as a starter than a meal. A few find the BBQ shrimp po-boy bland, small or like a bowl of sauce, and one found a shrimp po-boy bland and soggy.
- RecommendsSuggests a barbecue shrimp sandwich from this Liuzza's location as a good option. r/NewOrleans, Sep 2025
- CaveatFound the shrimp po-boy bland and soggy. r/NewOrleans, Aug 2024
8.Clesi's, Mid City
15 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend Clesi's in Mid-City, mostly for its crawfish boil, and a couple also mention boiled crab. Several find the crawfish underwhelming, tiny or less flavorful, and many call it pricey. One diner liked the crawfish but found the oysters poor, and another says it is strained by spring crowds.
Mid City
- RecommendsRecommends Clesi's for seafood boils and says shrimp and crab are on offer. r/AskNOLA, Nov 2024
- CaveatHas had mediocre to poor experiences there and says it does not justify its cost. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2026
9.MRB Bar & Kitchen, French Quarter
14 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend MRB, a bar on St Philip Street, most often for its chargrilled oysters. A few also praise the gumbo and a couple the fried catfish po-boy. Several mention the courtyard and outdoor seating.
French Quarter
- RecommendsPraises the chargrilled oysters and fried catfish po-boy at this casual courtyard window spot. r/AskNOLA, Nov 2024
10.Drago's Seafood Restaurant
14 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
The listing here is the Hilton riverside Drago's, which a couple of diners name; others who recommend the brand do not say which outlet they mean. Most diners recommend Drago's, and many praise its oysters, especially the chargrilled ones. A couple say the oysters are small, one says the fish can be overcooked, and one rates its chargrilled oysters below Acme's.
- RecommendsNamed the Lobster Marco as their favorite and says they order the seafood pasta in place of the oyster version. Branch not stated. r/NewOrleans, Jul 2025
- CaveatSays the place tends to overcook its fish. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2025
11.The Blue Crab, Lakefront
13 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend the lakefront Blue Crab, and a few praise its boiled seafood, while a couple single out the sauteed crab. Several mention the lake setting and view, and a couple like its drinks. One diner calls it pricey but tasty, and another found the oysters good but the rest of the food disappointing.
Lakefront
- RecommendsCalls it a local-taste spot praised for boiled and fried seafood, seafood gumbo and drinks; not fancy. r/AskNOLA, Dec 2025
- MixedFound the oysters good but the rest of the food disappointing. r/AskNOLA, May 2026
12.Casamento's Restaurant
13 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Most diners recommend Casamento's, and many praise its oysters, while a few point to its oyster and shrimp loaves. Two call it a reliable regular spot. One diner advises skipping it after an unimpressive visit, and another respects the family business but says the food is not even mid, with chargrilled oysters arriving cold on repeat visits.
- RecommendsSays the dressed oyster loaf is a must-try, with chargrilled oysters and an oyster shooter as add-ons. r/AskNOLA, Dec 2025
- CaveatAdvises skipping it after a visit where the food was unimpressive. r/AskNOLA, Dec 2025
13.Acme Oyster House
12 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNOLA
Acme is the French Quarter original on Iberville Street, the only Acme in the city. Most diners recommend it, and several praise its chargrilled oysters, while a couple like sitting at the oyster bar. A couple advise skipping it or say another place beats it on oysters, and one calls it good but expensive.
- RecommendsCalls Acme's chargrilled oysters decent and expects visitors to eat them there anyway. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2025
- CaveatSays Bourbon House beats this place on oysters and everything else. r/AskNOLA, Sep 2025
14.Guy's Po-Boys
11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Many diners rate the shrimp po-boy at Guy's highly, and a couple call it the best or among the best in town. One diner names the fried shrimp as their favorite and another enjoys the grilled shrimp. One found the shrimp po-boy mediocre and doesn't see the hype.
- RecommendsNames the shrimp po-boy there as a last-meal pick, which signals a clear favourite. r/NewOrleans, Aug 2025
- CaveatFound Guy's shrimp po boy mediocre from personal visits and doesn't see the hype. r/NewOrleans, Aug 2024
15.Superior Seafood, St Charles
9 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend Superior Seafood on St Charles, and a few call it a classic or dependable oyster spot. One diner praises the gumbo and shrimp brochettes, another the fried oysters and shrimp and grits, and one says the chargrilled oysters are a good pick but most other dishes disappoint. One diner calls it a good pick but not the top seafood in town.
