Best pizza in San Francisco

135 people recommend, 21 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/Pizza, r/AskSF, X

Tony's draws broad support for the range of pizza styles at its North Beach restaurant. Diners recommend the New Yorker and Detroit-style pies; one singles out the squash blossom and burrata pizza. The enthusiasm is not unanimous: critics describe inconsistent results, doughy or floppy crusts and pizza that falls short of the hype. Long waits and premium pricing recur as caveats, even among some fans.

North Beach

122 people recommend, 35 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/bayarea, r/AskSF

Golden Boy earns substantial support across its North Beach and Taraval shops for square slices and relative value, with garlic clam pizza a recurring recommendation. Its thick, bread-like base is a draw for fans but a drawback for diners who call it average or overrated. North Beach visitors report takeaway-only service and slices losing their crispness when wrapped; several prefer Tony's instead.

North Beach

93 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Diners recommend Outta Sight across its San Francisco shops for slices. Chinatown is specifically recommended for Peking duck pizza, and another diner reports butter chicken pizza there too, though menus can change. Happy-hour value draws praise, while regular pricing, dry crust and sweet sauce attract criticism. Some diners prefer The Pizza Shop, so the acclaim is not unanimous.

Chinatown

54 people recommend, 11 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF, r/Pizza

Diners recommend this pizzeria across its San Francisco locations mainly for deep dish. Valencia Street remains an option after the Divisadero shop's closure. Some diners praise the deep dish and thin crust, while critics dislike the cornmeal crust or find the pizza expensive. One diner preferred the former Divisadero pies after a single Valencia visit; that comparison is not a verdict on every visit.

Mission

43 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco, r/Pizza

Slice House draws strong support across its San Francisco shops, with many recommendations naming the Haight outlet. Haight diners praise both New York-style slices and Detroit-style pizza, and some suggest preordering for a large group. Others describe inconsistent quality, tough slices or pricing above nearby alternatives. A Haight diner recommends asking for a double cut because the slices are large; another backs that suggestion.

Haight

39 people recommend, 13 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Square Pie Guys draws both enthusiasm and substantial dissent across its San Francisco shops, including Mission Street and Ghirardelli Square. Diners recommend the hot honey version and The Big Von, while critics find the Detroit-style pizza ordinary, overly rich or salty. Price and value are recurring objections, including among people who still enjoy it. Not every opinion identifies which outlet the diner visited.

37 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco, r/Pizza

Cellarmaker draws strong support for Detroit-style pizza, including at its Mission Street House of Pizza. Diners also praise its beer; individual recommendations include the tavern-style pie and a red top pizza with pesto on the side when available. The pizza is not universally loved: a Mission visitor liked the space but was not impressed by the pie, and other comments describe it as pricey or richer than they wanted.

Mission

37 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/Pizza, r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Capo's attracts recommendations for both deep dish and its cracker-thin, tavern-style pizza. Several diners particularly like the thin crust, while another praises the pan-style pie. Diners also mention the atmosphere. Caveats differ by taste: a visitor found the food too sweet and tomato-heavy, while another describes the deep dish as heavy and pricey.

North Beach

34 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

The Pizza Shop on 24th Street attracts recommendations for a straightforward New York-style slice and comparatively good value. Diners point to cheese slices, whole pies and the pesto and cherry-pepper slice, with takeaway and delivery both mentioned positively. Its appeal is not universal: some find the crust hard or bland, one visitor disliked a flat, crunchy slice with little flavor, and others note that prices are still high despite undercutting some nearby rivals.

Mission

32 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/Pizza, r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco, X

Flour + Water's North Beach pizzeria draws recommendations for whole pies and the big slice sold from its back storefront. One North Beach diner praises the thin crust, while others like the slice's crisp cheese edges. One diner prefers the pizza at the brand's Mission restaurant, another finds the pies less impressive than its pasta, and slice pricing is a recurring caveat. Commenters also disagree over how closely the pies fit Neapolitan style.

North Beach

32 people recommend, 4 warn against itcounted across its outletsvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Diners recommend Goat Hill across its San Francisco outlets for sourdough crust. Individual diners recommend the Porky Pie and Hawaiian Roast without identifying an outlet for those orders. Some describe the brand as dependable neighborhood pizza rather than a destination meal, while others actively dislike it or find it overhyped. Price increases also come up in the discussion; the different outlets should not be assumed to offer identical experiences.

