Best pizza in Orlando

47 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/orlando

Many commenters recommend SoDough Square for Detroit-style pizza, and one calls the Detroit Rob City excellent. Several mention its pepperoni, including the pepperoni cups and a honey-ricotta pepperoni pie. One picks it for takeout, and one says it runs a little pricey but rarely misses. A few were less sold: one liked the cheese bread more than the pizza, one found a honey pie lacking spice, and one found it well short of a pizzeria they miss.

46 people recommend, 5 warn against itvia r/orlando

Many commenters recommend John & John's as a New York-style pick, and some mention its slices. Some who came from the New York and New Jersey area call it the closest local match to the pizza they know, and one says it holds up well for delivery or takeout. Several commenters are unconvinced: one found the sauce under-seasoned for a New York slice, one does not see the hype, one keeps choosing another spot after repeated visits, and one reports wrong orders and overly browned crusts.

32 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/orlando, r/Pizza, X

Many commenters recommend Black Magic Pizza, and several call it a favorite or a regular go-to. One says its specials are always interesting and its Reuben pie was a standout, and one praises it but notes there is no seating. Some commenters point out it is not strictly Neapolitan while still liking the pizza a lot. Others say it depends on the pie or does not always suit them, and one says it will not suit anyone after a very low per-pizza price.

25 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/orlando

Most commenters recommend Ziggie's, in Ivanhoe Village on Virginia Drive, and many are enthusiastic about the pizza. Two name the Killa Beez pie and two name Everybody Hates Pineapple. A few praise the hot honey, and two warn it runs very spicy. A couple praise the thin crust. One suggests it for visiting friends and family, and one notes a cheaper build-your-own deal on Wednesdays. One commenter found it overrated, with a long wait even after ordering ahead and a basic crust.

Ivanhoe Village

25 people recommend, 8 warn against itvia r/orlando, X

Pizza Bruno is recommended across its two Orlando shops, College Park and Curry Ford Road, and many commenters do not say which; the address listed is the College Park shop. Many commenters like it, some mention its weekday and Monday deals, and one praises the garlic knots. Several find it pricey. Some say quality varies by pie or by shop, some say it has slipped, and some find it average or overrated, while others strongly dislike it.

College Park

19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/orlando

Lazy Moon is a pizzeria with more than one shop, and most commenters do not name one; the address listed is the East Colonial Drive shop, which one commenter names. Many commenters recommend it, and a few call it a budget-friendly pick, whether for a big slice with a beer or a very large pie for a crowd. One calls its slices really special and another calls it underrated. Three commenters hold back: one found slices undercooked even after asking for extra crisp, one would not make it a top pick, and one called it standard pizza.

12 people recommendvia r/orlando, X

Many commenters recommend Nuri's Tavern, in downtown Orlando, for tavern-style pizza, and several single out the very thin, crisp crust. One calls it a change of pace, and one adds that the wings are worth ordering. One commenter ate tavern-style pizza here but cannot vouch for how authentic it is.

Downtown

11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/orlando

Many commenters recommend Pizzeria del Dio, and several describe New York-style pies. Recommendations do not always say which shop; one commenter names the East Colonial Drive shop near Fashion Square, the address listed. One says it is the closest they have found to New York and New Jersey pizza, one praises the crust and says they visit most weeks, and one calls it a hidden gem. One who loved it years ago found a recent visit poor and suspects cheaper cheese.

East Colonial and Maguire

10 people recommendvia r/orlando

Many commenters recommend Brad's Underground Pizza, and several name it for Chicago-style deep dish. A few mention its thin or tavern-style pies, and one says it is the top Chicago-style pick locally.

9 people recommendvia r/orlando

Many commenters recommend Gitto's, and most do not say which shop; two name the downtown one, the address listed. One calls it a late-night lifesaver downtown, and one with New York experience says it is the closest to that style they have found. A few mention a garlic knot with each slice, one favors the buffalo chicken and lasagna slices, and one says its lunch deals were good in the past. One finds a single slice expensive.

Downtown

8 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/orlando

Flippers is a pizzeria with more than one shop, and most commenters do not say which; the address listed is the SoDo shop, which one commenter names and calls quite good dine-in, fresh from the oven. A few call it a favorite, with one singling out the buffalo chicken pie and one the salsiccia rustica. One likes it mainly for delivery and one calls it a solid, cheaper alternative to chain pizza. Several are lukewarm: one finds it not quite New York-style, one is not a fan, one finds it okay but unremarkable, and one says their family keeps ordering it while nearby options have been lacking.

Sodo

7 people recommendvia r/orlando

Several commenters recommend Brooklyn Pizza, and a few name it for New York-style pizza. Commenters point to the Pershing Avenue and South Semoran area, where the listed shop sits; one other mentions a shop on South Cimarron. One says slices are available and one calls it awesome.

Pershing and Semoran

6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Pizza, r/orlando

Josie's is recommended by several commenters, and two name the shop on Hiawassee Road in MetroWest, the address listed. One calls it underrated, it is also called excellent, and one suggests it for anyone who wants pizza and wings in one place. One shares a pepperoni and sausage pie with extra sauce. One commenter strongly dislikes the pizza.

Metrowest

5 people recommendvia r/orlando

Several commenters recommend 1803 Pizza Kitchen, and a couple point to it as an easy walk from East End. One simply loves it. Two commenters are less sure: one calls it a coin flip, great when it is on and weaker at other times, and one who visited only in its opening week was not impressed.