The Pizza Shop, Mission
34 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 19 threads.
What people say, in short
The Pizza Shop on 24th Street attracts recommendations for a straightforward New York-style slice and comparatively good value. Diners point to cheese slices, whole pies and the pesto and cherry-pepper slice, with takeaway and delivery both mentioned positively. Its appeal is not universal: some find the crust hard or bland, one visitor disliked a flat, crunchy slice with little flavor, and others note that prices are still high despite undercutting some nearby rivals.
Address
The Pizza Shop, 3104 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94110
At a glance
- Price
- Budget
- Signature dishes
- Cheese slice, Pesto and cherry pepper slice, Large cheese pie
- Best for
- Takeaway, Delivery, Budget
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to The Pizza Shop, Mission, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/AskimbenimGT in r/AskSF · Jul 2025
Says they simply like the Pizza Shop at 24th and Folsom.
- Mixedu/PoopyPirates in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025value
Calls it a good cheaper option with nostalgia, but says the pizza is only average and not a strong endorsement.
- Caveatu/wjean in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025price
Thinks a comparable Pizza Shop slice costs far more than comparable slices in Manhattan.
- Recommendsu/AlmondJoyAdvocate in r/AskSF · Jul 2025
Names Pizza Shop on 24th as an answer.
- Recommendsu/Fickle-Pay-570 in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024
Lists this among the places they usually go for slices, based on proximity.
- Recommendsu/npeers in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024
Picks the 24th Street spot in the Mission as their top answer.
- Recommendsu/testurshit in r/AskSF · Apr 2026taste
Lists it among local spots with good pies, without further detail.
- Recommendsu/I-choochoochoose-you in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024taste
Calls it the best of the spots compared and the cheapest of them.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/pluckyhustler in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025taste
Thinks this Mission shop is the closest thing in the city to a New York slice.
- Recommendsu/Zero36 in r/AskSF · Jul 2025taste
Ranks Pizza Shop a bit higher as a purer NY-style slice.
- Recommendsu/Master_Who in r/sanfrancisco · May 2024
Uses it as a lower-priced New York-style alternative to Outta Sight.
- Caveatu/HURCANADA in r/AskSF · Jul 2025taste
Tried it after the hype; found it flat, greasy and bland.
- Recommendsu/Human_Practice8 in r/AskSF · Jul 2025
Names Pizza Shop as their answer.
- Recommendsu/comatoast- in r/sanfrancisco · May 2024taste
Thinks it sits closer to regular New York-style pizza, though another spot is better.
- Recommendsu/MaybeACultLeader in r/sanfrancisco · Dec 2025
Suggests The Pizza Shop as a Mission pick.
- Recommendsu/JonahHillsWetFart in r/sanfrancisco · Oct 2025taste
Says a decent New York-style pie can be had at places like it.
- Recommendsu/Waogamer in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025value
Endorses The Pizza Shop for fair slice pricing, allowed outside items, and as a favorite for takeout.
- Recommendsu/AttitudeOne4886 in r/AskSF · Jul 2026taste
Recommends its New York-style slices, while distinguishing it from a cozy family-style restaurant.
- Mixedu/Unclekaz06 in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025taste
Says it used to be their favorite spot, but hesitates to return after a lukewarm take.
- Recommendsu/coolpuppybob in r/AskSF · Jun 2026value
Says The Pizza Shop has good, fairly cheap thin-crust slices.
- Recommendsu/neverbeder in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024taste
Says this 24th St spot is where to find an authentic NY/NJ-style slice.
- Recommendsu/steel_wheels_rolling in r/sanfrancisco · Dec 2025value
Calls it their go-to comfort pie; doubts another city spot offers a comparable large pie at its value.
- Recommendsu/oldstalenegative in r/sanfrancisco · Oct 2025value
Says they usually grab slices here, find the cheese slice affordable, and rate the off-menu vegan pie well.
- Recommendsu/Certaeb in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025taste
Says the Pizza shop's cheese slice is the closest thing in SF to New York style.
- Recommendsu/CMTNP21 in r/AskSF · Jan 2025
Suggests a pesto and cherry-pepper slice as an option for spicy pizza.
- Recommendsu/DrBaus in r/sanfrancisco · Apr 2025taste
Names it among the few spots with good slices, while mocking the New York-themed branding.
- Recommendsu/DullVermicelli9829 in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024taste
Says they now like The Pizza Shop.
- Recommendsu/sugarwax1 in r/sanfrancisco · Jul 2024taste
Says it most resembles Arinell's and is less greasy.
- Recommendsu/Gnolls in r/AskSF · Mar 2024taste
Admits it isn't quite New Haven style, but the commenter enjoys it and it satisfies that craving.
- Recommendsu/Pure_Vermicelli693 in r/AskSF · Nov 2024consistency
Reports that its deliveries are consistently good and dependable.
More maps in San Francisco, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 10 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.