Potrero Hill

31 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF, r/Pizza

Gioia is a recurring slice recommendation, with its Hayes Valley shop explicitly praised for New York-style pizza. One diner recommends its acciughe pizza there. The overall discussion is positive, but not every endorsement calls it the city's best: a Hayes Valley regular describes it as a reliable personal go-to rather than the top pick, and another diner prefers Golden Boy's clam slice while still liking Gioia.

Hayes

31 people recommend, 16 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/Pizza, r/AskSF

Joyride attracts both strong praise and substantial criticism across its San Francisco shops, including a recommendation for the Embarcadero location. Fans praise its Detroit-style pizza for the flavors, crisp edges and range of toppings, though not everyone identifies an outlet. Critics question the value, describe portions as small or bready, or find it overhyped; one diner finds it too salty. Other diners prefer Square Pie Guys or Cellarmaker.

29 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Long Bridge is a frequent Dogpatch recommendation, with diners praising its crust, cheese pizza and Hot & Honey pie. One diner suggests getting pizza to go for a nearby park. Other comments recommend its occasional Detroit-style special, though menus can change. Caveats center on cost and personal preference: some now find it an expensive treat, one says the crust loses its appeal after cooling, and another finds it fine rather than memorable.

Dogpatch

25 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Za Pizza on Hyde Street receives repeated recommendations, including from diners who name Russian Hill explicitly. One diner praises its seasonal peach slice, and another suggests it to someone seeking a denser, crispier crust. The positive pizza opinions coexist with practical reservations: one fan says reaching the shop by phone is difficult, while another describes a disappointing ordering and delivery experience.

Russian Hill

25 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Pizza Hacker draws recommendations for its sourdough-style crust, with one diner singling out the margherita. A regular describes it as a place where they can often walk in and sit down, rather than establishing a seating guarantee. Price increases and small, thin pies are recurring caveats, especially for family takeaway. Another regular still likes the pizza but says the crust does not match the particularly chewy style they were seeking.

Mission

21 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Zante's is repeatedly recommended for Indian-style pizza, with praise for its seasoning and specific mentions of paneer masala pizza and Indian pizza with tikka masala sauce. Takeaway and the restaurant's own delivery are both mentioned. The enthusiasm includes caveats: one longstanding customer reports a less satisfying taste recently, and another found recent orders under-seasoned while still liking the crust. One diner prefers takeout to the dining room.

21 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco, r/bayarea

Pie Punks draws recommendations for both its grandma pie and Detroit-style pizza. Diners praise the grandma slice, one visitor describes the Detroit-style pie as among their favorites after repeated visits, and another likes the crisp crust. A visitor also recommends it as a lunchtime pizza-and-beer stop. Some diners prefer it to Golden Boy.

21 people recommend, 1 warns against itcounted across its outletsvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco, r/Pizza

Diners recommend Il Casaro across its San Francisco branches, including North Beach. They praise its Neapolitan-style pizza, including the Diavola and Bufalina; one person who visited both branches finds North Beach brighter and livelier. Some also suggest it as an alternative to waiting at Tony's, not a guarantee of immediate seating. Dissent remains: one former fan reports declining quality, and another dislikes it personally despite acknowledging its value and specials.

North Beach

21 people recommend, 3 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Uncle Vito's appeals to diners seeking an old-school pie, with returning customers praising it and individual recommendations for the Greek pie and pesto chicken slices. One regular particularly likes the sweet tomato sauce, while another describes the place as pleasant rather than fancy. Dissent includes complaints about thick or bland crust, unremarkable cheese and pizza that simply is not to the diner's taste. Some favorable memories are historical rather than recent visits.

19 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Damn Fine is repeatedly recommended for pizza in the Outer Sunset. Diners praise its Neapolitan-style pies, and one specifically recommends the white-sauce Pig in the Woods and Mushroom Dream pizzas. A visitor also likes the cocktails and appetizers in a sit-down restaurant setting. The praise is not unanimous: one diner found the pizza mediocre and another was underwhelmed, even while agreeing with other recommendations in the same discussion.

Sunset

17 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF, r/bayarea

Escape from New York has supporters across its San Francisco shops, with Haight specifically recommended. Potato pizzas are a recurring pick, and some diners suggest it for a quick slice or a group order. Others find it bland, prefer nearby Slice House or consider the garlic excessive. Comments mention late-night pizza and the business's own delivery, though one advises checking whether that delivery arrangement still applies.