St Charles
- RecommendsDefends Superior; says the menu isn't all great but praises its gumbo and shrimp brochettes. r/AskNOLA, Jan 2024
- MixedSays the grilled oysters are a good pick but most other menu items disappoint. r/AskNOLA, Jan 2024
16.Pascal's Manale
9 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend Pascal's Manale, and several name its barbecue shrimp, with a couple calling it the best. A few point to its oysters or oyster bar, and one suggests it for a family because the menu has plenty of seafood.
- RecommendsCalls it the original place for BBQ shrimp. r/AskNOLA, Mar 2026
17.Porgy's Seafood, Carrollton
8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Porgy's is a seafood market with a restaurant, and most diners recommend it. A couple praise its tuna muffuletta, and a couple suggest it for seafood boils, though one found the crawfish poor on two visits. One diner calls its gumbo hearty, and two were unhappy with the shrimp po-boy.
Carrollton
- RecommendsSays Porgy's seafood is excellent across preparations, its tuna muffuletta is a standout, and prefers its food to Clesi's. r/AskNOLA, Nov 2024
- CaveatHad poor crawfish at Porgy's on two visits and thinks that is simply their method. r/NewOrleans, Feb 2026
18.High Hat Cafe
7 people recommendvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Many diners recommend High Hat Cafe, and several single out its fried catfish. A couple recommend the oyster po-boy, and one says they love the gumbo. One diner calls the oyster po-boy authentic but somewhat playful in its construction.
- RecommendsSays High Hat is good among cornmeal-fried catfish spots. r/NewOrleans, Aug 2025
- MixedCalls High Hat's oyster po'boy authentic overall, but says its build is somewhat playful. r/NewOrleans, Feb 2024
19.Cochon
7 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Many diners recommend Cochon, and a few praise its oysters, including the wood-fired ones. A couple point to the redfish or the wood-fired fish, and one lists its gumbo as good.
- RecommendsNames Cochon among restaurants that make good gumbo. r/AskNOLA, Oct 2024
20.Bayou Beer Garden
7 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Diners recommend Bayou Beer Garden, and many point to its crawfish boil, which one diner found delicious. A couple mention the outdoor setting: one suggests it as an outdoor spot for crawfish and another liked the back deck and the mostly local crowd. One rates its crawfish the top option in town.
- RecommendsVisited and liked the back deck and mostly local crowd, found the crawfish boil delicious, and said a smaller single plate can be requested. r/AskNOLA, Feb 2026
21.Jack Dempsey's
7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Many diners recommend Jack Dempsey's, and a couple single out the catfish. One diner praises the grilled shrimp, one the stuffed flounder, and a couple like the gumbo. One diner who lives nearby finds it like a generic fish fry and doubts the praise.
- RecommendsSays it is hard to beat, answering the platter question directly. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2024
- CaveatLives nearby; says it tastes like a generic Midwestern fish fry and doubts the praise. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2024
22.Atchafalaya
6 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA
Many diners recommend Atchafalaya, and several praise its shrimp and grits, with one finding them delicious after a visit. One also likes its gumbo among restaurant options.
- RecommendsPoints to Atchafalaya as a place that does shrimp and grits well. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2025
23.Frady's One Stop Food Store, Bywater
6 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Diners recommend Frady's, a Bywater po-boy counter, and several name its shrimp: one calls its shrimp po-boy the best they have ever had and another a favorite for fried shrimp po-boys. One praises its oyster po-boy.
Bywater
- RecommendsExpresses enthusiasm for Frady's when it comes to seafood. r/AskNOLA, Feb 2026
24.Sidecar Patio & Oyster Bar
6 people recommendvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Diners recommend Sidecar Patio & Oyster Bar, and several rate its oysters highly, including one who is not usually an oyster fan. A few point to its wide choice of oyster varieties, and one recommends the chargrilled version.
- RecommendsPraises it as a standout oyster spot offering many unusual options. r/NewOrleans, Apr 2024
25.Herbsaint
6 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Diners recommend Herbsaint for its gumbo: one ranks it the best in the city and several others call it very good or outstanding. One diner who went found the gumbo very delicious but the setting more upscale than expected.
- RecommendsNames Herbsaint among restaurants that make good gumbo. r/AskNOLA, Oct 2024
26.Deanie's Seafood Restaurant, French Quarter
6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Deanie's has restaurants in New Orleans and Metairie, and the listing here is the French Quarter one, which a few diners name. Diners recommend it for seafood. One diner praises the crawfish balls, and one found the seafood platter greasy and soggy.
