Black Magic Pizza
32 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/orlando, r/Pizza, X30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 15 threads.
What people say, in short
Many commenters recommend Black Magic Pizza, and several call it a favorite or a regular go-to. One says its specials are always interesting and its Reuben pie was a standout, and one praises it but notes there is no seating. Some commenters point out it is not strictly Neapolitan while still liking the pizza a lot. Others say it depends on the pie or does not always suit them, and one says it will not suit anyone after a very low per-pizza price.
Address
Black Magic Pizza, 121 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Black Magic Pizza, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/GatorSe7en in r/orlando · Jun 2026taste
Gives short, enthusiastic praise to Black Magic Pizza.
- Recommendsu/PapageorgiouMBO in r/orlando · Jan 2024variety
Lists it among five pizzerias worth trying, all very different.
- Recommendsu/dwaynejetski in r/orlando · Apr 2026variety
Says Black Magic's specials are always interesting; their reuben pie was a standout.
- Mixedu/PeptoBisquick in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Rates Black Magic highly, but says its pizza doesn't always suit them.
- Recommendsu/South_Ant_4170 in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Says they love Black Magic too.
- Recommendsu/MasonHere in r/orlando · May 2025
Names Black Magic as its pick for the pizza question.
- Recommendsu/Funny-Berry-807 in r/orlando · Jan 2024ambience
Phenomenal pizza, though there is no seating.
- Recommendsu/jsmithx__ in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Lists Black Magic among favorites.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/After_Lunch7662 in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Calls Black Magic a solid, enjoyable pick.
- Recommendsu/vypermajik in r/orlando · Jan 2024
Names it as a top suggestion.
- Recommendsu/bartman533 in r/orlando · Jun 2026
Lists Black Magic Pizza as one of their suggestions.
- Recommendsu/narnarqueen in r/orlando · Jan 2024variety
More brick-oven style; suggests getting one from each place for a taste test.
- Recommendsu/nsbsalt in r/orlando · Jun 2026consistency
Agrees with the parent and says it has been their regular go-to for about a year.
- Recommendsu/zaprutertape in r/orlando · May 2025taste
Has ordered their pizza repeatedly and rates it very highly.
- Recommendsu/pacemakerpaula in r/orlando · Mar 2025
Says it's pretty good in their view.
- Recommendsu/Veleax in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Calls Black Magic incredible, a treat to order.
- Caveatu/ASIWYFA in r/orlando · Aug 2025price
Says it will not suit someone who wants a very low per-pizza price.
- Recommendsu/Epic-x-lord_69 in r/orlando · Mar 2025
Recommends Black Magic Pizza as another option.
- Recommendsu/_getdiddled_ in r/orlando · Jun 2024
Says they will keep recommending Black Magic as a pizza pick.
- Recommendsu/GlockGuy13 in r/orlando · Apr 2026
Names Black Magic among their favorite spots.
- Mixedu/motherofshorkie in r/orlando · Dec 2025taste
Likes it only for certain pies; no location named.
- Recommendsu/Imaginary-Box-407 in r/orlando · May 2025taste
Calls it delicious while saying it is not Neapolitan.
- Recommendsu/Aggravating_Dog7698 in r/orlando · Mar 2025
Answers the pizza question with Black Magic Pizza and no other detail.
- Recommendsu/Gerald_the_sealion in r/Pizza · Jan 2025
Given how bad pizza is there generally, thinks this place seems worth the trip.
- Recommendsu/ThenCMacSaid in r/orlando · Aug 2025
Fully agrees with the Black Magic recommendation.
- Recommendsu/benjamin_blk in r/orlando · May 2025
Suggests Black Magic in reply to the Neapolitan question.
- Recommendsu/jcrll in r/orlando · May 2025taste
Agrees it is not Neapolitan but calls the pizza very good.
- Recommendsu/spaghettu in r/orlando · Oct 2024
Lists Black Magic as a decent spot for Neo-Neapolitan pizza.
- Recommendsu/Fault_Pretty in r/orlando · Jan 2024taste
Says it's the best but notes it's not thick crust.
- Recommends@datal0re on X · Aug 2024taste
Author calls it their favorite pizza they've had and says they've been a customer since its tent pop-up days.
More maps in Orlando, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.