Haight

16 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

The Laundromat in the Outer Richmond attracts recommendations for Detroit-style pizza. One diner names the mushroom and sausage-and-peppers pies as favorites, and another particularly likes the vegan pizza. The crisp crust is not universally liked: a critic finds it too hard and not airy enough, while another advises choosing elsewhere. A fan also says their pizza was not hot enough when served, and cost comes up as a caveat.

Outer Richmond

15 people recommend, 7 warn against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Diners recommend Pasquale's across its San Francisco shops, including Irving Street in the Inner Sunset. One praises its thinner, East Coast-style crust, while others like its takeaway convenience. An Inner Sunset fan recommends both dining in and takeout while distinguishing it from Sloat. Critics call the pizza cafeteria-like or merely average. A Sloat visitor found that branch expensive.

Sunset

14 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Many people recommend Giorgio's on Clement Street in the Inner Richmond, and two visitors point to it as an old-school, classic-looking spot. One diner who ate a lot of New York-style pies and slices says its basic pies offer that same profile, and another diner says its slices look made with extra care. One diner who ordered a pie with broccoli and eggplant added says the vegetables give it a nice crunch.

Richmond

13 people recommend, 4 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Patxi's draws recommendations for deep dish, including from Hayes Valley diners, although not every comment identifies an outlet. Some compare it favorably with Chicago pizza, and one particularly likes the roasted garlic and layered pepperoni. Others prefer a local deep-dish rival or say the chain has declined. Hayes Valley's setting also divides opinion, with one favorable comparison of its dining room and another complaint about the flow of delivery pickups.

Hayes Valley

13 people recommend, 6 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Jules has supporters for its pizza and small plates, but the discussion is notably divided. A diner likes the crisper base from a longer bake, while others describe the pies as good without ranking them among the city's best. Critics find them too oily, salty, saucy or soft, and some consider the hype excessive for the price. These reservations recur alongside repeat visitors who have enjoyed their meals.

12 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Pink Onion receives recommendations for its thin-crust pizza, with individual diners praising the margherita, a spicy pie and the vegan cheese. One occasional visitor describes it as a gourmet-style alternative to their usual pizza spots. The overall discussion is favorable, but a diner who tried it among several local pizzerias felt something was missing, and the margherita fan is less enthusiastic about the rest of the food.

11 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Diners recommend Fiorella's pizza across its San Francisco restaurants, including the Inner Sunset outlet. Individual comments praise the soft, toasted crust, Salsiccia pie and a summer sweet-corn special, without identifying the outlet for those orders. Seasonal menus can change. An Inner Sunset diner prefers the pasta and is not enthusiastic about the pizza, so the branch's reception is not uniformly positive.

Inner Sunset

10 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Hi Hat in the Mission earns recommendations for New York-style pizza. One diner calls it a personal favorite, another sees it as a strong alternative to other slice shops, and another particularly likes its crust and topping combinations. A customer recommends adding garlic confit to a slice. A visitor reports enjoying the food on a work trip. A diner who likes the pizza nevertheless finds it expensive.

Mission

10 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Pizzetta is repeatedly recommended as a California-style or gourmet pizza option in the Richmond. One diner particularly enjoys its margherita with white anchovy and also likes the rest of the menu. Another suggests it for a more intimate meal, while a commenter calls the Richmond shop a top local choice.

9 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Beretta's pizza recommendations include the Carbonara and Bartender's Special, with diners also mentioning thin crust. Not every diner identifies a San Francisco outlet. The discussion includes reservations as well as praise: two diners describe the pizza as only decent, and one would choose Doppio Zero for the crust style they wanted. Those comments are about preference, not a uniform judgment against the restaurant.

Mission

7 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Sforno in Hayes Valley earns recommendations for Neapolitan-style pizza and its crust. Two diners compare their experience favorably with pizza in Italy or Naples, and one specifically mentions pizza portafoglio. One diner also praises its value relative to other local options. A diner who likes the crust still finds the traditional topping choices limited for their preferences, and another points out that this style will not suit every pizza request.

Hayes Valley

7 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Marcello's in the Castro receives recommendations for slices, including praise for its sauce and relative value. Some endorsements are recollections rather than recent visits. One diner who dislikes the area's pizza choices still prefers Marcello's deep dish among them; another considers Slice House better but more expensive. A separate comparison calls Marcello's underrated while preferring Outta Sight. The discussion does not make it an uncontested New York-style favorite.

Castro

7 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Tommaso's on Kearny Street in North Beach receives several direct pizza recommendations. One diner calls it a personal go-to, another values it as a distinctly local experience, and a commenter seeking an old-school red-sauce setting includes it among their picks. The available recommendations emphasize the place and atmosphere more than individual toppings, so there is no source-supported signature dish singled out here.