French Quarter
- RecommendsNames Deanie's as a go-to example of local-style fried seafood plates. r/AskNOLA, Jan 2025
- CaveatSays the seafood platter was greasy and soggy and calls it inedible. r/NewOrleans, Jan 2026
27.Seaworthy
5 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Diners recommend Seaworthy, and a few praise its oysters, calling them excellent or good in any season. One diner loves the vibe and sitting at the oyster bar, and one suggests it as a downtown option for raw oysters.
- RecommendsRecommends Seaworthy as a downtown option for raw oysters. r/AskNOLA, Feb 2024
28.Gabrielle Restaurant
5 people recommendvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Diners recommend Gabrielle, and several call out the gumbo: one says it is the best in town, another says the smoked gumbos are the real highlight, and one calls the seafood gumbo great. One also points to the shrimp pie, and one says the rest of the food is great too.
- RecommendsCalls this the top gumbo in town. r/NewOrleans, Jun 2024
29.Katie's Restaurant & Bar, Mid City
5 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA, r/NewOrleans
Diners recommend Katie's in Mid-City, and a few point to its chargrilled oysters, one calling them super yummy. One ranks its catfish the best they have tried so far, and one counts the crawfish beignet among their standout appetizers in town.
Mid City
- RecommendsSuggests chargrilled oysters at Katie's. r/AskNOLA, Dec 2025
30.Mandina's Restaurant
5 people recommendvia r/NewOrleans, r/AskNOLA
Many diners recommend Mandina's, and one says it has consistently satisfied their seafood cravings. One singles out the seafood gumbo and another calls the gumbo good. One suggests the trout meuniere, and one praises the shrimp po-boy.
- RecommendsSays it has consistently satisfied their seafood cravings. r/NewOrleans, Mar 2024
31.Pigeon & Whale
5 people recommendvia r/AskNOLA
Diners recommend Pigeon & Whale for seafood, and a couple praise its oysters. One praises the hot lobster roll, another points to the grilled mussels and swordfish schnitzel, and one calls the seafood amazing.
- RecommendsCalled this spot pretty good, citing its grilled mussels and swordfish schnitzel as examples. r/AskNOLA, Aug 2024
Questions people ask
- Which seafood restaurants do New Orleans locals recommend most?
- Right now the most-recommended are Felix's Restaurant & Oyster Bar, French Quarter, Parkway Bakery & Tavern and Pêche Seafood Grill, ranked by how many different people vouched for each one. Every place lists the reasons people gave and the caveats they raised, with a link to the original comment.
- How is this list made?
- It is built from public Reddit discussions — 338 comments from 293 people across r/AskNOLA and r/NewOrleans. We paraphrase why each place is recommended, keep the negatives and caveats in, and link to the original comment so you can read the source yourself. We never invent details.
- Are these paid placements?
- No. Nothing here is sponsored, paid or ranked by a business. Places are included only because real people recommended them in public conversations, and every claim links back to its source.
- How recent are these recommendations?
- This map was last refreshed November 17, 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time, so confirm current details directly before you rely on them.
Did this page answer your question?
More maps to explore
New Orleans
Places to visit
New Orleans sights and visitor stops recommended in local discussions, with the cited reasons and caveats behind each pick.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Museums
New Orleans museums recommended for their collections and visitor experience, with the original discussions behind each pick.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best brunch
New Orleans brunch recommendations, with the dishes, trade-offs and source conversations behind each place.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best bars
New Orleans bars and cocktails, including French Quarter picks, with the recommendations and caveats about drinks, crowds and getting a seat.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best cafés
New Orleans cafés and coffee stops, including City Park beignets and Canal Boulevard picks, with recommendations and the disagreements about coffee, pastries and waits.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best steak
New Orleans steak dinners, from French Quarter dining rooms to old-school steakhouses, with recommendations and caveats about cuts, sides and atmosphere.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best sushi
New Orleans sushi picks, including Carrollton Avenue restaurants, with recommendations and disagreements about rolls, portions and the meal.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best restaurants
New Orleans restaurants, from French Quarter dining to neighbourhood favourites, with recommendations and disagreements from Reddit and X.
Open the mapNew Orleans
Best breakfast
New Orleans breakfast recommendations, including beignets, café au lait and sit-down breakfasts, with the source discussions and waiting-time caveats.
Open the map