Dino's Tomato Pie, Capitol Hill
33 people recommend, 8 warn against itvia r/Seattle, r/AskSeattle, r/SeattleWA30 comments cited below
The comments cited below are a sample of the full tally across 13 threads.
What people say, in short
Most commenters recommend Dino's Tomato Pie, and many name it as their pick, including two who call it the only standout slice they have found. Some single out the square pies, and some say it is not true New York style but close. Results are uneven for some diners: some report burnt pizza, and others slices that fell apart or looked left out too long.
Address
Dino's Tomato Pie, 1524 E Olive Wy, Seattle, WA 98122
At a glance
- Signature dishes
- Square style pie
- Opinions divided
- Yes
Nearby on this map
Other places on this map closest to Dino's Tomato Pie, Capitol Hill, as the crow flies.
The evidence
Every point below is paraphrased from a real public comment, ordered by how much the community engaged with it. Caveats and negatives are kept in — follow any link to read the original for yourself.
- Recommendsu/TonyTheEvil in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
Recently visited Dino's and came away very impressed.
- Recommendsu/SnooStrawberries6934 in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Ranks Dino's just behind Post Alley for them, though not truly NY-style.
- Recommendsu/bstroszek in r/Seattle · Apr 2025
Lists this among local pizzerias they rate above the pizza in the post.
- Recommendsu/HarmNHammer in r/Seattle · May 2025
Long-time city resident who calls Dino's the sole standout pizza they've found in town.
- Recommendsu/MickDubble in r/SeattleWA · Oct 2026
Lists this Capitol Hill spot among the local pizza options worth trying.
- Recommendsu/ryan0702 in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
On Capitol Hill, says Dino's is essentially the only slice that stands out as good.
- Mixedu/Justwatchinitallgoby in r/Seattle · May 2025consistency
Describes Dino's results as inconsistent, with both good and poor outings.
- Recommendsu/cubity in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026
Gives this name as their answer.
Show all 30 cited comments
- Recommendsu/The_Bababillionaire in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026taste
Loves it; says it's not exactly New York style but close and tasty.
- Recommendsu/SunlightNStars in r/AskSeattle · Aug 2026taste
Listed among local pizza places better than the one they advise skipping.
- Recommendsu/tadddpole in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Seconds the pick of Dino's.
- Recommendsu/Dependent_Knee_369 in r/Seattle · May 2025
Says Dino's is the way to go.
- Recommendsu/Religion_Failed_Us in r/AskSeattle · Nov 2026
Says they like it, alongside two other places.
- Recommendsu/TheNonExample in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026
Calls it cool and says its hours are reasonable.
- Caveatu/backlikeclap in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026consistency
Two recent visits gave slices that fell apart and lacked charring; stopped going, price not worth it.
- Caveatu/devnullopinions in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
On a past visit found excessive breading on the pizza.
- Caveatu/olythrowaway4 in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
Had a poor pizza there and suspects it was an off night.
- Caveatu/Which-Adhesiveness44 in r/AskSeattle · Jun 2026consistency
Adds that slices sometimes look left out far too long.
- Recommendsu/Garbanzo_Beanie in r/Seattle · Jan 2026taste
Calls it a rare treat, usually ordering a square during their happy hour.
- Recommendsu/GreenRainier253 in r/SeattleWA · Nov 2025
Seconds the parent's Dino's pick.
- Recommendsu/5MileBurrito in r/SeattleWA · Jun 2025taste
Lists Dino's and says they love the Mr. Pink.
- Recommendsu/Maleficent-Trifle118 in r/Seattle · May 2025
Says Dino's is the obvious pick for this question.
- Caveatu/tastypoopies in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
One visit ended with a burned pizza bottom; says they would consider returning for another try.
- Caveatu/vietnams666 in r/Seattle · May 2025taste
Says Dino's pizza is consistently dry and burnt.
- Recommendsu/durbblurb in r/Seattle · May 2025
Calls Dino's a safe pick and says they love the spot.
- Recommendsu/Minormeow in r/AskSeattle · Apr 2025taste
Recommends this spot for square pies with crispy pepperoni.
- Recommendsu/90s_kids_only in r/Seattle · Mar 2024taste
Says Dino's in Capitol Hill is pretty good.
- Recommendsu/DannyMyDevito in r/Seattle · Jul 2025
Ranks Dino's as their top pizza in the city.
- Recommendsu/iranmeba in r/Seattle · May 2025
Simply agrees with the Dino's recommendation above.
- Recommendsu/Shrimmmmmpuh in r/AskSeattle · Oct 2024taste
Calls Dino's a regular go-to for a classic thin style; says it is in Capitol Hill.
More maps in Seattle, United States
Did this page answer your question?
Freshness
Details last checked 13 Nov 2026. Recommendations reflect what people said at the time; confirm current details before you go.