North Beach

7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Gusto Pinsa Romana attracts recommendations for its pizza, including individual mentions of the Margherita and Diavola. A diner who tried the Margherita says they would return, while another says they have enjoyed several different pies. One commenter also recommends the Napoli pinsa. The positive views coexist with a clear dissenting voice: a former nearby resident reports repeated disappointing pizza orders.

7 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Delfina draws recommendations for Neapolitan-style pizza across San Francisco, though diners often use the shorthand name without identifying an outlet. Some recommend it for a simple margherita or as another Neapolitan option. Positive suggestions coexist with a specific criticism of a crust that one diner finds hard and dry. The Mission pizzeria should be distinguished from the restaurant when checking menus and takeaway choices.

Mission

7 people recommend, 2 warn against itvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Diners recommend Che Fico across its San Francisco restaurant and pizzeria locations, with several praising the pizza or naming it among their favorites. The Divisadero restaurant should be distinguished from the pizzeria by Chase Center: comments about outdoor seating and bay views concern the latter. Reservations about the brand include added fees and a disappointing experience arriving without a reservation, rather than a uniform verdict on every visit.

Divisadero

6 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Diners recommend Seniore's across San Francisco, including the Sunset, with praise for the sauce, chicken garlic pizza and a Hawaiian slice. One recommends it for late-night pizza, and another reports enjoying delivery, though they do not all identify an outlet. A commenter who liked the business would nevertheless order its burger before its slices, so not every favorable mention is equally strong support for the pizza.

6 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Gaspare's in the Richmond receives several pizza recommendations, including from diners seeking a traditional red-sauce setting or a cheesy pie. One commenter calls it delicious alongside other Richmond pizzerias, and another says it would be their choice in the area. An additional diner suggests it when asked about gluten-free pizza; anyone with dietary requirements should confirm the current ingredients and preparation directly.

Richmond

6 people recommendvia r/AskSF

Victor's on Polk Street is recommended by several diners, including one who describes the pizza as bready rather than New York style. Two commenters prefer it to other pizza choices on that street, while another says it was good for its style but has not tried the nearby alternatives. One customer also praises the speed of delivery.

Polk St Nob Hill

6 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

The Pizza Place on Noriega receives several recommendations, including as an alternative to bringing a pizza oven to Ocean Beach. One diner praises its thin-crust vegan pizza, and another enthusiastically recommends the Spiccoli pizza. A customer who compares it with Arinell's says the base is a little thicker but still likes it. These recommendations are about buying its pizza, not a general preference against making pizza at home.

Noriega

6 people recommendvia r/AskSF

Serrano's is recommended for large slices and value rather than universally described as the city's best pizza. Two diners explicitly frame it as a strong slice choice for the money while acknowledging better pizza elsewhere. Other commenters describe it as a regular delivery order, and one advises ordering through the restaurant's website. These are customer reports, not a guarantee about current delivery arrangements or service times.

6 people recommend, 1 warns against itvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Cybelle's Front Room on Ninth Avenue is recommended by diners discussing vegan pizza and delivery. One customer specifically praises its dairy-free pizza, while another suggests asking for a well-done bake to approach a crisper style. The discussion is not uniformly positive: another diner feels the pizza loses its appeal quickly after serving.

5 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Pizzetta Napoletana is recommended under both its current name and its former Kezar Pizzetta name. Diners suggest it for local pizza, with one calling it very good and praising the wood-fired oven, and another saying they love it. A comparison of Richmond and Sunset pizzerias also counts it as a strength for the broader Sunset area. These comments concern the Frederick Street business, not Pizzetta in the Richmond.

5 people recommendvia r/AskSF, r/sanfrancisco

Gialina in Glen Park receives several pizza recommendations, including a diner who calls it fancy and delicious and suggests arriving by BART. Another considers it a nearby alternative to Pizza Hacker at a similar price level while explicitly saying the pizzas are not equivalent. Other comments name it among strong San Francisco options or simply say they like it. The available evidence does not single out a signature topping.

Glen Park

5 people recommendvia r/sanfrancisco, r/AskSF

Little Original Joe's in West Portal receives recommendations for slices and value. A diner specifically praises the West Portal slices, while others also like its slices or list it among preferred pizza options. Another suggests its weekend breakfast pizza, though menus can change. These are suggestions for Little Original Joe's, rather than the similarly named Little Joe's on Mission Street.

West Portal