Big Mario's, Capitol Hill

Found the pizza decent but slightly overdone and unremarkable, with a price it judged acceptable.

Calls Big Mario's the worst, saying it tastes bad even when drunk.

Ranks Big Mario's third among local picks, with the local scene seen as expensive and unremarkable.

Ordered a Spicoli without pineapple, got it with pineapple anyway, and thought that was fair.

Calls it not amazing pizza overall, yet praises its New York slice as a late-night favorite.

Says it offers the cup pepperoni style and rates the pizza pretty good.

Warned others off.

Says they like this place's pizza and calls themselves an oddball for it.

Rates the nearby Mario's well below A Pizza Mart.

Complains a cheese slice there was dried out and overpriced.

Says Big Mario's crust is less floppy, but its flavors don't match Slicebox.

Former New Yorker says it's easy to beat in NY and advises skipping it.

Suggests dropping it unless someone wants a late-night slice.

Says they don't think much of it, even compared with other local pizza options.

Says Big Mario's consistently keeps a vegan slice on offer.

Says they're more into the bread-bowl clam chowder pie from Big Mario's than the taco pizza.

Surprised it gets little praise; finds it fairly authentic with generous slices.

Says the Fremont location is always solid.

Says Big Mario's is sometimes a favorite pizza place.

Reports consistently good results at Big Mario's, calling it cheap and dependable, though not New York-level.

Suggests this for New York-style pizza.

Relays that their East Coast-raised partner likes the place; the commenter gives no firsthand view.